Kargil Review Committee

Last updated

The Kargil Review Committee (KRC) was set up by the Government of India on 29 July 1999, three days after the end of the Kargil War. The committee was set up "to examine the sequence of events and make recommendations for the future". [1] [2] [3]

Contents

Site of the conflict Kargil.map.gif
Site of the conflict
The report was submitted to the Prime Minister of India, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, on 7 January 2000 The Prime Minister Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee delivering his speech at the 12th SAARC Summit in Islamabad, Pakistan on January 4, 2004 (1) (cropped).jpg
The report was submitted to the Prime Minister of India, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, on 7 January 2000

Over a hundred senior military, civil service and intelligence officials, politicians, including former prime ministers, diplomats and journalists were interviewed by the committee over a period of five months. The report was completed on 15 December 1999 and was tabled in the Parliament of India on 23 February 2000. [4] [5] [6] Certain parts of the final KRC report, such as the findings, have remained confidential.

The Committee found numerous flaws on multiple level of intelligence collection, operational strategies and procedural sharing of data. [7] [8] As per the KRC's recommendations, a Group of Ministers (GoM) and several task forces were set up to do a complete review of the Indian security system. The GoM subsequently conducted a comprehensive review of the entire security apparatus. This became the first review of its kind in independent India's history to be made public, although in the interests of national security, the government initially redacted several parts. The recommendations of the KRC report and the GoM report led to far-reaching changes in the Indian security apparatus.

Background

The Kargil Review Committee laid out the context of the report. They noted that the national security system in the country had seen very little changes since the 52-year-old framework outlined by Hastings Ismay and recommended by Louis Mountbatten. In these 52 years, India had undergone the Sino-Indian War, the Indo-Pakistani War of 1965, and the Indo-Pakistani War of 1971, as well as increased nuclear danger, the Cold War, persistence of the hybrid war in Kashmir for more than ten years, and a revolution in military affairs elsewhere. [9]

India tried major defence reforms following the Sino-Indian War in 1962, but these did not address national security in a holistic way. They decided to assess defence needs on a five-year basis, leading to the First Defence Plan. The Ministry of Defence and, subsequently the Department of Defence Production, Defence Research and Development Organisation and services headquarters, set up planning cells and units. A Joint Intelligence Committee was also formed. The Directorate General of Defence Planning Staff, composed of officers of various services, was formed to synergise defence planning under the Chiefs of Staff Committee in 1986. [10]

Members

Brajesh Mishra, the national security advisor at the time. Brajesh Mishra.jpg
Brajesh Mishra, the national security advisor at the time.

The committee consisted of:

Brajesh Mishra, the national security advisor at the time, assisted in the establishment of the Kargil Review Committee. [11]

Timeline

Kargil Review Committee report

The Kargil Review Committee was initially given a period of three months to submit the report. The deadline was later extended to 15 December 1999, giving the committee five months instead. In the report, the committee pointed out that they would not assign any individual blame. [13] The report's scope was to

review the events leading up to the Pakistani aggression in the Kargil District of Ladakh in Jammu & Kashmir; and to recommend such measures as are considered necessary to safeguard national security against such armed intrusions.

Over a hundred senior military, civil service and intelligence officials, politicians, including former prime ministers, diplomats and journalists were interviewed. [5] Unlike previous reports of a similar nature, this report was published and made publicly available, though some parts were blanked. [14]

The second and third chapters of the report are devoted to a historical background of the events leading up to the war, covering issues such as the Simla Agreement, Pakistan's attempts at internationalising the Kashmir issue, the "Rajiv-Benazir" interlude, Siachen, the Indo-Pak dialogue in general and the impact of the proxy war on the Indian Army. Chapter 5 reconstructs the Kargil intrusion. In Chapter 6, the committee outlines the role and function of intelligence agencies. Chapters 7 and 8 discusses and analyses intelligence on the Kargil issue, as well as the army's subsequent response. Chapter 13 and 14 summarises the findings and offers further recommendations. [13]

Findings

General Pervez Musharraf Pervez Musharraf - World Economic Forum Annual Meeting Davos 2008 numb2.jpg
General Pervez Musharraf

Chapter 13 of the report outlines the findings of the committee. It clearly states that the intrusion had been a surprise for the Indian government. After elaborating on the history of the "Kargil plan", the committee discusses the government's, army's, and media's respective responses. They then outline the intelligence findings, elaborating on the role of the Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW), Intelligence Bureau and the military intelligence collection just prior to the war, as well as the lack of inter-agency coordination. The Kargil Review Committee found R&AW's human intelligence to be weak, [7] but Chapter 14 also praises the interception of telephone conversations of Pervez Musharraf in China. The KRC report also acknowledges the work of the Aviation Research Centre of R&AW, which produced aerial intelligence after the intrusion's detection. The report goes into detail regarding the nuclear, technological and media effects of the incident. [7]

The report also mentions that the Kargil War could perhaps have been avoided if troops had been stationed there, but also notes that had troops been stationed there all year round and the conflict had still occurred, it would have resulted in huge costs "and enabled Pakistan to bleed India." [5]

Recommendations

The KRC suggested a "thorough review of the national security system in its entirety", conducted by a credible body of experts. It also suggested that various task forces should also review specific parts of the system, including:

Group of Ministers

Following the Kargil Review Committee report, a Group of Ministers (GoM) was set up by the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) on 17 April 2000 to consider the recommendations in the Kargil Review Committee. The GoM consisted of the ministers of home affairs, defence, external affairs and finance. Brajesh Mishra, the National Security Advisor, was also assigned as a special guest to the meetings of the GoM and the Cabinet Secretariat provided help to the group. [15]

The GoM established task forces, as suggested in the KRC report:

The GoM came out with its own report "Reforming the National Security System". [16] It was submitted to Prime Minister Vajpayee on 26 February 2001. [17]

Implementation and impact

Among the recommendations in the Kargil Review Committee report, the following have been implemented:

The Kargil Review Committee also recommended that the government find ways to reduce the pension expenditure, which has not yet been implemented.

From among the recommendations in the GoM report, the following have been implemented:

Aftermath

Following the Kargil Review Committee, Group of Ministers and the task forces, other committees have been formed to follow up on the Kargil Review Committee recommendations and further assess national security. These groups include the Standing Committee on Defence in 2007, Naresh Chandra task force [22] in 2011 and the Ravindra Gupta task force in 2012. [23]

Standing Committee on Defence review

On July 2007, the Standing Committee on Defence and the Ministry of Defence presented a report titled "Review of Implementation Status of Group of Ministers (GoMs) Report on Reforming National Security System in Pursuance to Kargil Review Committee Report—A Special Reference to Management of Defence" as a follow-up to the Kargil Review Committee report and the Group of Minister report. [24]

Naresh Chandra Naresh Chandra July 2012.jpg
Naresh Chandra

Naresh Chandra task force

In 2011, the Naresh Chandra task force reviewed the recommendations of the Kargil Review Committee, assessed the implementation and accordingly suggested new changes needed related to national security. [25] The task force was led by Naresh Chandra and comprised thirteen other members. The committee submitted its report on 23 May 2012. [10]

According to the task force many of the main recommendations of the Kargil Review Committee have not been implemented, such as recommendations related to defence procurement. The task force further suggested framing a National Security Doctrine (National Security Strategy) among other things. [22] [26]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Office of National Assessments</span> Australian former intelligence agency

The Office of National Assessments (ONA) was an Australian statutory intelligence agency established by the Office of National Assessments Act 1977 as an independent statutory body directly accountable to the Prime Minister of Australia as a portfolio agency of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. ONA provided all-source assessments on international political, strategic and economic developments to the Prime Minister and the National Security Committee of Cabinet. ONA also played a coordination role in the Australian Intelligence Community through evaluating foreign intelligence products, convening the National Intelligence Coordination Committee, and developing relationships with intelligence agencies around world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kargil War</span> 1999 India–Pakistan conflict

The Kargil War, also known as the Kargil conflict, was fought between India and Pakistan from May to July 1999 in the Kargil district of Jammu and Kashmir and elsewhere along the Line of Control (LoC). In India, the conflict is also referred to as Operation Vijay, which was the codename of the Indian military operation in the region. The Indian Air Force acted jointly with the Indian Army to flush out the Pakistan Army and paramilitary troops from vacated Indian positions along the LoC, in what was designated as Operation Safed Sagar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">K. Subrahmanyam</span> Indian civil servant (1929–2011)

Krishnaswamy Subrahmanyam was a prominent international strategic affairs analyst, journalist and former Indian civil servant. Considered a proponent of Realpolitik, Subrahmanyam was an influential voice in Indian security affairs for a long time. He was most often referred to as the doyen of India's strategic affairs community, and as the premier ideological champion of India's nuclear deterrent. His son S Jaishankar was appointed India's External Affairs Minister in 2019.

The Australian Intelligence Community (AIC) and the National Intelligence Community (NIC) or National Security Community of the Australian Government are the collectives of statutory intelligence agencies, policy departments, and other government agencies concerned with protecting and advancing the national security and national interests of the Commonwealth of Australia. The intelligence and security agencies of the Australian Government have evolved since the Second World War and the Cold War and saw transformation and expansion during the Global War on Terrorism with military deployments in Afghanistan, Iraq and against ISIS in Syria. Key international and national security issues for the Australian Intelligence Community include terrorism and violent extremism, cybersecurity, transnational crime, the rise of China, and Pacific regional security.

The National Security Council (NSC) of India is an executive government agency tasked with advising the Prime Minister's Office on matters of national security and strategic interest. It was established by the former Prime Minister of India Atal Bihari Vajpayee on 19 November 1998, with Brajesh Mishra as the first National Security Advisor. Prior to the formation of the NSC, these activities were overseen by the Principal Secretary to the preceding Prime Minister.

The Aviation Research Centre (ARC) is India's imagery intelligence organisation, a part of the Directorate General of Security, run by the Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW). It started functioning in November 1962, in the wake of the Sino-Indian War, as an extension of the Intelligence Bureau, but placed under the Ministry of External Affairs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ministry of Defence (India)</span> Indian Executive Department

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) is charged with coordinating and supervising all agencies and functions of the government relating directly to national security and the Indian Armed Forces. The President of India is the ceremonial commander-in-chief of the armed forces of the country. The Ministry of Defence provides policy framework and resources to the armed forces to discharge their responsibility in the context of the defence of the country. The Indian Armed Forces and Indian Coast Guard under the Ministry of Defence are primarily responsible for ensuring the territorial integrity of India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Technical Research Organisation</span> Technical intelligence agency of India

The National Technical Research Organisation (NTRO) is a technical intelligence agency under the National Security Advisor in the Prime Minister's Office, India. It was set up in 2004.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sashastra Seema Bal</span> Indian border guarding force for Indo-Nepalese and Indo-Bhutanese borders

Sashastra Seema Bal is a border guarding force of India deployed along its borders with Nepal and Bhutan. It is one of the seven Central Armed Police Forces under the administrative control of the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Defence Intelligence Agency (India)</span> Agency within the Ministry of Defence of India

The Defence Intelligence Agency (DIA) is an intelligence agency responsible for providing and coordinating defence and military intelligence to the Indian Armed Forces.

From the 1991 India economic crisis to its status of third largest economy in the world by 2011, India has grown significantly in terms of economic development, so has its banking sector. During this period, recognizing the evolving needs of the sector, the Finance Ministry of the Government of India set up various committees with the task of analyzing India's banking sector and recommending legislation and regulations to make it more effective, competitive and efficient.

The 7th Central Pay Commission (7CPC), constituted in February 2014 the principles and structure of emoluments of all central government civilian employees including defence forces in India, submitted its report on 19 November 2015. 7CPC's recommendations affects the organization, rank structure, pay, allowances and pension, of 13,86,171 armed forces personnel. This helps A salary monitoring system is designed to determine and suggest needed changes to the salaries of government employees.page 105, para 6.2.2[3]

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Security Committee (Australia)</span> National security and major foreign policy body in Australia

The National Security Committee (NSC), also known as the National Security Committee of Cabinet, is the peak decision-making body for national security and major foreign policy matters in the Australian Government. It is a committee of the Cabinet of Australia, though decisions of the NSC do not require the endorsement of the Cabinet itself.

The Defence Planning Committee is a senior decision-making organisation created on 19 April 2018 by the Government of India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Integrated Defence Staff</span> Tri-service Defense organization of the Indian Armed Forces

The Integrated Defence Staff (IDS) is an organisation responsible for fostering coordination and enabling prioritisation across the different branches of the Indian Armed Forces. It is composed of representatives from the Indian Army, Indian Navy, Indian Air Force, Ministry of External Affairs, Defence Research and Development Organisation, Ministry of Defence and Ministry of Finance. The IDS is headed by Chief of Integrated Defence Staff along with Deputy Chiefs of Integrated Defence Staff. On December 24, 2019, the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) established the post of Chief of Defence Staff, a four-star general, a tri-service Chief, that shall lead the defence forces as well as play the role of head of the Department of Military Affairs. The body advises and assists the Chief of Defence Staff.

The Defence Cyber Agency (DCyA) is a tri-service command of the Indian Armed Forces. Headquartered in New Delhi, the agency is tasked with handling cyber security threats. The DCyA draws personnel from all three branches of the Armed Forces. The head of the DCyA is an officer of two-star rank, and reports to the Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) through the Integrated Defence Staff (IDS).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chief of Defence Staff (India)</span> Leader of the Indian Armed Forces

The Chief of Defence Staff of the Indian Armed Forces (CDS) is the professional head and permanent Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff Committee (COSC) of the Indian Armed Forces. The Chief of Defence Staff is the highest-ranking uniformed officer on active duty in the Indian military and chief military adviser to the Minister of Defence. The Chief also heads the Department of Military Affairs. The CDS is assisted by a vice-chief of defence staff,

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Armed Forces Special Operations Division</span> Joint formation of the Indian Armed Forces responsible for special operations

The Armed Forces Special Operations Division (AFSOD) is a tri-service command of the Indian Armed Forces. The division is tasked to carry out special operations. The AFSOD draws personnel from all three special warfare branches of the Armed Forces.

The Defence Space Agency (DSA) is a tri-service agency of the Indian Armed Forces. Headquartered in Bengaluru, Karnataka, India. The agency is tasked with operating the space-warfare and Satellite Intelligence assets of India. The DSA draws personnel from all three branches of the Armed Forces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Indian Armed Forces Tri-Service Commands</span>

Integrated Theatre Commands of the Indian Armed Forces are varying degrees of synergy and cross–service cooperation between the military wings of the Indian Armed Forces. Following Independence, in 1949 a joint educational framework was set up starting with the first tri-service academy in the world, the National Defence Academy, and over the years this joint educational framework has been expanded to bring officers from the different services together at different stages of their careers.

References

  1. ↑ "Kargil : Subrahmanyam Committee's Report". Indian News. Archived from the original on 19 October 2006. Retrieved 20 October 2009.
  2. ↑ Jayal, BD. "The Kargil Review Committee Report A Mindset Frozen in 1962 Era". South Asia Terrorism Portal. Archived from the original on 8 October 2017. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  3. ↑ "Executive Summary of the Kargil Committee Report". nuclearweaponarchive.org. Archived from the original on 4 July 2018. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  4. 1 2 Menon, Air Marshal Narayan (July–September 2009). "Downhill from Kargil". Indian Defence Review. Archived from the original on 23 April 2018. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  5. 1 2 3 Bedi, Rahul (22–28 April 2000). "Kargil Report: More Questions Raised than Answered". Economic and Political Weekly. 35 (17): 1429–1431. JSTOR   4409195.
  6. ↑ Swami, Praveen (22 January 2000). "A committee and some questions: A first-person account with regard to the Kargil Review Committee Report and its implications". Frontline. The Hindu Group. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  7. 1 2 3 Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses Task Force Report (2012). A Case for Intelligence Reforms in India (PDF). New Delhi: Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses. pp. 25, 26. ISBN   9789382169031. Archived (PDF) from the original on 21 December 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  8. ↑ Kanwal, Gurmeet; Chansoria, Monika (2009). "Report of the Kargil Review Committee: An Appraisal (Interview of Mr K Subrahmanyam, Chairman of the Kargil Review Committee)" (PDF). Centre for Land Warfare Studies. Archived (PDF) from the original on 11 July 2016. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  9. ↑ Singh, Satyindra. "The Kargil Review Committee Report: Much to Learn and Implement". South Asia Terrorism Portal. Archived from the original on 14 December 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  10. 1 2 Gurmeet, Kanwal (2013). "Defence Reforms: Managing Threats and Challenges to National Security" (PDF). Centre for Land Warfare Studies. CLAWS Journal. Archived (PDF) from the original on 11 July 2016. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  11. ↑ Gupta, Arvind (30 September 2012). "Brajesh Mishra's Legacy to National Security and Diplomacy". MP-Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses. Archived from the original on 20 June 2018. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  12. ↑ Prof. A. Lakshmisagar, H. K. Javare Gowda, Krishna Kumar Birla (19 April 2001). Rajya Sabha Official Debates: Report of the Kargil Review Committee. Parliament of India.
  13. 1 2 Kargil Review Committee (July 2000). From Surprise To Reckoning: The Kargil Review Committee Report . New Delhi. Sage Publications. ISBN   9780761994664
  14. ↑ Swami, Praveen (10 November 2000). "The Kargil Story". The Hindu. Archived from the original on 20 December 2001. Retrieved 20 October 2009.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  15. ↑ "GoM Report on National Security, Chapter 1. Appointment, Approach and Methodology" (PDF). Vivekananda International Foundation . Archived (PDF) from the original on 15 December 2017. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  16. ↑ Rana, Vijai Singh (May 2016). "Status Of Jointness In Indian Security Apparatus". Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses . Archived from the original on 27 December 2018. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  17. ↑ "'Group of Ministers' Report on "Reforming the National Security System"". Press Information Bureau, India. 23 May 2001. Archived from the original on 27 December 2018. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  18. 1 2 3 4 Ghosh, AK (9 February 2004). "CHAPTER V – Higher Defense Organisation in India Need for Reforms". University. hdl:10603/183362.
  19. ↑ Bedi, RS (23 April 2015). "NTRO: India's Technical Intelligence Agency". Indian Defence Review. Archived from the original on 20 April 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  20. ↑ "Integrated Defence Staff – Vision and History". Integrated Defence Staff.
  21. ↑ Dutta, Prabhash K. (26 September 2018). "Tracing the Aadhaar journey: From Kargil to Supreme Court". India Today. Archived from the original on 6 December 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  22. 1 2 Joseph, Josy (26 July 2012). "13 years on, Kargil panel report still ignored". The Times of India. Archived from the original on 6 January 2019. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  23. ↑ Kanwal, Gurmeet (31 December 2015). "Restructuring Defence Reforms for National Security". Indian Defence Review. Archived from the original on 19 April 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.
  24. ↑ Standing Committee on Defence, Ministry of Defence, 14th Lok Sabha (July 2007). "Review of Implementation Status of Group of Ministers (GoMs) Report on Reforming National Security System in Pursuance to Kargil Review Committee Report—A Special Reference to Management of Defence" (PDF). Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses. Lok Sabha Secretariat. Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 October 2012. Retrieved 12 December 2018.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  25. ↑ Joshi, Manoj (March 2014). "Policy Report: The Unending Quest to Reform India National Security System" (PDF). S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS). Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  26. ↑ Raman, Raghu (26 July 2017). "Why Is India Still Ignoring Lessons Learnt From the Kargil War?". The Wire. Archived from the original on 21 December 2018. Retrieved 12 December 2018.

Bibliography

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.