Hamilton's optico-mechanical analogy

Last updated

Hamiltonian Optics--Rays and Wavefronts Hamiltonian Optics-Rays and Wavefronts.svg
Hamiltonian Optics—Rays and Wavefronts

Hamilton's optico-mechanical analogy is a conceptual parallel between trajectories in classical mechanics and wavefronts in optics, introduced by William Rowan Hamilton around 1831. [1] It may be viewed as linking Huygens' principle of optics with Maupertuis' principle of mechanics. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]

Contents

While Hamilton discovered the analogy in 1831, it was not applied practically until Hans Busch used it to explain electron beam focusing in 1925. [7] According to Cornelius Lanczos, the analogy has been important in the development of ideas in quantum physics. [3] Erwin Schrödinger cites the analogy in the very first sentence of his paper introducing his wave mechanics. [8] Later in the body of his paper he says:

Unfortunately this powerful and momentous conception of Hamilton is deprived, in most modern reproductions, of its beautiful raiment as a superfluous accessory, in favour of a more colourless representation of the analytical correspondence. [9]

Quantitative and formal analysis based on the analogy use the Hamilton–Jacobi equation; conversely the analogy provides an alternative and more accessible path for introducing the Hamilton–Jacobi equation approach to mechanics. The orthogonality of mechanical trajectories characteristic of geometrical optics to the optical wavefronts characteristic of a full wave equation, resulting from the variational principle, leads to the corresponding differential equations. [10]

Hamilton's analogy

The propagation of light can be considered in terms of rays and wavefronts in ordinary physical three-dimensional space. The wavefronts are two-dimensional curved surfaces; the rays are one-dimensional curved lines. [11] Hamilton's analogy amounts to two interpretations of a figure like the one shown here. In the optical interpretation, the green wavefronts are lines of constant phase and the orthogonal red lines are the rays of geometrical optics. In the mechanical interpretation, the green lines denote constant values of action derived by applying Hamilton's principle to mechanical motion and the red lines are the orthogonal object trajectories. [11]

The orthogonality of the wavefronts to rays (or equal-action surfaces to trajectories) means we can compute one set from the other set. [10] This explains how Kirchhoff's diffraction formula predicts a wave phenomenon – diffraction – using only geometrical ray tracing. [7] : 745  Rays traced from the source to an aperture give a wavefront that becomes sources for rays reaching the diffraction pattern where they are summed using complex phases from the orthogonal wavefronts.

The wavefronts and rays or the equal-action surfaces and trajectories are dual objects linked by orthogonality. [10] On one hand, a ray can be regarded as the orbit of a particle of light. It successively punctures the wave surfaces. The successive punctures can be regarded as defining the trajectory of the particle. On the other hand, a wave-front can be regarded as a level surface of displacement of some quantity, such as electric field intensity, hydrostatic pressure, particle number density, oscillatory phase, or probability amplitude. Then the physical meaning of the rays is less evident. [12]

Huygen's principle; Fermat's principle

The Hamilton optico-mechanical analogy is closely related to Fermat's principle and thus to the Huygens–Fresnel principle. [10] Fermat's principle states that the rays between wavefronts will take the path least time; the concept of successive wavefronts derives from Huygens principle.

Extended Huygens' principle

Going beyond ordinary three-dimensional physical space, one can imagine a higher dimensional abstract configuration "space", with a dimension a multiple of 3. In this space, one can imagine again rays as one-dimensional curved lines. Now the wavefronts are hypersurfaces of dimension one less than the dimension of the space. [6] Such a multi-dimensional space can serve as a configuration space for a multi-particle system.

Classical limit of the Schrödinger equation

Albert Messiah considers a classical limit of the Schrödinger equation. He finds there an optical analogy. The trajectories of his particles are orthogonal to the surfaces of equal phase. He writes "In the language of optics, the latter are the wave fronts, and the trajectories of the particles are the rays. Hence the classical approximation is equivalent to the geometric optics approximation: we find once again, as a consequence of the Schrödinger equation, the basic postulate of the theory of matter waves." [13]

History

Hamilton's optico-mechanical analogy played a critical part [14] [11] in the thinking of Schrödinger, one of the originators of quantum mechanics. Section 1 of his paper published in December 1926 is titled "The Hamiltonian analogy between mechanics and optics". [15] Section 1 of the first of his four lectures on wave mechanics delivered in 1928 is titled "Derivation of the fundamental idea of wave mechanics from Hamilton's analogy between ordinary mechanics and geometrical optics". [16]

In a brief paper in 1923, de Broglie wrote : "Dynamics must undergo the same evolution that optics has undergone when undulations took the place of purely geometrical optics." [17] In his 1924 thesis, though Louis de Broglie did not name the optico-mechanical analogy, he wrote in his introduction, [18]

... a single principle, that of Maupertuis, and later in another form as Hamilton's Principle of least action ... Fermat's ... principle ..., which nowadays is usually called the principle of least action. ... Huygens propounded an undulatory theory of light, while Newton, calling on an analogy with the material point dynamics that he created, developed a corpuscular theory, the so-called "emission theory", which enabled him even to explain, albeit with a contrived hypothesis, effects nowadays considered wave effects, (i.e., Newton's rings).

In the opinion of Léon Rosenfeld, a close colleague of Niels Bohr, "... Schrödinger [was] inspired by Hamilton's beautiful comparison of classical mechanics and geometrical optics ..." [19]

The first textbook in English on wave mechanics [20] devotes the second of its two chapters to "Wave mechanics in relation to ordinary mechanics". It opines "... de Broglie and Schrödinger have turned this false analogy into a true one by using the natural Unit or Measure of Action, h, .... ... We must now go into Hamilton's theory in more detail, for when once its true meaning is grasped the step to wave mechanics is but a short one—indeed now, after the event, almost seems to suggest itself." [21]

According to one textbook, "The first part of our problem, namely, the establishment of a system of first-order equations satisfying the spacetime symmetry condition, can be solved in a very simple way, with the help of the analogy between mechanics and optics, which was the starting point for the development of wave mechanics and which can still be used—with reservations—as a source of inspiration." [22]

Recently the concept has been extended to wavelength dependent regime. [23]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diffraction</span> Phenomenon of the motion of waves

Diffraction is the interference or bending of waves around the corners of an obstacle or through an aperture into the region of geometrical shadow of the obstacle/aperture. The diffracting object or aperture effectively becomes a secondary source of the propagating wave. Italian scientist Francesco Maria Grimaldi coined the word diffraction and was the first to record accurate observations of the phenomenon in 1660.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Double-slit experiment</span> Physics experiment, showing light and matter can be modelled by both waves and particles

In modern physics, the double-slit experiment demonstrates that light and matter can satisfy the seemingly-incongruous classical definitions for both waves and particles, which is considered evidence for the fundamentally probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics. This type of experiment was first performed by Thomas Young in 1801, as a demonstration of the wave behavior of visible light. At that time it was thought that light consisted of either waves or particles. With the beginning of modern physics, about a hundred years later, it was realized that light could in fact show both wave and particle characteristics. In 1927, Davisson and Germer and, independently George Paget Thomson and Alexander Reid demonstrated that electrons show the same behavior, which was later extended to atoms and molecules. Thomas Young's experiment with light was part of classical physics long before the development of quantum mechanics and the concept of wave–particle duality. He believed it demonstrated that Christiaan Huygens' wave theory of light was correct, and his experiment is sometimes referred to as Young's experiment or Young's slits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Huygens–Fresnel principle</span> Method of analysis

The Huygens–Fresnel principle states that every point on a wavefront is itself the source of spherical wavelets, and the secondary wavelets emanating from different points mutually interfere. The sum of these spherical wavelets forms a new wavefront. As such, the Huygens-Fresnel principle is a method of analysis applied to problems of luminous wave propagation both in the far-field limit and in near-field diffraction as well as reflection.

The mathematical formulations of quantum mechanics are those mathematical formalisms that permit a rigorous description of quantum mechanics. This mathematical formalism uses mainly a part of functional analysis, especially Hilbert spaces, which are a kind of linear space. Such are distinguished from mathematical formalisms for physics theories developed prior to the early 1900s by the use of abstract mathematical structures, such as infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, and operators on these spaces. In brief, values of physical observables such as energy and momentum were no longer considered as values of functions on phase space, but as eigenvalues; more precisely as spectral values of linear operators in Hilbert space.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Optics</span> Branch of physics that studies light

Optics is the branch of physics that studies the behaviour and properties of light, including its interactions with matter and the construction of instruments that use or detect it. Optics usually describes the behaviour of visible, ultraviolet, and infrared light. Because light is an electromagnetic wave, other forms of electromagnetic radiation such as X-rays, microwaves, and radio waves exhibit similar properties.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quantum mechanics</span> Description of physical properties at the atomic and subatomic scale

Quantum mechanics is a fundamental theory in physics that describes the behavior of nature at the scale of atoms and subatomic particles. It is the foundation of all quantum physics including quantum chemistry, quantum field theory, quantum technology, and quantum information science.

Wave–particle duality is the concept in quantum mechanics that quantum entities exhibit particle or wave properties according to the experimental circumstances. It expresses the inability of the classical concepts such as particle or wave to fully describe the behavior of quantum objects. During the 19th and early 20th centuries, light was found to behave as a wave, and then later discovered to have a particulate character, whereas electrons were found to act as particles, and then later discovered to have wavelike aspects. The concept of duality arose to name these contradictions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fermat's principle</span> Principle of least time

Fermat's principle, also known as the principle of least time, is the link between ray optics and wave optics. Fermat's principle states that the path taken by a ray between two given points is the path that can be traveled in the least time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louis de Broglie</span> Nobel Laureate physicist (1892–1987)

Louis Victor Pierre Raymond, 7th Duc de Broglie was a French physicist and aristocrat who made groundbreaking contributions to quantum theory. In his 1924 PhD thesis, he postulated the wave nature of electrons and suggested that all matter has wave properties. This concept is known as the de Broglie hypothesis, an example of wave–particle duality, and forms a central part of the theory of quantum mechanics.

The de Broglie–Bohm theory, also known as the pilot wave theory, Bohmian mechanics, Bohm's interpretation, and the causal interpretation, is an interpretation of quantum mechanics. It postulates that in addition to the wavefunction, an actual configuration of particles exists, even when unobserved. The evolution over time of the configuration of all particles is defined by a guiding equation. The evolution of the wave function over time is given by the Schrödinger equation. The theory is named after Louis de Broglie (1892–1987) and David Bohm (1917–1992).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schrödinger equation</span> Description of a quantum-mechanical system

The Schrödinger equation is a linear partial differential equation that governs the wave function of a quantum-mechanical system. Its discovery was a significant landmark in the development of quantum mechanics. It is named after Erwin Schrödinger, who postulated the equation in 1925 and published it in 1926, forming the basis for the work that resulted in his Nobel Prize in Physics in 1933.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wave function</span> Mathematical description of the quantum state of a system

In quantum physics, a wave function, is a mathematical description of the quantum state of an isolated quantum system. The most common symbols for a wave function are the Greek letters ψ and Ψ. Wave functions are composed of complex numbers. For example, a wave function might assign a complex number to each point in a region of space. The Born rule provides the means to turn these complex probability amplitudes into actual probabilities. In one common form, it says that the squared modulus of a wave function that depends upon position is the probability density of measuring a particle as being at a given place. The integral of a wavefunction's squared modulus over all the system's degrees of freedom must be equal to 1, a condition called normalization. Since the wave function is complex-valued, only its relative phase and relative magnitude can be measured; its value does not, in isolation, tell anything about the magnitudes or directions of measurable observables. One has to apply quantum operators, whose eigenvalues correspond to sets of possible results of measurements, to the wave function ψ and calculate the statistical distributions for measurable quantities.

Matter waves are a central part of the theory of quantum mechanics, being half of wave–particle duality. All matter exhibits wave-like behavior. For example, a beam of electrons can be diffracted just like a beam of light or a water wave.

The stationary-action principle – also known as the principle of least action – is a variational principle that, when applied to the action of a mechanical system, yields the equations of motion for that system. The principle states that the trajectories are stationary points of the system's action functional.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pilot wave theory</span> One interpretation of quantum mechanics

In theoretical physics, the pilot wave theory, also known as Bohmian mechanics, was the first known example of a hidden-variable theory, presented by Louis de Broglie in 1927. Its more modern version, the de Broglie–Bohm theory, interprets quantum mechanics as a deterministic theory, avoiding troublesome notions such as wave–particle duality, instantaneous wave function collapse, and the paradox of Schrödinger's cat. To solve these problems, the theory is inherently nonlocal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wavefront</span> Locus of points at equal phase in a wave

In physics, the wavefront of a time-varying wave field is the set (locus) of all points having the same phase. The term is generally meaningful only for fields that, at each point, vary sinusoidally in time with a single temporal frequency.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electron optics</span> Electron trajectories in electromagnetic fields

Electron optics is a mathematical framework for the calculation of electron trajectories in the presence of electromagnetic fields. The term optics is used because magnetic and electrostatic lenses act upon a charged particle beam similarly to optical lenses upon a light beam.

In physics, a variational principle is an alternative method for determining the state or dynamics of a physical system, by identifying it as an extremum of a function or functional. Variational methods are exploited in many modern software to simulate matter and light.

The history of quantum mechanics is a fundamental part of the history of modern physics. The major chapters of this history begin with the emergence of quantum ideas to explain individual phenomena -- blackbody radiation, the photoelectric effect, solar emission spectra -- an era called the Old or Older quantum theories. Building on the technology developed in classical mechanics, the invention of wave mechanics by Erwin Schrödinger and expanded by many others triggers the "modern" era beginning around 1925. Paul Dirac's relativistic quantum theory work lead him to explore quantum theories of radiation, culminating in quantum electrodynamics, the first quantum field theory. The history of quantum mechanics continues in the history of quantum field theory. The history of quantum chemistry, theoretical basis of chemical structure, reactivity, and bonding, interlaces with the events discussed in this article.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Branches of physics</span> Overview of the branches of physics

Physics is a scientific discipline that seeks to construct and experimentally test theories of the physical universe. These theories vary in their scope and can be organized into several distinct branches, which are outlined in this article.

References

  1. ↑ Hamilton, W.R., (1834).
  2. ↑ Kemble, E.C. (1937), pp. 7–10.
  3. 1 2 Lanczos, C. (1949/1970). Lanczos wrote on p. 136: "[Maupertuis] ... thus pointed to that remarkable analogy between optical and mechanical phenomena which was observed much earlier by John Bernoulli and which was later fully developed in Hamilton's ingenious optico-mechanical theory. This analogy played a fundamental role in the development of modern wave-mechanics."
  4. ↑ Synge, J.L. (1954). On p. 2, Synge writes: "... the analogy between Newtonian mechanics and geometrical optics is completed only when we supplement the former by thinking of waves in association with the paths of particles. This completion was actually present in Hamilton's theory, since he made it so wide as to include both corpuscular and wave theories of light, and in the former interpretation his surfaces of constant action are the waves in question. Thus, since the time of Hamilton we have actually had what might be called 'Newtonian geometrical mechanics', based on the principle of Maupertuis, δ ∫v ds = 0, where v is given in terms of energy by mv2/2 = E − V."
  5. ↑ Messiah, A. (1961), pp. 53–55.
  6. 1 2 Arnold, V.I. (1974/1978), p. 252.
  7. 1 2 Born, Max; Wolf, Emil (1993). Principles of optics: electromagnetic theory of propagation, interference and diffraction of light (6. ed., reprinted (with corrections) ed.). Oxford: Pergamon Press. ISBN   978-0-08-026481-3.
  8. ↑ Schrödinger, E. (1926/1928), p. ix.
  9. ↑ Schrödinger, E. (1926/1928), p. 13
  10. 1 2 3 4 Houchmandzadeh, Bahram (May 2020). "The Hamilton–Jacobi equation: An alternative approach". American Journal of Physics. 88 (5): 353–359. arXiv: 1910.09414 . Bibcode:2020AmJPh..88..353H. doi:10.1119/10.0000781. ISSN   0002-9505. S2CID   204800598.
  11. 1 2 3 Masoliver, Jaume; Ros, Ana (1 January 2010). "From classical to quantum mechanics through optics". European Journal of Physics. 31 (1): 171–192. arXiv: 0909.3258 . Bibcode:2010EJPh...31..171M. doi:10.1088/0143-0807/31/1/016. ISSN   0143-0807. S2CID   14765944.
  12. ↑ Arnold, V.I. (1974/1978), p. 250.
  13. ↑ Messiah, A. (1961), pp. 224–225.
  14. ↑ Joas, Christian; Lehner, Christoph (2009). "The classical roots of wave mechanics: Schrödinger's transformations of the optical-mechanical analogy". Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics. Elsevier BV. 40 (4): 338–351. Bibcode:2009SHPMP..40..338J. doi:10.1016/j.shpsb.2009.06.007. ISSN   1355-2198. S2CID   122826763.
  15. ↑ Schrödinger, E. (1926) p. 1049.
  16. ↑ Schrödinger, E. (1928), p. 1.
  17. ↑ de Broglie, L. (1923).
  18. ↑ de Broglie, L. (1924).
  19. ↑ Rosenfeld, L. (1971/1979), on p. 286.
  20. ↑ Jammer, M. (1966), p. 366.
  21. ↑ Biggs, H.F. (1927), pp. 50, 52.
  22. ↑ Frenkel, J. (1934), p. 260.
  23. ↑ Khan, Sameen Ahmed (February 2017). "Hamilton's optical–mechanical analogy in the wavelength-dependent regime". Optik. 130: 714–722. doi:10.1016/j.ijleo.2016.10.112.

Bibliography of cited sources

  • Arnold, V.I. (1974/1978). Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, translated by K. Vogtmann, A. Weinstein, Springer, Berlin, ISBN   978-1-4757-1695-5.
  • Biggs, H.F. (1927). Wave Mechanics. An Introductory Sketch, Oxford University Press, London.
  • de Broglie, L. (1923). Waves and quanta, Nature112: 540.
  • de Broglie, L., Recherches sur la théorie des quanta (Researches on the quantum theory), Thesis (Paris), 1924; de Broglie, L., Ann. Phys. (Paris) 3, 22 (1925). English translation by A.F. Kracklauer
  • Cohen, R.S, Stachel, J.J., editors, (1979). Selected papers of Léon Rosenfeld , D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, ISBN   978-90-277-0652-2.
  • Jammer, M. (1966). The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics, MGraw–Hill, New York.
  • Frenkel, J. (1934). Wave mechanics. Advanced General Theory, Oxford University Press, London.
  • Kemble, E.C. (1937). The Fundamental Principles of Quantum Mechanics, with Elementary Applications, McGraw–Hill, New York.
  • Hamilton, W.R., (1834). On the application to dynamics of a general mathematical method previously applied to optics, British Association Report, pp. 513–518, reprinted in The Mathematical Papers of Sir William Rowan Hamilton (1940), ed. A.W. Conway, A.J. McConnell, volume 2, Cambridge University Press, London.
  • Lanczos, C. (1949/1970). The Variational Principles of Mechanics, 4th edition, University of Toronto Press, Toronto, ISBN   0-8020-1743-6.
  • Messiah, A. (1961). Quantum Mechanics, volume 1, translated by G.M. Temmer from the French Mécanique Quantique, North-Holland, Amsterdam.
  • Rosenfeld, L. (1971). Men and ideas in the history of atomic theory, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci., 7: 69–90. Reprinted on pp. 266–296 of Cohen, R.S, Stachel, J.J. (1979).
  • Schrödinger, E. (1926). An undulatory theory of the mechanics of atoms and molecules, Phys. Rev., second series 28 (6): 1049–1070.
  • Schrödinger, E. (1926/1928). Collected papers on Wave Mechanics, translated by J.F. Shearer and W.M. Deans from the second German edition, Blackie & Son, London.
  • Schrödinger, E. (1928). Four Lectures on Wave Mechanics. Delivered at the Royal Institution, London, on 5th, 7th, 12th, and 14th March, 1928, Blackie & Son, London.
  • Synge, J.L. (1954). Geometrical Mechanics and de Broglie Waves, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.