City of Glasgow Bank

Last updated

The City of Glasgow Bank was a bank in Scotland that was largely known for its spectacular collapse in October 1878, which ruined all but 254 of its 1,200 shareholders since their liability was unlimited.

Contents

History

A cleared cheque from 1877 City of Glasgow Bank cheque1877.JPG
A cleared cheque from 1877

The bank was founded in 1839 [1] with an initial capital of £656,250 (equivalent to about £56 million at 2023 prices). It aimed to cater particularly for small savers, with its branches opening in the evenings to receive deposits. It was part of a wave of bank formations that saw 16 Scottish banks established between 1825 and 1840. By the 1870s the bank had grown to have the third-largest branch network in the United Kingdom.

As was common at the time its shareholders had unlimited liability and so they were jointly liable to cover any debts and were called to inject additional funds to cover any losses. [2]

The bank's principal office was established in Virginia Street, Glasgow in 1842 and moved to 21 Glassford Street in 1851. [3] In 1855 it moved to a huge building on Trongate at the corner of Albion St. [4] [lower-alpha 1] [5] During the Panic of 1857, the bank had to suspend operation but later reopened and continued trading. [6] For a long time before the bank's closure, dividends were paid at 9%-12%.

Collapse

On discovery of a £7,000 deficit (equivalent to £½ million at 2005 prices), the Bank's operations were suspended in November and December 1877, when by agreement with the other Scottish banks, the New York agency was closed. [7] All seemed well, and in June 1878, the bank announced that there were now 133 branches and deposits of £8 million (= £600 million at 2005 prices), and it declared a 12% dividend. [1]

On 2 October, however, the directors announced the bank's closure. [8] An examination after the closure showed net liabilities of over £6 million (equivalent to £500 million at 2005 prices), together with extensive loans on poor security and speculative investments in Australasian farming, mining stocks and American railway shares. [9] In addition, false reports of gold holdings were made to the authorities, financial statements were falsified and the share price was held up by secret share buybacks. [10] So successful was the deception that on the Bank's last business day, its £100 shares were selling at £236. [10]

The directors were arrested and tried at the High Court in Edinburgh in January 1879. Their sentence was pronounced on 1 February. The Manager, Robert Stronach and Lewis Potter, who had been a director of the bank since its establishment, were found guilty of falsifying and fabricating the balance sheets of the bank and were given eighteen months imprisonment each. The other five directors were found guilty of uttering and publishing the balance sheets, knowing them to be false, and were sentenced to eight months imprisonment. [1] [10]

Scores of Glasgow businesses failed as a result of the bankruptcy, and shareholders were called to make good the bank's losses. The case of one shareholder who sought to mitigate the consequence by arguing that he had become a shareholder through the fraud of the bank's agents was appealed unsuccessfully to the House of Lords ("Houldsworth's case", 1880, 7 R. (H.L.) 53). [11]

Depositors and note holders did not suffer, as other banks accepted their notes, and deposits were protected by the shareholders' liability.

The 1200 shareholders and their families suffered greatly. Their liability was unlimited, and the failure ruined most of them. [2] A public subscription was set up to help the shareholders, almost all of whom were bankrupted by the disaster, in the form of a national relief fund, which received £379,670 in donations by 1882. [12]

Wider effects of the collapse have been seen in the growth of limited liability and a temporary banking liquidity problem, [13] and a longer-term reduced trend in bank deposits across the UK. [14]

The legalities of the collapse and liquidation were overseen by Alexander Bennett McGrigor. [15]

The liquidation of the US assets, primarily holdings in railroad stock which amounted to $5,000,000, were handled by John Stewart Kennedy's firm J.S.Kennedy & Co. [16]

Archives

The bank's archives are now held in the Archives of the University of Glasgow. [17] [18] [19]

In literature

The Bank's collapse was vividly represented in the 1948 trilogy The Wax Fruit by Guy McCrone (dramatised by BBC Radio 4 in 2010). It also features in Mrs George de Horne Vaizey's 1910 novel A Question of Marriage.

Ken Follett’s "A Dangerous Fortune" pages 252,270,273,274,436

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Airdrie Savings Bank</span>

Airdrie Savings Bank was a small commercial bank operation in the Lanarkshire area of Scotland. It ran three branches throughout the area, with its head office in Airdrie at the time of the announcement of its closure. Total assets of the bank at 31 October 2013 were £158 million with a reported loss of £267,000. In January 2017, the bank announced it would begin closure proceedings on 28 April of that year.

The Home Bank of Canada was a Canadian bank that was incorporated July 10, 1903, in Toronto but did not receive a Treasury Board certificate to operate as a chartered bank until the next year.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Unlimited company</span> Company where shareholders/members have unlimited legal liability

An unlimited company or private unlimited company is a hybrid company (corporation) incorporated with or without a share capital but where the legal liability of the members or shareholders is not limited: that is, its members or shareholders have a joint and several non-limited obligation to meet any insufficiency in the assets of the company to enable settlement of any outstanding financial liability in the event of the company's formal liquidation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clydesdale Bank plc</span> UK commercial bank

Clydesdale Bank plc is a retail and commercial bank in Scotland. It was formed in Glasgow, Scotland in 1838 and now trades as Virgin Money.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trongate</span> Street in Glasgow

Trongate is one of the oldest streets in the city of Glasgow, Scotland. Trongate begins at Glasgow Cross, where the steeple of the old Glasgow Tolbooth is situated, being the original centre of medieval Glasgow, and goes westward changing its name to Argyle Street at Glassford Street. In modern times, it forms the notional southern boundary of the Merchant City area.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bank of United States</span> Former American bank

The Bank of United States, founded by Joseph S. Marcus in 1913 at 77 Delancey Street in New York City, was a New York City bank that failed in 1931. The bank run on its Bronx branch is said to have started the collapse of banking during the Great Depression.

NetBank, formerly named Atlanta Internet Bank (1996) and Net.B@nk (1998), was a direct bank.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tobacco Lords</span> Group of 18th-century Scottish merchants

The Tobacco Lords were a group of Scottish merchants active during the Georgian era who made substantial sums of money via their participation in the triangular trade, primarily through dealing in slave-produced tobacco that was grown in the Thirteen Colonies. Concentrated in the port city of Glasgow, these merchants utilised their fortunes, which were also partly made via the direct ownership of slaves, to construct numerous townhouses, churches and other buildings in Scotland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bank failure</span> Insolvency or illiquidity of a bank

A bank failure occurs when a bank is unable to meet its obligations to its depositors or other creditors because it has become insolvent or too illiquid to meet its liabilities. A bank usually fails economically when the market value of its assets declines to a value that is less than the market value of its liabilities. The insolvent bank either borrows from other solvent banks or sells its assets at a lower price than its market value to generate liquid money to pay its depositors on demand. The inability of the solvent banks to lend liquid money to the insolvent bank creates a bank panic among the depositors as more depositors try to take out cash deposits from the bank. As such, the bank is unable to fulfill the demands of all of its depositors on time. A bank may be taken over by the regulating government agency if its shareholders' equity are below the regulatory minimum.

The government interventions during the subprime mortgage crisis were a response to the 2007–2009 subprime mortgage crisis and resulted in a variety of government bailouts that were implemented to stabilize the financial system during late 2007 and early 2008.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British credit crisis of 1772–1773</span> British banking crisis

The British credit crisis of 1772–1773 also known as the crisis of 1772, or the panic of 1772, was a peacetime financial crisis which originated in London and then spread to Scotland and the Dutch Republic. It has been described as the first modern banking crisis faced by the Bank of England. New colonies, as Adam Smith observed, had an insatiable demand for capital. Accompanying the more tangible evidence of wealth creation was a rapid expansion of credit and banking, leading to a rash of speculation and dubious financial innovation. In today’s language, they bought shares on margin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">St Andrew's Square, Glasgow</span>

St Andrew's Square is a public square in the city of Glasgow, Scotland and lies to the south east corner of Glasgow Cross, close to Glasgow Green. The square is noted for its immense 18th-century classical church, St Andrew's in the Square, from which the square takes its name. The church was completed in 1758, to the designs of architect Allan Dreghorn and master mason Mungo Naismith and is among the finest of its type anywhere in Britain. The interior has lavish 18th century rococo plasterwork. The building is Category A listed. It is one of six squares in the city centre.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Amsterdam banking crisis of 1763</span> Financial crisis in the Netherlands

The Amsterdam banking crisis of 1763 in the Netherlands followed the end of the Seven Years' War. At this time prices of grain and other commodities were falling sharply, and the supply of credit dried up due to the decreased value of collateral goods. Many of the banks based in Amsterdam were over-leveraged and were interlinked by complex financial instruments, making them vulnerable to a sudden tightening of credit availability. The crisis was marked by the failure of one large bank - that of De Neufville - and many smaller financial enterprises. The extent of the crisis was mitigated by the provision of additional liquidity by the Bank of Amsterdam, the Dutch central bank. Similarities have been identified between these events and the financial crisis of 2007–2008.

James Simpson Fleming FRSE (1828-1899) was a Scottish lawyer and banker. From 1858 to 1871 he was a partner in the legal firm of McGrigor, Stevenson & Fleming. In the 1870s he was responsible for introducing the Royal Bank of Scotland to London.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Signature Bank</span> American commercial bank

Signature Bank was an American full-service commercial bank headquartered in New York City and with 40 private client offices in the states of New York, Connecticut, California, Nevada, and North Carolina. In addition to banking products, specialty national businesses provided services specific to industries such as commercial real estate, private equity, mortgage servicing, and venture banking; subsidiaries of the bank provided equipment financing and investment services. At the end of 2022, the bank had total assets of US$110.4 billion and deposits of $82.6 billion; as of 2021, it had loans of $65.25 billion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dumbell's Bank</span>

Dumbell's Bank was a bank in the Isle of Man. The bank's insolvency in 1900, known as Black Saturday and referred to in the Isle of Man as the Dumbell's Bank Crash, resulted in a run on the bank with many individuals losing their life savings and the ruin of numerous local businesses causing poverty, depression and bankruptcy. The effects were profound and lasted for a considerable number of years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Glassford Street</span> Street in Glasgow, Scotland, UK

Glassford Street is a major thoroughfare in the city of Glasgow, the largest city in Scotland. The street runs north from the junction of Argyle Street and Trongate through the Merchant City until it meets Ingram Street.

The Glasgow Savings Bank, formed in 1836, had become the largest savings banks in Scotland by the mid-1850s and the largest in the country by 1870. When the trustee savings banks were reorganised into regional banks in 1975 Glasgow became the core of the West of Scotland TSB.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Old Ship Bank</span>

The Ship Bank or more usually Old Ship Bank was an independent bank formed in Glasgow in 1750: Glasgow's first bank.

The Northumberland and Durham District Bank was a joint stock bank created in Newcastle upon Tyne, England, in 1836, which operated across the north-east of England. It was the area's largest such bank in its period, but failed in 1857 and was liquidated at enormous cost to its shareholders between then and 1865. A modern analysis of the bank's failure suggests the cause of its collapse was its own thorough incompetence, rather than an exogenous shock such as a monetary panic or bank run.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "City of Glasgow Bank". British Banking History Society. Archived from the original on 30 January 2014. Retrieved 5 June 2014.
  2. 1 2 "Desperate adventurers and men of straw: the failure of City of Glasgow Bank and its enduring impact on the UK banking system" (PDF). Bank of England.
  3. "Glasgow, 21 Glassford Street, City Of Glasgow Bank", Canmore, https://canmore.org.uk/site/140761/glasgow-21-glassford-street-city-of-glasgow-bank#783284
  4. "View of Trongate at junction with Nelson Street, Glasgow, including the City of Glasgow Bank. Titled: 'Trongate Nelson Street", canmore, https://canmore.org.uk/collection/1166097
  5. Williams, David, The Glasgow Guide 1998, p53; ISBN 0-86241-840-2
  6. Grossman, Richard (2010). Unsettled Account: The Evolution of Banking in the Industrialized World since 1800. Princeton University Press. p. 96. ISBN   978-1400835256.
  7. "Records of City of Glasgow Bank, bankers, Glasgow, Scotland". University of Glasgow Archive Services.
  8. "Bank must restore confidence". The Scotsman. 14 September 2007. Retrieved 5 June 2014.
  9. Lloyd Pritchard, Muriel F. (1970). An Economic History of New Zealand to 1939. Auckland: Collins. p. 155.
  10. 1 2 3 Rosenblum, Leo (December 1933). "The Failure of the City of Glasgow Bank". The Accounting Review (subscription required). 8 (4): 285–291. JSTOR   238146.
  11. Nehme, Marina; Hyland, Margaret (2008). "Houldsworth: An Obsolete Piece in the Legislative Puzzle". University of Western Sydney Law Review. Retrieved 22 March 2016.
  12. "Receipt for donation to relief fund". The Glasgow Story.
  13. Manfred Pohl, Sabine Freitag, ed. (1994). Handbook on the History of European Banks. European Association for Banking History. p. 1145. ISBN   9781781954218.
  14. Cottrell, P. J. (2004). Roderick Floud, Paul A. Johnson (ed.). Cambridge Economic History of Modern Britain. Vol. 2. p. 274. ISBN   9780521527378.
  15. "TheGlasgowStory: Alexander Bennett McGrigor".
  16. "JS Kennedy and the city of Glasgow bank". Dissertations in economic and business history.
  17. "Recent Heavy Failures.; the Breaking of the City of Glasgow Bank. ITS Credit Known to Have Been Shaken Ten Years Great Dividends Paid Reckless System of Business Failure of a London Firm of East India Merchants". The New York Times. 4 October 1878.
  18. "Bank of Scotland (1695- )". Archived from the original on 5 December 2008. Retrieved 23 December 2008.
  19. Scotland’s ghost of banking meltdown past www.sundayherald.com, retrieved 2008-12-23 Archived 24 December 2008 at the Wayback Machine

Notes

  1. The Nelson St reference in Canmore is an error: should be Albion St