Handled the ball

Last updated

Michael Vaughan was the penultimate cricketer to be dismissed handled the ball in international cricket, in 2001. Michael Vaughan600.jpg
Michael Vaughan was the penultimate cricketer to be dismissed handled the ball in international cricket, in 2001.

Handled the ball was formerly one of the methods of dismissing a batsman in the sport of cricket, but was integrated into the Law on obstructing the field when the Laws of Cricket were rewritten in 2017. [1] It dictated that either batsman can be given out if they intentionally touch the ball with a hand that is not holding their bat. An exception was given if the batsman handled the ball to avoid injury. It was governed by Law 33 of the 2000 Edition of the Laws, and was a rare way for a batsman to be dismissed: in the history of cricket, there have been 61 instances in first-class matches and 5 occasions in List A games. In most cases this occurred when a batsman thought that the ball was going to hit their wicket, and knocked it away from the stumps with their hand.

Contents

In international cricket, only ten dismissals have been in this fashion; on seven occasions in Test cricket and three times in One Day Internationals. The South African Russell Endean became the first victim of this method in international cricket when he was dismissed in a 1957 Test match against England. The final occurrence was in an ODI in 2015, when Chamu Chibhabha of Zimbabwe was given out against Afghanistan national cricket team. After the rebranding of the law, Mushfiqur Rahim handled the ball in a test match against New Zealand. On appeal, he was given out 'Obstructing the field'.

Definition

Handled the ball was Law 33 in the Laws of Cricket established by the Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC). [2] A batsman could be given out for handling the ball if, while playing a delivery, the batsman intentionally touched the ball with one or both of their hands not holding the bat. A decision of not out would be reached if the batsman handled the ball to avoid incurring an injury. [2] A bowler did not receive credit for the wicket when a batsman was dismissed in this fashion. [2]

History

As a method of dismissal, handling the ball was included in the Laws of Cricket from the original code, written in 1744. In that document, it stated that "If ye Striker touches or takes up ye Ball before she is lain quite still, unless asked by ye Bowler or Wicket-keeper, its out." [3] Similar wording remained in the revision made to the laws thirty years later. [4] The first batsman to be dismissed for handling the ball in first-class cricket was James Grundy, who suffered the fate while playing for the MCC against Kent in 1857. [5] Prior to 1899, a batsman could be given out for handling the ball even if they were doing so to remove a ball which had got stuck in their equipment or clothing. [6] At the time, if one of the fielders removed the ball from the batsman's clothing, they could claim a catch. [7] It was in such a situation that George Bennett, the first player to be given out handled the ball in English county cricket, was dismissed in 1872. [8] The wicket of William Scotton in early 1887 was described by Gerald Brodribb as "most unusual". [7] In a match between the smokers and the non-smokers involved in the 1886–87 Ashes series, Scotton faced the final delivery of the contest. Eager to claim the ball as a souvenir of the high-scoring match, he defended the delivery and picked the ball up. The fielders—who also wanted the souvenir—appealed, and Scotton was ruled out. [7]

An addition was made to the law in 1950 to allow umpires to give a batsman not out if the ball should strike the hand after "an involuntary action by the striker in the throwing up of a hand to protect his person". [6] For a time, the act of handing the ball back to the fielding side was listed as not out under Law 33, and instead was considered to be part of a different method of dismissal: obstructing the field, covered in Law 37. [9] The illegal nature of this offence was later returned to Law 33, [2] but reverted to Law 37 in 2013. [10] In 1948 the MCC issued a reminder to batsman, advising them not to handle the ball for any reason at any point during a cricket match, but it is relatively common for batsmen to pick the ball up and return it to the fielding side. [11] Charles Wright was the first player to be dismissed for returning the ball to a fielder in first-class cricket; albeit wrongly. Brodribb relates that in an 1893 match, W. G. Grace influenced Wright to return the ball to him, and upon doing so, appealed. The umpire dismissed Wright, despite a clause added to the law nine years previous stating that a batsman would not be ruled out if they were returning the ball at the request of the fielding side. [12]

In 2013, the law received a major change. Prior to this, there had been ambiguity in certain situations whether handling the ball or obstructing the field was applicable. This ambiguity was removed by setting a clear demarcation point between the two as the point when the striker has "finished playing the ball": before this point, handling the ball applies; thereafter, obstructing the field applies. The result was that only the striker could be dismissed handled ball, and only during the short period when the striker was playing (or attempting to play) the ball, either as a first or subsequent stroke. The act of handing the ball back to the fielding side, mentioned above, was therefore no longer regarded as the striker playing the ball, resulting in this event then being dealt with under obstructing the field. [10]

In March 2017 it was announced by the MCC that the law on handled the ball would be completely removed and subsumed into the law on obstructing the field. This means that the act of handling the ball will still result in the batsman's dismissal, but will now always be recorded as obstructing the field. The new law came into effect on 1 October 2017. [1]

In total, there were 63 occasions on which a batsman has been given out handled the ball in first-class cricket and 5 instances in List A cricket. [13] [14] Brodribb suggests that it is likely that there should have been a significant number more dismissals than there have been for handling the ball: in addition to the cases where batsman have returned the ball to the fielding side without permission, there are records of cases in which the umpires have been reticent to uphold an appeal. On one such instance, the umpire David Constant rejected an appeal against Younis Ahmed, saying that he thought the appeal was not serious. [11]

Occasions in international cricket

Andrew Hilditch is the only non-striking batsman to have been given out for handling the ball in international cricket. Andrew Hilditch 2.jpg
Andrew Hilditch is the only non-striking batsman to have been given out for handling the ball in international cricket.

The first occasion of a batsman being given out handled the ball in international cricket occurred during a Test match between South Africa and England in Cape Town in 1957. [16] [17] [18] In the second innings of the match, the South African Russell Endean padded away a delivery from Jim Laker. The ball looped off his pads into the air, and was falling towards his stumps until Endean instinctively knocked it away with his free hand. [19] He later suggested that he had "thought of heading it away, but that seemed too theatrical." [20] The second instance came 22 years later during a bad-tempered series between Australia and Pakistan that also involved another rare dismissal method: Mankading. [21] Andrew Hilditch was the victim in this match; he picked up the ball and returned it to the bowler after a wayward throw from a fielder. The bowler, Sarfraz Nawaz, appealed for the wicket and Hilditch was given out. [22] Another Pakistan player, Asif Iqbal, distanced himself from the incident, commenting that he felt "there was no need for us to stoop so low as to appeal against Hilditch". [15] Hilditch's dismissal marked the only time that a non-striking batsman has been given out for handling the ball. [15] The next case also occurred in another match between Australia and Pakistan. Mohsin Khan defended a delivery from Geoff Lawson, which then landed behind him. Mohsin pushed the ball away from the stumps with his hand, resulting in the wicket. [23]

Desmond Haynes was the fourth man to be dismissed for handling the ball in Test cricket, just over a year after Mohsin. Facing India in late 1983, Haynes had been struck on the bat and pad by the ball, which then headed towards the stumps. The West Indian batsman redirected the ball away from the stumps with his free hand. [24] Upon being given out, Haynes—who was ignorant of the law regarding handling the ball—argued with the umpire about the dismissal. [25] After asking the bowler, Kapil Dev, if he wanted to withdraw his appeal, the umpire sent Haynes back to the pavilion. [24] The first instance in One Day Internationals was in 1986, when the Indian batsman Mohinder Amarnath knocked away a turning delivery from Australia's Greg Matthews that was heading for the stumps. [26] In 1993, Graham Gooch became the only player to be dismissed for handling the ball after scoring a century. Playing defensively to try and draw the Test match against Australia, Gooch blocked a short ball from Merv Hughes. [27] The ball flicked off his bat and fell towards his stumps, prompting Gooch to instinctively punch the ball away: Australia won the match by 179 runs. [28]

The dismissal of Daryll Cullinan in 1999 was the second instance in ODIs: facing the West Indian spinner Keith Arthurton, Cullinan fended the ball off into the ground. It bounced high in the air, and Cullinan removed his right hand from his bat to catch it as it fell again. [29] Despite the fact that it was unlikely that the ball would land near the stumps, the West Indies captain, Brian Lara, appealed, and Cullinan was dismissed. [30] The next occurrence was two years later, in a Test match between Australia and India. In the first innings of the match, Steve Waugh was struck on the pads by a delivery from Harbhajan Singh. The umpire turned down the appeal, but as he did so, the ball bounced and spun towards the stumps. [31] Waugh was alerted by a shout from the non-striking batsman, and instinctively swept the ball away with his free hand. [32] The most recent instance came during the same year as Waugh's dismissal, in another Test match involving India. England's Michael Vaughan missed an attempted sweep against Sarandeep Singh, and the ball trickled along the ground after striking his pads. Vaughan brushed the ball away with his hand, despite the fact that it was not travelling towards the stumps. [33] Initially, he claimed that he was attempting to give the ball back to the fielder at short leg, [34] but he later admitted that he "should have just held up [his] hands and said 'I got it all wrong, I'm an idiot.'" [35]

Batsmen dismissed in international cricket

No.BatsmanRunsTeamOppositionVenueMatch dateFormatRef
1 Russell Endean 3Flag of South Africa (1928-1982).svg  South Africa Flag of England.svg  England Newlands, Cape Town 1 January 1957Test [36]
2 Andrew Hilditch 29Flag of Australia (converted).svg  Australia Flag of Pakistan.svg  Pakistan WACA, Perth 24 March 1979Test [37]
3 Mohsin Khan 58Flag of Pakistan.svg  Pakistan Flag of Australia (converted).svg  Australia National Stadium, Karachi 22 September 1982Test [38]
4 Desmond Haynes 55WestIndiesCricketFlagPre1999.svg  West Indies Flag of India.svg  India Wankhede Stadium, Bombay 24 November 1983Test [39]
5 Mohinder Amarnath 15Flag of India.svg  India Flag of Australia (converted).svg  Australia Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne 9 February 1986ODI [40]
6 Graham Gooch 133Flag of England.svg  England Flag of Australia (converted).svg  Australia Old Trafford, Manchester 3 June 1993Test [41]
7 Daryll Cullinan 46Flag of South Africa.svg  South Africa WestIndiesCricketFlagPre1999.svg  West Indies Kingsmead, Durban 27 January 1999ODI [42]
8 Steve Waugh 47Flag of Australia (converted).svg  Australia Flag of India.svg  India MA Chidambaram Stadium, Chennai 18 March 2001Test [43]
9 Michael Vaughan 64Flag of England.svg  England Flag of India.svg  India M Chinnaswamy Stadium, Bangalore 19 December 2001Test [44]
10 Chamu Chibhabha 18Flag of Zimbabwe.svg  Zimbabwe Flag of Afghanistan (2013-2021).svg  Afghanistan Queens Sports Club, Bulawayo 20 October 2015ODI [45]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leg before wicket</span> Cricket rule

Leg before wicket (lbw) is one of the ways in which a batter can be dismissed in the sport of cricket. Following an appeal by the fielding side, the umpire may rule a batter out lbw if the ball would have struck the wicket but was instead intercepted by any part of the batsman's body. The umpire's decision will depend on a number of criteria, including where the ball pitched, whether the ball hit in line with the wickets, the ball's expected future trajectory after hitting the batsman, and whether the batsman was attempting to hit the ball.

The Laws of Cricket is a code that specifies the rules of the game of cricket worldwide. The earliest known code was drafted in 1744. Since 1788, the code has been owned and maintained by the private Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC) in Lord's Cricket Ground, London. There are currently 42 Laws, which describe all aspects of how the game is to be played. MCC has re-coded the Laws six times, each with interim revisions that produce more than one edition. The most recent code, the seventh, was released in October 2017; its 3rd edition came into force on 1 October 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wicket-keeper</span> Fielding position in cricket

The wicket-keeper in the sport of cricket is the player on the fielding side who stands behind the wicket or stumps being watchful of the batsman and ready to take a catch, stump the batsman out and run out a batsman when occasion arises. The wicket-keeper is the only member of the fielding side permitted to wear gloves and external leg guards. The role of the keeper is governed by Law 27 and of the Laws of Cricket.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wicket</span> One of the two sets of three stumps and two bails at either end of a cricket pitch

In cricket, the term wicket has several meanings:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Glossary of cricket terms</span> Cricketing terminology

This is a general glossary of the terminology used in the sport of cricket. Where words in a sentence are also defined elsewhere in this article, they appear in italics. Certain aspects of cricket terminology are explained in more detail in cricket statistics and the naming of fielding positions is explained at fielding (cricket).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dismissal (cricket)</span> Cricket terminology

In cricket, a dismissal occurs when a batter's innings is brought to an end by the opposing team. Other terms used are the batter being out, the batting side losing a wicket, and the fielding side taking a wicket. The ball becomes dead, and the dismissed batter must leave the field of play for the rest of their team's innings, to be replaced by a team-mate. A team's innings ends if ten of the eleven team members are dismissed. Players bat in pairs so, when only one batter remains who can be not out, it is not possible for the team to bat any longer. This is known as dismissing or bowling out the batting team, who are said to be all out.

Obstructing the field is one of the nine methods of dismissing a batsman in the sport of cricket. Either batsman can be given out if he wilfully attempts to obstruct or distract the fielding side by word or action. It is Law 37 of the Laws of cricket, and is a rare way for a batsman to be dismissed; in the history of cricket, there has been only two instances in Test matches, six occasions in One Day International (ODI) games, and only one instance in Twenty20 International matches. There have also been seven instances in Test cricket, and two in ODIs, where a batsman has been dismissed handled the ball, a mode of dismissal now folded into obstructing the field.

Hit the ball twice, or "double-hit", is a method of dismissal in the sport of cricket. Its occurrence in modern cricket is exceptionally rare.

Timed out is a method of dismissal in the sport of cricket. It occurs when an incoming batter is not ready to play within a given amount of time of the previous batter being either dismissed or retired. This is one case of a 'diamond' or 'platinum' duck, as the player is out without having faced a ball. Only one batter in international cricket has been dismissed by this method, Angelo Mathews playing against Bangladesh in the ICC Men's Cricket World Cup 2023. The purpose of the law is to ensure there are no unnecessary delays to the game. It is easily avoided, and it is very unusual for a batter to get out 'timed out'. As of December 2023, there have been no instances of this type of dismissal in Test match or Twenty20 cricket, a single instance in one day international cricket, and six instances in first-class cricket as a whole.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bowled</span> Term in cricket

In cricket, the term bowled has several meanings. First, it is the act of propelling the ball towards the wicket defended by a batter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caught</span> Cricket dismissal method; the ball does not hit the ground after it is batted

Caught is a method of dismissing a batsman in cricket. A batsman is out caught if the batsman hits the ball, from a legitimate delivery, with the bat, and the ball is caught by the bowler or a fielder before it hits the ground.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Run out</span> Method of dismissal in cricket

Run out is a method of dismissal in cricket, governed by Law 38 of the Laws of Cricket. A run out usually occurs when the batters are attempting to run between the wickets, and the fielding team succeed in getting the ball to one wicket before a batter has crossed the crease line near the wicket. The incomplete run the batters were attempting does not count.

Hit wicket is a method of dismissal in the sport of cricket. This method of dismissal is governed by Law 35 of the Laws of Cricket. The striker is out "hit wicket" if, after the bowler has entered his delivery stride and while the ball is in play, his wicket is put down by his bat or his person. The striker may do this whilst preparing to receive or receiving a delivery or in setting off for his first run after playing the delivery. In simple language, if the striking batsman knocks the bails off the stumps or uproots the stumps, while attempting to hit the ball or take off for a run, he is out hit wicket.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stumped</span> Method of dismissal in cricket

Stumped is a method of dismissing a batter in cricket, in which the wicket-keeper puts down the striker's wicket while the striker is out of their ground. It is governed by Law 39 of the Laws of Cricket.

Daryll John Cullinan is a former South African first-class cricketer who played Test cricket and One Day Internationals for South Africa as a specialist batsman. He was regarded as the most gifted batsman of his generation as he was equally adept against pace or spin. Cullinan has said that his most important batting fundamentals were his balance, knowing where his off-stump was and getting his defence in order. He ended up playing 70 tests and 138 ODIs for South Africa. Cullinan's career Test average of 44.21 is only surpassed by ten South Africans with more than ten Tests. At the time of his retirement, he held the record for scoring the most test centuries for South Africa, with 14. Cullinan was a member of the South Africa team that won the 1998 ICC KnockOut Trophy, the only ICC trophy the country has won to date.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Russell Endean</span> South African cricketer

William Russell Endean was a South African cricketer who played in 28 Test matches from 1951 to 1958.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cricket</span> Bat-and-ball game

Cricket is a bat-and-ball game played between two teams of eleven players on a field at the centre of which is a 22-yard (20-metre) pitch with a wicket at each end, each comprising two bails balanced on three stumps. The batting side scores runs by striking the ball bowled at one of the wickets with the bat and then running between the wickets, while the bowling and fielding side tries to prevent this and dismiss each batter. Means of dismissal include being bowled, when the ball hits the stumps and dislodges the bails, and by the fielding side either catching the ball after it is hit by the bat, but before it hits the ground, or hitting a wicket with the ball before a batter can cross the crease in front of the wicket. When ten batters have been dismissed, the innings ends and the teams swap roles. The game is adjudicated by two umpires, aided by a third umpire and match referee in international matches. They communicate with two off-field scorers who record the match's statistical information.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Decision Review System</span> Technology-based system used in the sport of cricket

The Decision Review System (DRS), formerly known as the Umpire Decision Review System(UDRS), is a technology-based system used in cricket to assist the match officials in their decision-making. On-field umpires may choose to consult with the third umpire (known as an Umpire Review), and players may request that the third umpire consider a decision of the on-field umpires (known as a Player Review).

References

  1. 1 2 "MCC ANNOUNCES BAT SIZE LIMIT". MCC. Retrieved 6 March 2017.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "Law 33 (Handled the ball)". Marylebone Cricket Club. 2013. Retrieved 1 March 2015.
  3. Hogg, James; Marryat, Florence (1864). London society. Vol. 6. William Clowes and Sons. p. 142. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  4. Hoyle, Edmond (1779). Hoyle's games improved. J.F. and C. Rivington. p. 228.
  5. Donnelly, Paul (2010). First, Last & Only: Cricket. Octopus Publishing Group. ISBN   978-0-600-62253-6 . Retrieved 3 March 2011.
  6. 1 2 Oslear, Don. Wisden: The Laws of Cricket. London: Ebury Press. pp. 142–143.
  7. 1 2 3 Brodribb (1995), p. 229.
  8. Scott, Les (31 August 2011). Bats, Balls & Bails: The Essential Cricket Book. London: Random House. ISBN   978-1-4464-2316-5.
  9. Fraser, David (2005). Cricket and the Law: The man in white is always right. London: Routledge. p. 145. ISBN   0-7146-8285-3.
  10. 1 2 "Explanation of changes to the Laws of Cricket for the 5th Edition of the 2000 Code" (PDF). Marylebone Cricket Club. Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 August 2016. Retrieved 14 July 2016.
  11. 1 2 Brodribb (1995), p. 231.
  12. Brodribb (1995), p. 230.
  13. "Records / First-class matches / Batting records / Unusual dismissals". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  14. "Records / List A matches / Batting records / Unusual dismissals". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  15. 1 2 3 Luke, Will; Williamson, Martin (6 December 2005). "Ten controversial dismissals". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  16. "Records / Test matches / Batting records / Unusual dismissals". ESPNcricinfo . Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  17. "Records / One-Day Internationals / Batting records / Unusual dismissals". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  18. "Records / Twenty20 Internationals / Batting records / Unusual dismissals". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  19. "Second Test Match: England v South Africa 1956–57". Wisden Cricketers' Alamanack. 1958. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  20. "Obituary, 2004: Russell Endean". Wisden Cricketers' Alamanack. 2004. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  21. Baum, Greg (23 February 2012). "Let's back up a clear line on 'run-outs'". Sydney Morning Herald . Sydney: Fairfax Media . Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  22. "Player Profile: Andrew Hilditch". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  23. "First Test Match: Pakistan v Australia 1982–83". Wisden Cricketers' Alamanack. 1984. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  24. 1 2 "Fourth Test Match: India v West Indies 1983–84". Wisden Cricketers' Alamanack. 1985. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  25. Memon, Ayaz (2 March 2011). "Indians were not aware of DRS regulations". Mid-Day . Mid-Day Infomedia Limited. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  26. "World Series Cup – Second Final Match: Australia v India 1985–86". Wisden Cricketers' Almanack. 1987. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
  27. Warne, Shane (2009). Shane Warne's Century: My Top 100 Test Cricketers. Edinburgh: Random House. p. 14. ISBN   978-1-84596-451-1.
  28. Lynch, Steven (2009). Wisden on the Ashes: The Authoritative Story of Cricket's Greatest Rivalry. London: John Wisden & Co. p. 491. ISBN   978-1-4081-0983-0.
  29. "Cullinan makes history as South Africa triumph". The Guardian . London. 28 January 1999. Retrieved 11 March 2012.
  30. Prescott, Lawrence (28 January 1999). "Cricket: Cullinan out for handling the ball". The Independent . London: Independent Print Limited. Retrieved 11 March 2012.
  31. Rutnagur, D.J. (19 March 2001). "Test Match: India trump Waugh's hand". The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  32. Knox, Malcolm (2009). The Greatest: The players, the moments, the matches: 1993–2008. Prahran, Victoria: Hardie Grant Publishing. p. 254. ISBN   978-1-74066-998-6.
  33. Miller, Andrew; Luke, Will (February 2006). "Eleven bizarre dismissals ... and one that got away". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  34. "Bizarre dismissal spoils England's solid start". The Daily Telegraph. London. 19 December 2001. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
  35. Vaughan, Michael (2004). Year in the Sun. Coronet. ISBN   0-340-83095-6.
  36. "2nd Test: South Africa v England at Cape Town, Jan 1–5, 1957". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  37. "2nd Test: Australia v Pakistan at Perth, Mar 24–29, 1979". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  38. "1st Test: Pakistan v Australia at Karachi, Sep 22–27, 1982". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  39. "4th Test: India v West Indies at Mumbai, Nov 24–29, 1983". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  40. "2nd Final: Australia v India at Melbourne, Feb 9, 1986". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  41. "1st Test: England v Australia at Manchester, Jun 3–7, 1993". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  42. "3rd ODI: South Africa v West Indies at Durban, Jan 27, 1999". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  43. "3rd Test: India v Australia at Chennai, Mar 18–22, 2001". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  44. "3rd Test: India v England at Bangalore, Dec 19–23, 2001". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2 March 2012.
  45. "3rd ODI: Zimbabwe v Afghanistan at Bulawayo, Oct 20, 2015". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 21 October 2015.

Bibliography