Michael Tugendhat

Last updated

The Honourable

Sir Michael Tugendhat
Born
Michael George Tugendhat

(1944-10-21) 21 October 1944 (age 78)
Bishop's Stortford, Hertfordshire, England
Other namesThe Hon. Mr Justice Tugendhat
Education Ampleforth College
Alma mater Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge
Occupation High Court judge
Known forMedia law cases
Spouse
Blandine de Loisne
​
(m. 1970)​
[1]
Children Tom Tugendhat and 3 others

Sir Michael George Tugendhat (born 21 October 1944), [1] styled The Hon. Mr Justice Tugendhat, and referred to as Tugendhat J in legal writing, is a retired High Court judge in England and Wales. He was the High Court's senior media judge, taking over that role from Mr Justice Eady on 1 October 2010. [2]

Contents

Early life

Sir Michael Tugendhat is the son of Georg Tugendhat, an emigrant from Vienna, Austria, who founded a petrochemical refinery in Manchester, and his British wife Marie Littledale. [3] [4] His elder brother is Lord Tugendhat, a Conservative politician, businessman, and author, while one of his sons is Tom Tugendhat, a Conservative MP. [5] Sir Michael is married and has four sons. [1] [6] His father was from a Jewish family, and converted to Catholicism. [7] [8]

Education

Tugendhat attended Ampleforth College and Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, where he studied philosophy and classics. [6] [9] He won the Henry Fellowship to attend Yale Law School and studied at the Hague Academy of International Law before being called to the Bar by the Inner Temple in 1969. [6] He then joined Five Raymond Buildings, a set of barristers' chambers specialising in media and entertainment law. [10] [11]

Tugendhat was appointed Queen's Counsel in 1986. He became a Recorder of the Crown Court in 1994 and a deputy judge sitting in the High Court of Justice in 1995. [10] In 2000, he became a judge sitting in the appeal courts of Jersey and Guernsey. [10] He was appointed a High Court Judge, Queen's Bench division, in April 2003. [12] In 2010 he was appointed to be the Judge in Charge of the Queen's Bench jury lists. [13] He is a fellow of the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies. [12] He was formerly on the management committee of the Advice on Individual Rights in Europe Centre. [11] [14]

Described by The Guardian as "Britain's leading expert on privacy law", Tugendhat told the Commons' select committee on Culture, Media and Sport: [15]

We must never underestimate the asset we have in the free press and I am afraid a free press is bound to be one that occasionally gets it wrong either by malice or mistake.

Notable cases

Barrister

In 2000 Tugendhat acted for David and Victoria Beckham, who were petitioning the High Court to prevent the publication of a biography of them by Andrew Morton. The Beckhams claimed a portion of the book was derived from confidential information passed on by their former bodyguard, who was already enjoined from making public disclosures about the couple. Tugendhat called the bodyguard's conduct "a very bad case of disloyalty and breach of confidentiality" but opposing counsel, Geoffrey Robertson QC, argued that Morton and his publisher enjoyed protection of their free speech in this regard. The parties reached an out of court settlement and the book was published. [16]

In 2001 he represented The Sunday Times newspaper in its efforts to publish extracts from a book by former MI6 officer Richard Tomlinson. The Attorney General sought to compel newspapers to gain the approval of the Government before publishing such sensitive information. The court (Lord Phillips, Lord Justice Tuckey, and Lord Justice Longmore) ruled that, as the information had already been published in Russian newspaper Komsomolskaya Pravda , it was already in the public domain and so restraint on publication in the UK could not be justified. [17]

Later in 2001 he acted for a number of newspapers including The Times , the Daily Mirror and the Daily Mail , which sought to overturn a blanket ban on publishing unauthorised disclosures by former MI5 agents, including those of David Shayler. [18] The House of Lords ruled that the statutory prohibition on agents revealing secret information was proportionate and did not contravene Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. [19] [20]

Also in 2001 Tugendhat represented internet service provider Demon Internet, which sought to amend a ruling which would hold it responsible if any of its customers used the Demon service to identify the new identities of the killers of James Bulger. The court amended the order to indemnify Demon and other ISPs providing they took "all reasonable steps" to remove the infringing material. The order remained more onerous than Demon had wished – Tugendhat said of it "Happy would not be the word, but we have all signed it." [21]

In 2002, in the case Theakston v Mirror Group Newspapers Ltd , he represented TV presenter Jamie Theakston, who sought to enjoin newspapers from publishing a story about Theakston visiting a London brothel, arguing that, as the alleged visit took place in private, The Sunday People's publication of details infringed his right to privacy under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Refusing the application for the injunction, Mr Justice Ouseley said "It is not inherent in the nature of a brothel that all or anything that transpires within is confidential." [22] [23]

In 2003 Tugendhat appeared for actors Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta-Jones in Douglas v Hello! Ltd before the High Court. Douglas and Jones had sold rights to publish photographs of their 2000 wedding to celebrity news magazine OK! , but a paparazzo surreptitiously photographed the proceedings and sold his photographs to OK!'s competitor Hello . Douglas, Jones, and OK! sued Hello's publisher, alleging their privacy had been invaded and claiming £1.75 million in damages. [24] Rejecting the claim that the couple's selling photos of their wedding rendered the event "not genuinely private", Tugendhat argued "If Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta-Jones could not offer a slice without offering the whole cake, then their own freedom of expression is diminished." [25] The Douglases were successful in their claim; Hello successfully appealed to the Court of Appeal. The Douglases then appealed to the House of Lords which (in a combined ruling with OBG Ltd v Allan ), denied the appeal. [26]

Judge

In January 2010, Tugendhat overturned a superinjunction imposed on the application of the footballer John Terry which prevented the media from revealing details of his affair with team-mate Wayne Bridge's former girlfriend, Vanessa Perroncel, saying he did not feel the order was "necessary or proportionate". [27] He also criticised Terry's lawyers for not notifying newspapers of the action they were taking.

In June 2010, at an interim hearing in the case of Thornton v Telegraph Media Group, his ruling in favour of the Telegraph Media Group over Lynn Barber's review of Sarah Thornton's book, Seven Days in the Art World, was said to "raise the bar for libel claimants." [28] Amongst the allegations made in Barber's review that was the subject of the case, Barber had written that Thornton had given her interviewees copy approval, a practice of which journalists would "disapprove." Thornton considered this to be defamatory. Tugendhat accepted the argument of the Telegraph Media Group that there should be a "threshold of seriousness" for libel claims to prevent trivial claims and that a claimant should be able to demonstrate a "substantial effect" on their reputation to prove defamation. [29] However, the case went to trial in 2011, at which point Tugendhat ruled in favour of Thornton. During trial it was established that Barber had lied in her evidence to the court about the extent of her knowledge of the accusations published in her book review. [30] It emerged that Barber was fully aware that some of the accusations in her review were completely false, a fact which resulted in Tugendhat awarding Thornton £15,000 in malicious falsehood damages. [31] This was a notable award as it appears to have been the first award of general damages for malicious falsehood. [32] In the same judgment, Tugendhat went on to rule that other accusations in Barber's review were defamatory of Thornton, and awarded the latter a further £50,000 in damages. [33] By doing so, the judge overturned the Telegraph Media Group's "offer of amends" defence, [34] a first in English legal history.

In May 2011 Tugendhat partially lifted a gagging order brought by Sir Fred Goodwin, the former chief executive of the Royal Bank of Scotland, just hours after details of his alleged extra-marital affair were made public in the House of Lords. Tugendhat varied the injunction to allow publication of Goodwin's name, but not details of the alleged relationship and the name of the woman said to be involved. [35]

In November 2012, Tugendhat presided over an attempt by the Metropolitan Police to force claims against them relating to relationships between undercover police officers and unsuspecting women to be held in secret. (See National Public Order Intelligence Unit, Mark Kennedy (police officer), Bob Lambert.) He ruled in January 2013 that parts of these contentious cases (relating to the Human Rights Act) should be heard in a secret Investigatory Powers Tribunal, from which claimants are themselves excluded, and which to which there is no power of appeal. However, he ruled against the Metropolitan Police in relation to parts of the cases brought under common law, which will be held in the High Court rather than in secret. [36]

In May 2013, Tugendhat passed judgement in the landmark libel case McAlpine v Bercow, in which one-line tweet by Sally Bercow was judged defamatory [37] and led to an out-of-court settlement. [38]

Honours

Tugendhat was appointed Knight Bachelor on 20 May 2003 upon his appointment to the High Court. His investiture ceremony took place at Buckingham Palace on 25 June 2003 where he was knighted by Queen Elizabeth II. [39]

See also

Bibliography

Related Research Articles

Lynn Barber is a British journalist who has worked for many publications, including The Sunday Times.

Sir Charles Antony St John Gray was a British barrister and judge, who specialised in intellectual property, copyright, privacy and defamation cases. As a judge, he presided over the trial of David Irving's libel lawsuit against Professor Deborah Lipstadt and Penguin Books over claims that Irving was a Holocaust denier; Gray delivered a 349 pages long judgment against Irving.

David Blair is the Chief Foreign Correspondent for The Daily Telegraph, having formerly worked for the Financial Times as Energy Correspondent, and The Daily Telegraph as a Foreign Correspondent and then Diplomatic Editor.

Sir Thomas Scott Gillespie Baker, PC, KC is a retired English Court of Appeal judge.

Sir David Eady, KC is a retired High Court judge in England and Wales. As a judge, he is known for having presided over many high-profile libel and privacy cases.

Modern libel and slander laws in many countries are originally descended from English defamation law. The history of defamation law in England is somewhat obscure; civil actions for damages seem to have been relatively frequent as far back as the Statute of Gloucester in the reign of Edward I (1272–1307). The law of libel emerged during the reign of James I (1603–1625) under Attorney General Edward Coke who started a series of libel prosecutions. Scholars frequently attribute strict English defamation law to James I's outlawing of duelling. From that time, both the criminal and civil remedies have been found in full operation.

<i>Greene v Associated Newspapers Ltd</i> UK ruling on defamation cases

Greene v Associated Newspapers Ltd [2004] EWCA Civ 1462 is a case of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales that governs the use of injunctions against publication in alleged defamation cases. Greene, a businesswoman, sought an injunction against Associated Newspapers Ltd to prevent them publishing alleged links with Peter Foster; while they claimed to have emails showing links, she asserted that they were false. The test at the time for a preliminary injunction in defamation cases was Bonnard v Perryman, where it was established that the applicant has to show "a real prospect of success" at trial. The Human Rights Act 1998 established that judges should consider whether applicants are "more likely than not" to succeed at trial, a test applied to confidentiality cases in Cream Holdings Ltd v Banerjee and the Liverpool Post and Echo Ltd. Greene claimed that the Cream test should be applied rather than the Bonnard test.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rabinder Singh (judge)</span> British judge (born 1964)

Sir Rabinder Singh KC, styled The Rt. Hon. Lord Justice Singh, is a British Court of Appeal judge and President of the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, formerly a High Court judge of the Queen's Bench Division, a King's Counsel and barrister, formerly a founding member of Matrix Chambers and a legal academic.

Sir Duncan Brian Walter Ouseley, styled The Hon. Mr Justice Ouseley, is a recently retired High Court judge in England and Wales, Queen's Bench Division. He is notable for involvement in many legal cases reported in the British press.

WER v REW was an anonymised legal case in which Chris Hutcheson, represented by Hugh Tomlinson, QC, of Schillings, took out an injunction to prevent Popdog Ltd from publishing details regarding his private life, and was heard before Justice Sir Charles Grey in January 2009. Hutcheson – Gordon Ramsay's former business partner and father-in-law – gained an injunction but it was later partially lifted, and ultimately overturned in the Court of Appeal, with Hutcheson being publicly named by the judge.

Sir Richard Joseph Buxton, PC is a British judge and former Lord Justice of Appeal. He was appointed to the High Court of Justice on 11 January 1994, serving in the Queen's Bench Division. He was subsequently appointed to the Court of Appeal of England and Wales on 1 October 1997. He retired on 30 September 2008.

<i>McAlpine v Bercow</i> 2013 libel case

McAlpine v Bercow was a landmark libel case in 2013 between Conservative peer Lord McAlpine and Sally Bercow, the wife of John Bercow, Speaker of the House of Commons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Jay</span> British judge

Sir Robert Maurice Jay, styled The Hon. Mr Justice Jay, is a judge of the High Court of Justice of the Courts of England and Wales. He was counsel to the Leveson Inquiry.

Andrew George Lindsay Nicol is a retired judge of the High Court of England and Wales.

Sir James Richard William Goss KC, styled The Hon. Mr Justice Goss, is a judge of the High Court of England and Wales, assigned to the King's Bench Division. He was previously a Queen's Counsel, specialising in criminal law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mark Warby</span>

Sir Mark David John Warby PC, styled The Rt Hon. Lord Justice Warby, is a Lord Justice of Appeal.

Sir Christopher James Saunders French was a British barrister and judge who sat on the High Court of Justice. He is most commonly remembered as the judge who sat on the Sellafield cancer litigation, described as "one of the longest, most complicated and most expensive civil actions ever heard before a British court."

<i>Bent Coppers</i> Non-fiction book by Graeme McLagan

Bent Coppers: The Inside Story of Scotland Yard's Battle Against Police Corruption is a non-fiction book by award-winning British journalist Graeme McLagan. First published in the United Kingdom in 2003 by Orion Publishing Group, the book examines police corruption within the Metropolitan Police Service and South Eastern Regional Crime Squad—with particular focus on the 1990s and early 2000s—and the establishment and activities of the force's anti-corruption "Ghost Squad". Its publication led to a 4-year legal case resulting in a landmark ruling in English defamation law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">King's Bench Division</span>

The King's Bench Division of the High Court of Justice deals with a wide range of common law cases and has supervisory responsibility over certain lower courts.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "Tugendhat, Hon. Sir Michael (George), (born 21 Oct. 1944), a Judge of the High Court of Justice, Queen's Bench Division, 2003–14; Judge in charge of Queen's Bench jury and non-jury lists, 2010–14". Who's Who . 2007. doi:10.1093/ww/9780199540884.013.U38156.
  2. ↑ Preston, Peter (19 September 2010). "Mr Justice Tugendhat the libel judge of our dreams? Let's wait and see". The Guardian. Retrieved 17 October 2010.
  3. ↑ "German intelligence operations, agents and suspected agents". MI5, the Security Service. 27 August 2009. Archived from the original on 11 June 2011.
  4. ↑ "Papers of Dr Georg Tugendhat, industrialist and economist, concerning the Manchester Oil Refinery Limited and related interests, 1936–1964".
  5. ↑ Kunal Dutta (15 September 2010). "Mr Justice Eady to be replaced as senior judge on libel and privacy" . The Independent. Archived from the original on 14 May 2022.
  6. 1 2 3 "The Law of Privacy and the Media:About the Author(s)". Oxford University Press. March 2006.[ dead link ]
  7. ↑ "My name teaches me old hate is still alive". blogs.timesofisrael.com. 20 May 2020. Archived from the original on 10 June 2022. Retrieved 7 July 2022.
  8. ↑ May, Luke (13 December 2019). "Conservative Tom Tugendhat suffered antisemitism during Tonbridge and Malling General Election 2019 campaign". Kent Online. Archived from the original on 30 August 2021. Retrieved 30 August 2021.
  9. ↑ "Michael Tugendhat (W62) appointed as Senior Media Judge". Ampleforth College. 15 September 2010. Retrieved 4 May 2011.[ permanent dead link ]
  10. 1 2 3 "Tugendhat QC appointed to the Bench". 5RB. 8 May 2003.
  11. 1 2 "Memorandum submitted by Michael Tugendhat QC to the Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport". 17 February 2003.
  12. 1 2 "The Hon Mr Justice Tugendhat". Debrett's People of Today . Debrett's . Retrieved 21 November 2010.
  13. ↑ "Appointment of new judge in charge of the Queen's Bench Jury and Non-Jury Lists". Judicial Communications Office news release. 13 September 2010. Archived from the original on 23 June 2011.
  14. ↑ Henry Reichhold (2008). "Celebrating 15 Years from 1993 to 2008" (PDF). The AIRE Centre.
  15. ↑ Clare Dyer (18 April 2003). "Privacy law expert joins high court". The Guardian.
  16. ↑ "Posh and Becks settle book row". BBC News. 30 August 2000.
  17. ↑ Richard Norton-Taylor (26 January 2001). "MI6's lawyers lose spy book appeal". The Guardian.
  18. ↑ Richard Norton-Taylor (18 July 2001). "Guardian enters Shayler case to contest gagging". The Guardian.
  19. ↑ "R v Shayler (case report)". 5RB. Archived from the original on 10 August 2011.
  20. ↑ "Public interest defence not available in secrets prosecution". The Times . 22 March 2002.
  21. ↑ "Net firm wins Bulger ruling". BBC News. 10 July 2001.
  22. ↑ Joshua Rozenberg (15 February 2002). "Why judge let prostitutes tell on Theakston". The Daily Telegraph .
  23. ↑ Mr Justice Ouseley (14 February 2011). "Judgment (in the case between Theakston and MGN Limited)" (PDF). Queen's Bench Division, High Court of Justice. Archived from the original (PDF) on 25 August 2011.
  24. ↑ "Zeta Jones and Douglas begin court battle". The Daily Telegraph. 3 February 2003.
  25. ↑ Ciar Byrne (7 March 2003). "Zeta Jones offered wedding 'slice'". The Guardian.
  26. ↑ "2007 UKHL 21 : Judgments – OBG Limited and others (Appellants) v. Allan and others (Respondents)Douglas and another and others (Appellants) v. Hello! Limited and others (Respondents)Mainstream Properties Limited (Appellants) v. Young and others and another (Respondents)". House of Lords.
  27. ↑ Tryhorn, Chris (30 January 2010). "High court overturns superinjunction granted to England captain John Terry". The Guardian. Retrieved 21 November 2010.
  28. ↑ Greenslade, Roy (16 June 2010). "Judge's libel ruling enhances press freedom". The Guardian. Retrieved 21 November 2010.
  29. ↑ THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE TUGENDHAT (16 June 2010), Thornton v Telegraph Media Group Ltd [2010] EWHC 1414 (QB) , retrieved 25 October 2019
  30. ↑ "Sarah Thornton wins historic malicious falsehood and libel battle against Lynn Barber and the Daily Telegraph (press release) vs. Memorabilia". artdesigncafe.com. Retrieved 25 October 2019.
  31. ↑ THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE TUGENDHAT (26 July 2011), Thornton v Telegraph Media Group Ltd (Rev 1) [2011] EWHC 1884 (QB) , retrieved 25 October 2019
  32. ↑ "Case Law: Thornton v Telegraph Media Group, an offer of amends defence fails – Hugh Tomlinson QC [Updated]". Inforrm's Blog. 28 July 2011. Retrieved 25 October 2019.
  33. ↑ Halliday, Josh (26 July 2011). "Telegraph Media Group ordered to pay damages over Lynn Barber book review". The Guardian.
  34. ↑ Melville-Brown, Amber (19 February 2009). "Media law – offers of amends". Law Society Gazette.
  35. ↑ Halliday, Josh (19 May 2011). "Sir Fred Goodwin gagging order partially lifted by high court". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 25 October 2019.
  36. ↑ Evans, Rob; Lewis, Paul (17 January 2013). "Women who had relationships with police spies win partial legal victory". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 25 October 2019.
  37. ↑ Judgment in McAlpine v Bercow
  38. ↑ Sally Bercow tweet libelled Lord McAlpine The Guardian 24 May 2013
  39. ↑ "No. 56993". The London Gazette . 8 July 2003. p. 8473.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.