Bridge strike or tunnel strike (also known as bridge bashing) is a type of transport accident in which a vehicle collides with a bridge, overpass, or tunnel structure. Bridge-strike road accidents, in which an over-height vehicle collides with the underside of the structure, occur frequently and are a major issue worldwide. In waterways, the term encompasses water vessel–bridge collisions, including bridge span and support structure collisions.
In United Kingdom, railway bridge strikes (called "bridge bashing" [1] ) happen on an average of once every four and a half hours, with total of 1789 times in 2019. Several bridges have been hit over 20 times in a single year. The total cost borne by the state was around £23 million. [2] [3] In Beijing, China, 20% of all bridge damages are caused by bridge strikes. Texas Department of Transportation estimated in 2013 that an average cost to repair a bridge strike is $180,000 USD. [2]
Even without damages to the bridges, the strikes can result in significant damages to the vehicles. There are many examples of buses that have their roofs got completely cut off by bridge strikes, such as strikes in Birkenhead in 2014, [4] Long Island in 2018, [5] and Glasgow in 2023. [6] Local communities also incur costs related to strikes without bridge damages. These include economic impacts due to road closures, and police response and cleanup costs. [7] [8] From 2021 to 2022, Network Rail lost £12 million in train delay and cancellation fees. [9]
The severity of damage to bridges caused by strikes can vary depending on the type of impact and the differences in damage resistance among bridges. [11] Some of them are not structural damages and only minor repairs are required. [12] Some major structural damages require extensive repairs, for example, an overpass strike in Nashville in 2018 caused a structural beam to be twisted, resulting in repair cost of nearly one million US dollars. [13] Repairs of structural damages can be long and complicated process. In order to allow traffic to get moving as soon as possible, officials may need to implement emergency repairs before permanent repair solutions can be implemented. For example, a bridge strike in York County, Pennsylvania in 2022 required a large temporary stabilizing frame to be added to the top of the bridge. [10] After the second strike on the same spot six months later, the permanent repair was further delayed and the estimate costs of the permanent repair increased to $1.5 million USD. [14]
A single bridge strike may result in a catastrophic bridge damage. An example of that is the I-5 Skagit River bridge collapse. The collapse was caused by a truck with an oversize load that was taller than the clearance above of the bridge. The bridge was a steel through-truss bridge with a "fracture-critical" design that has non-redundant load-bearing beams. An impact of the oversize load to multiple sway braces was enough to damage load-bearing members and caused a span to be collapsed, resulting in vehicles falling down to the river with three minor injuries. [15]
Beyond damages and economic impacts, bridge strikes can result in serious injuries and fatalities. In 1994, five passengers of a double-decker bus were killed by a low-bridge strike in Glasgow. [16] In 2010, a rail bridge strike of a double-decker bus on a New York parkway killed 4 passengers. In the United States, 13 people died in bridge strike accidents between 2014 and 2018. [13] In 2022, a truck carrying liquified petroleum gas scraped the underside of a low bridge in Boksburg, South Africa, causing an explosion that killed at least 8 people. [17]
Some countries have standards on minimum vertical clearance of roadway. Any structures that do not meet that clearance would need to have warning signs. The United Kingdom has a standard on minimum clearance of a public highway at 16 feet 6 inches (5.03 m). Any bridges that do not meet the clearance requirement are considered to be "low bridges" and they require to have signage to indicate the clearance. [18]
In United States, the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices requires the placement of warning signs for any structure with vertical clearance less than 12 inches (30 cm) more than the legal maximum vehicle height. Warning signs installed on the structure can use either diamond or rectangle shapes, while advanced warning signs, must be diamonds. [19] States, not the federal government, set maximum vehicle heights. The most common maximum, used by 32 eastern states, is 13 feet 6 inches (4.11 m). This effectively sets a requirement for signage at structures in those states lower than 14 feet 6 inches (4.42 m). Higher legal maximum vehicle height limits used in other states. [20] [21]
There is a variety of shapes, colors and designs used for low clearance and height limit warning signs, indication signs, and prohibition signs used worldwide.
In United Kingdom, there is an emphasis on making low clearance structures be more noticeable to drivers. This includes having large "LOW BRIDGE" letters and hazard marking on the low bridges. It has various warning signs including warning signs at or near the structures, advanced warning signs, and road markings. For advanced warning signs, there can be large panel with alternative route information. [18] Similarly in Australia, advanced traffic instruction signs are used to provide clearance information of a low-clearance bridge ahead and accompanied by a detour direction. [22] [23]
Speed limits along with road narrowing, speed bumps, rumble strip or other traffic calming techniques can be used to force reducing vehicle speeds to prevent bridge strikes. [2]
Tattle tales are series of chains suspended from an overhead gantry over the roadway. The gantry is also equipped with warning signs and other markings. The chain are set to the clearances of the approaching low-clearance structures. When any parts of vehicles hit the chains, it creates noises to notify drivers so they can pay attention to the height restriction signs. [24] [25] Sometime a bar is hung at the bottom of the chains to make it more noticeable to drivers. [26] This type of devices only works in low speeds. High speed vehicles can run through without giving out enough noticeable noises to the drivers. [2]
In special situations where the clearance of a structure is reduced longitudinally, the beginning part of the structure may give an appearance that it provides enough clearance for vehicles to go through. As the vehicles are driven under it, the clearance is reduced. The vehicles may be wedged and stuck under the structure as it is too late for drivers to realize that it is not enough clearance to go all the way through. In this case, false soffits can be added to the beginning part of the structure. The false soffits are flaps that extend down from the underside of the structure to match the lowest clearance of the entire structure to provide visual aid to drivers of the actual clearance that they will be facing. There can be hazard markings on the false soffits to make them highly visible. [18]
Other devices include scarifying structures. These structures are installed in front of the bridges or tunnels with the heights of the clearance to absorb the impacts of overheight vehicles. The primary goal of using scarifying structures is to prevent damage to the bridge and tunnel structures. [2] Height restriction bars can be installed ahead of the structure to ensure that overheight vehicles will not be able to approach the low-clearance structure. [27] Collision protection beams are installed right in front or at the structures. They take the impacts and dissipate the energy from bridge strikes to prevent damages to the structures. [18] [28] As the goal of these devices are to protect the structures, they are used as the last resort without providing any benefits to crash prevention. Without other devices, risks to vehicles still hold. [2] In 2019, a bus crashed onto a height restriction bar in Dubai, resulting in several fatalities. [29]
Overheight detectors integrated with flashing lights and other warning signs are used to in some locations to provide an active warning to the drivers of the vehicles that are over the height restrictions of the upcoming bridges or tunnels. [22] Despite the yellow flashing lights, this method may still fail to gain attention of the drivers. The infamous Norfolk Southern–Gregson Street Overpass (also known as the 11-foot-8 Bridge) had 100 crashes on record between 2008 and 2016 even with this type of systems. [30] [31] An improvement to this is to have the detectors fully integrated with traffic lights to stop all traffic when an overheight vehicle is detected. [30]
Fully integrated systems of overheight detectors and traffic lights have been used in tunnel operations for decades. By the 1970s, several tunnels in the United States had such systems in place. [26] An example was a systems at the Hampton Roads Bridge–Tunnel which had two detection points. The first point provided an audible and visual warnings to drivers to pull over to an inspection station. The vehicle would be measured by an authority before allowing to proceed. In an event that an overheight vehicle failed to stop at the inspection station, the secondary detector would trigger another alarm that would display a message at variable-message signs to lower the speed limit and eventually turned the red light to stop all traffic. [32] Most detectors in the 70s used photocell system with light source installed on one pole and a photocell detector installed on opposite side of the roadway. A major drawback of the photocell detectors was that they produced a lot of false alarms caused by snow and heavy rain. Another type of detectors at the time included trip wires that would be broken if an object at that height hit the wire. [26]
Modern detectors now use other technologies such as red/infrared photoelectric sensors, infrared laser beams, and ultrasonic transducer. Some are dual-beam systems to increase reliability by allowing the system to function even with single beam, and to lower false alarms by rejecting birds and other materials. More sophisticated systems include camera systems that can capture 3D profiles of vehicles in realtime, and microwave radar systems that can capture vehicle height profiles. [33] [2] Contact-based detection systems are also in use such as low-clearance detection bars that are movable vertically to initiate a trigger. [33]
In case of overheight vehicle detection systems that are fully integrated with traffic light control systems but unmanned, there is no personnel available to perform measurements and direct overheight vehicles away from the bridges. The lights will turn green after a short stop with an expectation that the drivers will notice the height restrictions and use an alternative route by themselves. Some drivers still do not think that the warnings are applicable to them and proceed to crash into the bridges after the lights turn to green. [34]
In United Kingdom, a more advanced system that targets a specific vehicle was deployed at Blackwall Tunnel. An advanced overheight detection system is installed 1.6-kilometre (0.99 mi) ahead of the tunnel. It is equipped with automatic number-plate recognition that reads off the plate number and sends that over to variable-message signs to instruct the vehicle with that particular plate number to divert to the provided alternative route. The system reduced tunnel strikes by 38%. In Australia, a water curtain falling on all traffic lanes with a laser projection of a large stop sign in front of the Sydney Harbour Tunnel is used as the last resort to stop overheight vehicles that ignore all the warning signs and traffic lights. [35]
There are several systems that can be equipped in trucks or other commercial vehicles to provide bridge strike prevention. These include specialized truck GPS systems that have clearance information, systems that measure the actual vehicle heights, and onboard sensors that detect upcoming low-clearance structure. More advanced onboard systems can electronically receive warnings from overheight vehicle detection systems. They can apply a brake if drivers fail to react. [33]
A 2.7 m (8 ft 10+1⁄4 in) high overpass bridge near St Petersburg, Russia, is known as the "Bridge of Stupidity" because it is often struck by vehicles despite many warning signs. In May 2018, after it was struck for the 150th time by a GAZelle truck, a birthday cake was presented to the bridge. This made national news. [36] [37]
Similarly, the 11 ft 8 in (3.56 m) Norfolk Southern–Gregson Street Overpass, nicknamed "The Can Opener", in Durham, North Carolina, US, was very frequently struck by vehicles, and received international media attention [38] until it was raised in 2019. [39]
Infrared sensors, which trigger warning signs when a high vehicle approaches, were added to an underpass in Frauenfeld, Switzerland, only after several incidents. [40] [41]
A similar situation exists at an underpass on Guy Street in Montreal, which has a clearance of 3.75 m (12 ft 4 in). [42] [43] [44]
In waterways, the term bridge strike may be used when a water vessel collides with a bridge. This may include a collision to the bridge span or a collision to the bridge support structure such as a pier. [45] [46] [47] Bridge protection systems are used to mitigate the effects of a ship strike. [48]
In 2014, the United States Coast Guard published statistics that it investigated 205 bridge strikes in the eleven years prior to the publication. All of those collisions involved involved a fixed, swing, lift or draw bridge. That number was 1.2% of all vessel collision incidents investigated by the Coast Guard. The primary causal factor was the lack of accurate air draft data, the distance between water surface to the top most part of the vessel. [49]
 |
Low-flying aircraft can also collide with bridges. For example, Air Florida Flight 90 crashed into a bridge over the Potomac River just after takeoff.
To prevent controlled flight into terrain, tall bridges may bear aviation obstruction lighting that notifies pilots of their presence. [50]
A warning sign is a type of sign which indicates a potential hazard, obstacle, or condition requiring special attention. Some are traffic signs that indicate hazards on roads that may not be readily apparent to a driver.
The Eisenhower Tunnel, officially the Eisenhower–Edwin C. Johnson Memorial Tunnel, is a dual-bore, four-lane vehicular tunnel in the western United States, approximately 60 miles (97 km) west of Denver, Colorado. The tunnel carries Interstate 70 (I-70) under the Continental Divide in the Rocky Mountains. With a maximum elevation of 11,158 feet (3,401 m) above sea level, it is one of the highest vehicular tunnels in the world. The tunnel is the longest mountain tunnel and highest point on the Interstate Highway System. Opened in 1973, the westbound bore is named after Dwight D. Eisenhower, the U.S. President for whom the Interstate system is also named. The eastbound bore was completed in 1979 and is named for Edwin C. Johnson, a governor and U.S. Senator who lobbied for an Interstate Highway to be built across Colorado.
A rollover or overturn is a type of vehicle crash in which a vehicle tips over onto its side or roof. Rollovers have a higher fatality rate than other types of vehicle collisions.
The Hampton Roads Bridge–Tunnel (HRBT) is a 3.5-mile-long (5.6 km) Hampton Roads crossing for Interstate 64 (I-64) and US Route 60 (US 60). It is a four-lane facility comprising bridges, trestles, artificial islands, and tunnels under the main shipping channels for Hampton Roads harbor in the southeastern portion of Virginia in the United States.
A structure gauge, also called the minimum structure outline, is a diagram or physical structure that sets limits to the extent that bridges, tunnels and other infrastructure can encroach on rail vehicles. It specifies the height and width of station platforms, tunnels and bridges, and the width of the doors that allow access to a warehouse from a rail siding. Specifications may include the minimum distance from rail vehicles to railway platforms, buildings, lineside electrical equipment cabinets, signalling equipment, third rails or supports for overhead lines.
An impact attenuator, also known as a crash cushion, crash attenuator, or cowboy cushion, is a device intended to reduce the damage to structures, vehicles, and motorists resulting from a motor vehicle collision. Impact attenuators are designed to absorb the colliding vehicle's kinetic energy. They may also be designed to redirect the vehicle away from the hazard or away from roadway machinery and workers. Impact attenuators are usually placed in front of fixed structures near highways, such as gore points, crash barrier introductions, or overpass supports. Temporary versions may be used for road construction projects.
Vehicle activated sign (VAS) is a generic term for a type of road traffic sign which displays a message conditional upon the presence, or speed, of a road vehicle. The devices are deployed on roadsides like regular traffic signs in various countries. They are intended to help drivers by alerting them and drawing attention to danger or other undesirable situation.
Storrow Drive, officially James Jackson Storrow Memorial Drive, is a major crosstown parkway in Boston, Massachusetts, running east–west along the southern bank of the Charles River. It is restricted to cars; trucks and buses are not permitted on it, while pedestrian access is available via walking paths on the Charles River side of the road. Boston drivers use the route for quick access to downtown locations.
In road transport, an oversize load is a load that exceeds the standard or ordinary legal size and/or weight limits for a truck to convey on a specified portion of road, highway, or other transport infrastructure, such as air freight or water freight. In Europe, it may be referred to as special transport or heavy and oversized transportation. There may also be load-per-axle limits. However, a load that exceeds the per-axle limits but not the overall weight limits is considered overweight. Examples of oversize/overweight loads include construction machines, pre-built homes, containers, and construction elements.
The Newhall Pass interchange is a highway interchange at Newhall Pass in Southern California, United States. It is south of the city of Santa Clarita and north of the Los Angeles neighborhoods of Granada Hills and Sylmar. It connects Interstate 5 with California State Route 14. It is officially named in the memory of Los Angeles Police officer Clarence Wayne Dean, who was killed when he was unable to stop before going over a collapsed section of the interchange immediately following the 1994 Northridge earthquake.
An escort vehicle, also called a pilot vehicle in most areas, is an automobile used to alert other road users of an upcoming trucks with large loads, convoys of large vehicles or to guide motorists through construction sites. They are also used to guide aircraft taxiing from the runway to the apron at many airports. In most instances, pilot vehicles are provided by companies that specialize in convoy escort, although escort duties are occasionally performed by police vehicles. Some escort companies have special authority for traffic control through state approval.
On May 23, 2013, at approximately 7:00 pm PDT, a span of the bridge carrying Interstate 5 over the Skagit River in the U.S. state of Washington collapsed. Three people in two different vehicles fell into the river below and were rescued by boat, escaping serious injury. The cause of the catastrophic failure was determined to be an oversize load striking several of the bridge's overhead support beams, leading to an immediate collapse of the northernmost span.
The Norfolk Southern–Gregson Street Overpass, also known as the 11-foot-8 Bridge, is a railroad bridge in Durham, North Carolina, United States. Built in 1940, the bridge allows passenger and freight trains to cross over South Gregson Street in downtown Durham and also functions as the northbound access to the nearby Durham Amtrak station.
A tell-tale, also known as a bridge warning, is a series of ropes suspended over railway tracks to give warning to the engineer, and more importantly the brakeman who may be scampering across the tops of the cars, that the train is approaching a low-clearance obstacle, such as a tunnel or a bridge. In the US, a standard tell-tale design had ropes on 3 in (7.6 cm) centers for a width of 8 ft (2.4 m) over the track, the bottom of the ropes 6 in (15 cm) lower than the height of the obstruction, and placed at least 100 ft (30 m) before the obstruction.
The Montague Street Bridge is a railway bridge in South Melbourne, Australia, an inner suburb of Melbourne. The bridge is located at 83 Montague Street, between Woodgate Street and Gladstone Lane.
The Robert Parker Coffin Bridge is a Pratt pony truss bridge that spans Buffalo Creek in Long Grove, Illinois, United States. Standing 41 feet (12 m) long, it was built in 1906 by the Joliet Bridge and Iron Company. It is one of the few remaining bridges of its kind in the Chicago area and the state of Illinois, and it was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2018.
The 1990 Interstate 75 fog disaster was a traffic collision that occurred on the morning of December 11, 1990, on a section of Interstate 75 (I-75) near Calhoun, Tennessee, during dense fog which obscured the visibility of motorists. The collisions occurred in an area where fog is common and had been the site of previous multi-vehicle collisions caused by poor visibility. It consisted of a series of multi-vehicle collisions that ultimately involved 99 vehicles, and resulted in 12 deaths and 42 injuries. It was reportedly the largest motor vehicle collision in United States history when it occurred, in terms of the number of vehicles, and was the largest and second deadliest vehicle accident in Tennessee history behind the 1972 Bean Station bus-truck collision, which killed 14. The disaster resulted in multiple safety improvements to the section of I-75 where the collision occurred.
The Onondaga Lake Parkway Bridge is a truss bridge just outside the Syracuse, New York city limits that carries the St. Lawrence Subdivision railway freight line owned by CSX Transportation over a segment of New York State Route 370, known as the Onondaga Lake Parkway. The bridge has become infamous for a large number of commercial vehicles colliding with its deck, which rises just 10 feet 9 inches above grade, while driving down this stretch of NY-370.
In civil engineering, clearance refers to the difference between the loading gauge and the structure gauge in the case of railroad cars or trams, or the difference between the size of any vehicle and the width/height of doors, the width/height of an overpass or the diameter of a tunnel as well as the air draft under a bridge, the width of a lock or diameter of a tunnel in the case of watercraft. In addition, there is the difference between the deep draft and the stream bed or sea bed of a waterway.
The owner of a bridge which constitutes a hazard to aerial navigation should maintain, in addition to the lights prescribed in this part, such lights as may be prescribed by the Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration.