Beyond Chutzpah

Last updated
Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History
Beyond chutzpah.jpg
Cover of the first edition
Author Norman G. Finkelstein
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Publisher University of California Press
Publication date
2005
Media typePrint (Hardback and paperback)
Pages343
ISBN 978-0-520-24989-9 (Newest edition, paperback)
OCLC 441266179
956
LC Class DS119.7.F544
Preceded by The Holocaust Industry  
Followed byThis Time We Went Too Far 

Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History is a book by Norman Finkelstein published by the University of California Press in August 2005. The book provides a critique of arguments used to defend Israel's stance in the Israel-Palestine conflict, including the use of the weaponization of antisemitism to deflect criticism of Israel. The book also compares Alan Dershowitz's earlier book, The Case for Israel , with the findings of mainstream human rights organisations, such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International (see also Dershowitz–Finkelstein affair). It includes an epilogue entitled Dershowitz v. Finkelstein: Who’s Right and Who’s Wrong? by Frank Menetrez, a former Editor-in-Chief of the UCLA Law Review . [1] [2]

Contents

Finkelstein on the book

While still a graduate student at Princeton, Finkestein had published a critique of a book by Joan Peters, From Time Immemorial (1984), which claimed that Palestine had been largely empty in the early 20th century, and that both Jewish and Arab ethnic groups were immigrants. Finkelstein declared the book a fraud.

Two decades later, Finkelstein saw the record of the Israel-Palestine conflict as much less complex than previously. Finkelstein claims that the official Zionist "Exodus version," that Arab radio broadcasts had instructed the Palestinians to flee, has been largely swept away. He believes that proof of this became available in the 1960s but had little impact. In the late 1980s, however, some studies, including some by Israelis, claimed to dispel much of what Finkelstein refers to as "the Zionist mythology" enveloping the origins of the conflict. [3] Some scholarly debate now focuses on much narrower questions such as whether what in Finkelstein's view was "ethnic cleansing" was the intentional consequence of Zionist policy or the unintentional by-product of the 1948 Arab-Israeli war. The topic remains controversial, particularly in Israel, where mainstream historians continue to dispute the view of Israel's 1948 war of independence presented by Finkelstein.

In Beyond Chutzpah he analyses "The Not-So-New 'New Anti-Semitism'" from published sources. Finkelstein argues that the spectre of the "new anti-semitism" has been invented by supporters of Israel to brand any serious criticisms of Israel's human rights abuses as anti-semitism. The aim, Finkelstein contends, is to silence criticism of Israel's policies and to provide a cover for that country's expansionistic and illegal policies in the Palestinian territories. In the second part he analyses Alan Dershowitz's book The Case for Israel (2003).

Attempts by Dershowitz to stop publication

In Beyond Chutzpah Finkelstein documents what he says is the falsification of Israel's human rights record by Dershowitz and his plagiarism of research from Joan Peters' book From Time Immemorial. In response, Dershowitz's lawyers wrote letters to the University of California Press threatening a lawsuit if they published the book. Dershowitz also wrote to the Governor of California, Arnold Schwarzenegger, asking him to stop the book from being published. Schwarzenegger responded that "he is not inclined to otherwise exert influence in this case because of the clear, academic freedom issue it presents". According to Jon Weiner, writing in The Nation , Dershowitz' lawyers contacted the president of the University of California, the university provost, seventeen directors of the university press and nineteen members of the university press’s faculty editorial committee to attempt to stop the publication of the book. [4]

Eventually, Dershowitz backed off and the book was published by UC Press, albeit with some minor modifications as a result of Dershowitz's threat. [5]

Reviews

In his cover blurb for the publisher, Baruch Kimmerling, professor of sociology at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem wrote that Beyond Chutzpah is "the most comprehensive, systematic, and well-documented work of its kind. It is one of the harshest—rational and nonemotional—texts about the daily practices of the occupation and colonization of the Palestinian territories by Israel, and it is an excellent demonstration of how and why the blind defenders of Israel, by basing their arguments on false facts and figures, actually bring more damage than gains to their cause." [6] [ undue weight? ]

Amahl Bishara reviewing the book for 2005/2006 issue of The Arab Studies Journal wrote that the book is "an extremely well-researched account" that effectively "dismantles" Dershowitz's arguments. [7]

Stephanie Farmer writing for Arab Studies Quarterly in 2006 echoed Bishara, arguing that "Finkelstein' s examination reveals more than the dubious scholarship of Dershowitz", raising "important questions on the general lack of academic standards for Zionist scholars" and gets "the human rights record of the abuse of Palestinians to penetrate the bulwark of Zionism in the academy". [8]

In 2007, As'ad AbuKhalil in his review for Journal of Palestine Studies , wrote that "This is a book that should be recommended to all", as it successfully and carefully rebuts "the crude (and not-so-crude) elements of Israeli propaganda in the West". [9]

Also in 2007, Lisa Hajjar writing for Human Rights Review noted that the book is a rather successful critique of Dershowitz claims, although notes that it is strongly polemical, perhaps too strongly, and that the real value of the books is in its analytical footnotes and appendices rather than in the aggressive prose. [10]

Marc Saperstein, professor of Jewish history at George Washington University, wrote in conclusion of his review of Beyond Chutzpah for Middle East Journal : "if you are looking for a book that gathers for polemical purposes every anti-Israel argument in the arsenal of its opponents, and if you enjoy the rhetorical style of the arrogant academic pit bull, this may be the book for you. If you are looking for balance, fairness, context, a critical weighing of evidence on different sides of a controversial issue ... you will not find them here". [11]

Summarising the second edition in The Guardian in 2008, Ian Pindar said "It's an academic spat of epic proportions, but while Finkelstein wins the moral argument, his combative tone, born of exasperation, is unlikely to calm the debate." [12]

Awards

The University of California Press was awarded a prize for "sustained contributions to the promotion and defense of academic freedom in the Middle East and North Africa" by the Middle East Studies Association for publishing the book in the face of Dershowitz's threats. [6]

See also

Related Research Articles

The Dershowitz–Finkelstein affair was a public controversy involving academics Alan Dershowitz and Norman Finkelstein and their scholarship on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict in 2005.

<i>From Time Immemorial</i> 1984 book by Joan Peters

From Time Immemorial: The Origins of the Arab–Jewish Conflict over Palestine is a 1984 book by Joan Peters, published by Harper & Row, about the demographics of the Arab population of Palestine and of the Jewish population of the Arab world before and after the formation of the State of Israel.

<i>The Case for Israel</i> 2003 book by Alan Dershowitz

The Case for Israel is a 2003 book by Alan Dershowitz, a law professor at Harvard University. The work is a response to common criticisms of Israel. The Case for Israel was a New York Times bestseller.

New antisemitism is the concept that a new form of antisemitism developed in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, typically manifesting itself as anti-Zionism. The concept is included in some definitions of antisemitism, such as the working definition of antisemitism and the 3D test of antisemitism. The concept dates to the early 1970s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Greater Israel</span> Zionist ideologically irredentist term

Greater Israel is an expression with several different biblical and political meanings over time. It is often used, in an irredentist fashion, to refer to the historic or desired borders of Israel.

<i>Image and Reality of the Israel–Palestine Conflict</i> 1995 book by Norman Finkelstein

Image and Reality of the Israel–Palestine Conflict is a 1995 book about the Israeli–Palestinian conflict by Norman G. Finkelstein. Finkelstein examines and scrutinizes popular historical versions of the conflict by authors such as Joan Peters, Benny Morris, Anita Shapira and Abba Eban. The text draws upon Finkelstein's doctoral political science work. The 2003 revised edition offers an additional appendix devoted to criticism of Michael Oren's 2002 bestseller Six Days of War: June 1967 and the Making of the Modern Middle East.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alan Dershowitz</span> American lawyer and author (born 1938)

Alan Morton Dershowitz is an American lawyer and law professor known for his work in U.S. constitutional law and American criminal law. From 1964 to 2013, he taught at Harvard Law School, where he was appointed as the Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law in 1993. Dershowitz is a regular media contributor, political commentator, and legal analyst.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Massad</span> Jordanian academic and professor (born 1963)

Joseph Andoni Massad is a Jordanian academic specializing in Middle Eastern studies, who serves as Professor of Modern Arab Politics and Intellectual History in the Department of Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies at Columbia University. His academic work has focused on Palestinian, Jordanian, and Israeli nationalism.

The Case for Peace: How The Arab–Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved is a 2005 book by Alan Dershowitz and follow-up to his 2003 book The Case for Israel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">A land without a people for a people without a land</span> Phrase associated with Zionism

"A land without a people for a people without a land" is a widely cited phrase associated with the movement to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine during the 19th and 20th centuries. Its historicity and significance are a matter of contention.

This is an incomplete bibliography of the Arab–Israeli conflict.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Norman Finkelstein</span> American political scientist (born 1953)

Norman Gary Finkelstein is an American political scientist and activist. His primary fields of research are the politics of the Holocaust and the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anti-Zionism</span> Opposition to Jewish nationalism

Anti-Zionism is opposition to Zionism. Although anti-Zionism is a heterogeneous phenomenon, all its proponents agree that the creation of the modern State of Israel, and the movement to create a sovereign Jewish state in the region of Palestine—a region partly coinciding with the biblical Land of Israel—was flawed or unjust in some way.

In 1978 Sami Esmail, a 24-year-old American citizen of Palestinian descent, was prosecuted in Israel for membership in the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. The case generated a great deal of interest in the US, especially in the Arab American community and at Michigan State University, where Esmail was an Electrical Engineering graduate student.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Racism in the State of Palestine</span> Discussion of racism

Racism in the Palestinian territories encompasses all forms and manifestations of racism experienced in the Palestinian Territories, of the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem, irrespective of the religion, colour, creed, or ethnic origin of the perpetrator and victim, or their citizenship, residency, or visitor status. It may refer to Jewish settler attitudes regarding Palestinians as well as Palestinian attitudes to Jews and the settlement enterprise undertaken in their name.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Criticism of Israel</span> Disapproval towards the Israeli government

Criticism of Israel is a subject of journalistic and scholarly commentary and research within the scope of international relations theory, expressed in terms of political science. Israel has faced international criticism since its establishment in 1948 relating to a variety of issues, many of which are centered around human rights violations in its occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

Operation Atlas was the code name for an operation carried out by a special commando unit of the Waffen SS which took place in October 1944. It involved five soldiers: three who were previously members of the Templer religious sect in Mandatory Palestine, and two Palestinian Arabs who were close collaborators of the mufti of Jerusalem, Amin al-Husseini.

This timeline of anti-Zionism chronicles the history of anti-Zionism, including events in the history of anti-Zionist thought.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Legitimacy of the State of Israel</span> Question of whether Israeli political authority is legitimate or not

Since the Israeli Declaration of Independence in 1948, a number of countries and individuals have challenged the country's political legitimacy. Under international law, Israel has always met the standards for recognition as a sovereign state. However, over the course of the Arab–Israeli conflict, the country's authority has been questioned on a number of fronts. Critics of Israel may be motivated by their opposition to the country's right to exist or, since the 1967 Arab–Israeli War, their disapproval of the established power structure within the Israeli-occupied territories. Some have called for Israel's destruction.

The exploitation of accusations of antisemitism for political purposes, especially to counter anti-Zionism and criticism of Israel, may be described variously as weaponization of antisemitism, instrumentalization of antisemitism, or playing the antisemitism card. Such accusations have been criticized as a form of smear tactics. Some writers have compared this to playing the race card.

References

  1. Frank Menetrez: "Dershowitz v. Finkelstein: Who's Right and Who's Wrong?". Included as Epilogue in: Norman G. Finkelstein (2008). Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-semitism and the Abuse of History . University of California Press. pp.  363–. ISBN   978-0-520-24989-9 . Retrieved May 26, 2013.
  2. Menetrez, Frank J. (April 30, 2007). "Dershowitz vs. Finkelstein: Who's Right and Who's Wrong?". CounterPunch. Retrieved September 1, 2020. Includes e-mails attributed to Alan Dershowitz and remarks additional to the original article attributed to Menetrez etal
  3. "The New Historiography: Israel and Its Past," in Benny Morris, 1948 and After: Israel and the Palestinians (Oxford, 1990), pp. 1-34. Cited in BC p.3.
  4. Wiener, Jon (23 June 2005). "Giving Chutzpah New Meaning". The Nation. Retrieved 6 January 2024.
  5. Schuker, Daniel J. T. (8 July 2025). "Accusations Fly in Academic Feud | News | The Harvard Crimson". www.thecrimson.com. Retrieved 6 January 2024.
  6. 1 2 "Beyond Chutzpah On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History". Reviews. University of California Press. Archived from the original on 25 December 2007. Retrieved 10 September 2011.
  7. Bishara, Amahl (2005). "Review of Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History". The Arab Studies Journal. 13/14 (2/1): 152–156. ISSN   1083-4753. JSTOR   27933945.
  8. Farmer, Stephanie (2006). "Review of Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History". Arab Studies Quarterly. 28 (1): 59–62. ISSN   0271-3519. JSTOR   41858521.
  9. AbuKhalil, As'ad (2007). "Review of Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History". Journal of Palestine Studies. 36 (2): 95–97. doi:10.1525/jps.2007.36.2.95. ISSN   0377-919X. JSTOR   10.1525/jps.2007.36.2.95.
  10. Hajjar, Lisa (2007-11-12). "Norman Finkelstein, Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History. University of California Press, 2005". Human Rights Review. 8 (4): 423–424. doi:10.1007/s12142-007-0023-5. ISSN   1524-8879. S2CID   145684073.
  11. Saperstein, Marc (2006). "Review of Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History". Middle East Journal. 60 (1): 183–185. ISSN   0026-3141. JSTOR   4330239.
  12. Pindar, Ian (3 October 2008). "Review: Beyond Chutzpah by Norman G Finklestein". the Guardian. Retrieved 18 March 2024.

Further reading