Miller v. Alabama

Last updated

Miller v. Alabama
Seal of the United States Supreme Court.svg
Supreme Court of the United States
Argued March 19, 2012
Decided June 25, 2012
Full case nameEvan Miller, Petitioner v. Alabama; Kuntrell Jackson, Petitioner v. Ray Hobbs, Director, Arkansas Department of Correction
Docket nos. 10-9646
10-9647
Citations567 U.S. 460 ( more )
132 S. Ct. 2455; 183 L. Ed. 2d 407
Case history
PriorConviction affirmed sub nom. Miller v. State, 2010 WL 2546422 (Ala. Crim. App. June 25, 2010); rehearing denied, and new decision published, 63 So.3d 676 (Ala. Crim. App. August 27, 2010); certiorari denied sub nom. Ex parte Miller, unpub. n°1091663 (Ala. October 22, 2010); certiorari granted, 565 U. S. 1013 (2011). Conviction affirmed sub nom. Jackson v. State, 359 Ark. 87, 194 S.W.3d 757 (2004); petition for habeas relief dismissed, unpub. n°cv-08-28-2 (Jefferson Cnty Cir. Ct.); affirmed, 2011 Ark. 49, 378 S. W. 3d 103 (2011); certiorari granted, 565 U. S. 1013 (2011)
Holding
The Eighth Amendment prohibits a sentencing scheme that requires life in prison without the possibility of parole for juvenile homicide offenders. [1]
Court membership
Chief Justice
John Roberts
Associate Justices
Antonin Scalia  · Anthony Kennedy
Clarence Thomas  · Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Stephen Breyer  · Samuel Alito
Sonia Sotomayor  · Elena Kagan
Case opinions
MajorityKagan, joined by Kennedy, Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor
ConcurrenceBreyer, joined by Sotomayor
DissentRoberts, joined by Scalia, Thomas, Alito
DissentThomas, joined by Scalia
DissentAlito, joined by Scalia
Laws applied
U.S. Const. Amend. VIII

Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), [2] was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that mandatory sentences of life without the possibility of parole are unconstitutional for juvenile offenders. [3] [4] The ruling applied even to those persons who had committed murder as a juvenile, extending beyond Graham v. Florida (2010), which had ruled juvenile life without parole sentences unconstitutional for crimes excluding murder.

Contents

Background

The decision of the court was based on two consolidated cases, Jackson v. Hobbs, No. 10-9647, and Miller v. Alabama, No. 10-9646. [5] The Los Angeles Times wrote: "In one case that came before the court, Kuntrell Jackson was 14 in November 18, 1999 when he and two other teenagers went to a video store in Arkansas planning to rob it. [6] He stayed outside, and one of the youths pulled a gun and killed the store clerk. Jackson had waited outside the store for a time, but entered shortly before Derrick Shields shot the store clerk. There is debate as to whether he told the clerk, "We ain't playin'" or whether he said to his accomplices, "I thought you all was playin'." [7] Jackson was not the shooter. Jackson was charged as an adult and given a life term with no parole.

In the second case, Evan Miller, a 14-year-old from Alabama, was convicted of a July 15, 2003, murder after he and another boy set fire to a trailer where they had bought drugs from a neighbor. Miller committed homicide in the act of robbing his neighbor, Cole Cannon. Cannon had fallen asleep after he, Miller, and Miller's friend Colby Smith had indulged in alcohol and marijuana. Cannon awoke as Miller was replacing Cannon's wallet, and Smith hit Cannon with a baseball bat. [8] Miller took up the bat and proceeded to severely beat Cannon. Smith and Miller later returned to destroy the evidence of what they had done by setting fire to Cannon's trailer. Cannon died of severe injuries and smoke inhalation. [7] On October 20, 2006, Miller was given a life term with no parole, while Smith received life with parole on October 27, 2006. [3] [9]

Opinion of the Court

Majority opinion

Justice Elena Kagan wrote for the majority of the court "that mandatory life without parole for those under age of 18 at the time of their crime violates the 8th Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishments". [3] Justice Kagan said:

Mandatory life without parole for a juvenile precludes consideration of his chronological age and its hallmark features – among them, immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences. It prevents taking into account the family and home environment that surrounds him – and from which he cannot usually extricate himself – no matter how brutal or dysfunctional. [5]

Dissents

Chief Justice John Roberts voiced in his dissent the opinion that mandatory life sentences "could not plausibly be described" as unusual when a majority of states endorse them. He wrote: "Determining the appropriate sentence for a teenager convicted of murder presents grave and challenging questions of morality and social policy. Our role, however, is to apply the law, not to answer such questions." [10] A separate dissent was filed by Justice Samuel Alito. Alito wrote of the consequences of the majority ruling:

Even a 17+1⁄2-year-old who sets off a bomb in a crowded mall or guns down a dozen students and teachers is a 'child' and must be given a chance to persuade a judge to permit his release into society. Nothing in the Constitution supports this arrogation of legislative authority. [5]

The holding of the court applies retroactively to all those convicted of crimes committed under 18. It does not automatically free any prisoner, and it does not forbid sentences of life terms for young murderers. Instead judges in their review have to consider the defendant's youth, mitigating factors, and the nature of the crime before sentencing the defendant to imprisonment with no hope for parole. [3]

The case was remanded to the trial court for the convicted youths to be re-sentenced. [11]

Retroactivity

In Montgomery v. Louisiana (2016), the Supreme Court determined that Miller v. Alabama must be applied retroactively. The petitioner, Henry Montgomery, has been in prison since 1963 for a murder he committed at the age of 17. [12] [13] [14] The Court said that states could undertake re-sentencing, or offer parole to inmates sentenced to life as minors. Up to 2,300 cases nationwide were estimated to be affected by the ruling.

Another case affected by the ruling would be the sentence that Lee Boyd Malvo received for his role in the D.C. sniper attacks, with a judge making a ruling similar to Montgomery v. Louisiana. [15] Malvo's trial progress had earlier been affected by Roper v. Simmons , which took the death penalty out of play for Malvo, who had been charged with capital murder. The Supreme Court had granted the case Mathena v. Malvo in March 2019, and heard oral argument in October 2019. [16] [17] However, a change in Virginia law rendered the case moot. [18]

A year later, the Supreme Court granted a related case, Jones v. Mississippi , involving a person who had killed his grandfather when he was 15 in 2004 and given the mandatory sentence of life without parole. Due to the reactive rulings in Miller and Montgomery, Jones was given a rehearing but was still resentenced to life in prison, and appealed, claiming the court did not evaluate any aspect of his incorrigibility as required under Montgomery. Oral hearings were held on November 3, 2020. [18] On April 22, 2021, the US Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Mississippi Court of Appeals.

Kuntrell Jackson was released from prison on February 21, 2017. [19]

Subsequent developments

Miller was given a resentencing hearing in 2017, however it was not until April 2021 that a verdict had been reached with him being resentenced to life without parole. [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] Miller is now trying to appeal his resentencing verdict. [31] [32] [33] While life sentences are prohibited, de facto life sentences are permitted in selected jurisdictions, as the South Carolina Supreme Court ruled on April 3, 2019, in the case of State of South Carolina v. Conrad Lamont Slocumb. [34]

Related Research Articles

Life imprisonment is any sentence of imprisonment for a crime under which convicted criminals are to remain in prison for the rest of their natural lives. Crimes that warrant life imprisonment are extremely serious and usually violent. Examples of these crimes are murder, torture, terrorism, child abuse resulting in death, rape, espionage, treason, illegal drug trade, human trafficking, severe fraud and financial crimes, aggravated property damage, arson, hate crime, kidnapping, burglary, robbery, piracy, aircraft hijacking, and genocide.

Lee Boyd Malvo, also known as John Lee Malvo, is an American convicted murderer who, along with John Allen Muhammad, committed a series of murders dubbed the D.C. sniper attacks over a three-week period in October 2002. Malvo was aged 17 during the span of the shootings. He was serving multiple life sentences at Red Onion State Prison in Virginia, a supermax prison. Muhammad was executed in 2009.

Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551 (2005), is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of the United States in which the Court held that it is unconstitutional to impose capital punishment for crimes committed while under the age of 18. The 5–4 decision overruled Stanford v. Kentucky, in which the court had upheld execution of offenders at or above age 16, and overturned statutes in 25 states.

On January 27, 2001, Dartmouth College professors Half and Susanne Zantop, aged 62 and 55 respectively, were stabbed to death at their home in Etna, New Hampshire. Originally from Germany, the couple had been teaching at Dartmouth since the 1970s. High school classmates James J. Parker, age 16, and Robert W. Tulloch, age 17, were charged with first-degree murder.

The Richland High School shooting was a school shooting that occurred on Wednesday, November 15, 1995, in Lynnville, Tennessee, a small community located in Giles County. Seventeen-year-old James Ellison "Jamie" Rouse, a senior student at the school, murdered one teacher and one student, and seriously wounded another teacher.

On May 12, 2007, Alec Kreider, a 16-year-old high school student at the time, murdered his classmate and friend Kevin Haines, his father Thomas Haines, and mother Lisa Haines in their home in Manheim Township, Pennsylvania, United States. Kreider was arrested a month later on June 16, 2007 and was charged with three counts of first degree murder. He pleaded guilty to all charges, and was subsequently convicted on all three counts and sentenced to three consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole. Kreider later became eligible for a re-sentencing hearing following the United States Supreme Court's 2012 decision in Miller v. Alabama, which held that mandatory sentences of life without the possibility of parole are unconstitutional for juvenile offenders.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Honeck</span> American murderer

Richard Honeck was an American murderer who served one of the longest custodial sentences ever to terminate in a prisoner's release in American criminal history. Jailed in November 1899 for the murder of a former school friend, Honeck was paroled from Southern Illinois Penitentiary in Chester, Illinois on 20 December 1963, having completed 64 years and one month of his life sentence, and served a total of 23,418 days in jail.

In the United States, life imprisonment is the most severe punishment provided by law in states with no valid capital punishment statute, and second-most in those with a valid statute. According to a 2013 study, 1 of every 2 000 inhabitants of the U.S. were imprisoned for life as of 2012.

Life imprisonment in Canada is a criminal sentence for certain offences that lasts for the offender’s life. Parole is possible, but even if paroled, the offender remains under the supervision of Corrections Canada for their lifetime, and can be returned to prison for parole violations.

Graham v. Florida, 560 U.S. 48 (2010), was a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States holding that juvenile offenders cannot be sentenced to life imprisonment without parole for non-homicide offenses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Jason Sweeney</span> 2003 murder in Pennsylvania, United States

Jason Keel Sweeney was a construction worker from Fishtown, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, who at the age of 16 was murdered by four teenagers for his paycheck on May 30, 2003. The perpetrators included a girl he was dating and his best friend since childhood. Due to the manner in which Sweeney was murdered, the ages of the teens involved, and the seeming indifference of the perpetrators, the crime received national media coverage.

Kristina Joy Fetters was an Iowa woman who was convicted of the murder of her 73-year-old great-aunt, Arlene Klehm, on October 25, 1994, when she was 14 years old. At age 15, Fetters became the youngest woman in Iowa sentenced to life in prison without parole on December 18, 1995. Following the 2012 Supreme Court decision of Miller v. Alabama, which declared mandatory life sentences for juvenile offenders to be unconstitutional, Fetters became the first inmate in Iowa to be re-sentenced in November 2013. The following month, she was recommended for compassionate parole due to a prognosis of inoperable stage-four breast cancer, and she was released to a hospice care center in Des Moines, Iowa in December 2013. She succumbed to her cancer in July 2014, at age 34.

The Equal Justice Initiative (EJI) is a non-profit organization, based in Montgomery, Alabama, that provides legal representation to prisoners who may have been wrongly convicted of crimes, poor prisoners without effective representation, and others who may have been denied a fair trial. It guarantees the defense of anyone in Alabama in a death penalty case.

Montgomery v. Louisiana, 577 U.S. 190 (2016), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that its previous ruling in Miller v. Alabama (2012), that a mandatory life sentence without parole should not apply to persons convicted of murder committed as juveniles, should be applied retroactively. This decision potentially affects up to 2,300 cases nationwide.

Joseph Ligon is an American convicted murderer and former prisoner. He was America's longest-serving prisoner who was convicted to a life sentence as a minor. At 15, he was found guilty of murder by association and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. After the US Supreme Court had ruled in 2016 that all juvenile life sentences without parole were retroactively unconstitutional, he was released in 2021, having spent 68 years in jail.

Jones v. Mississippi, 593 U.S. ___ (2021), was a United States Supreme Court case regarding the imposition of life sentences for juveniles. The Supreme Court had previously ruled in Miller v. Alabama in 2012 that mandatory life sentences without parole for juvenile offenders was considered cruel and unusual punishment outside of extreme cases of permanent incorrigibility, and made this decision retroactive in Montgomery v. Louisiana in 2016. In Jones, a juvenile offender who was 15 at the time of his offense, challenged his life sentence following Montgomery but was denied by the state. In a 6–3 decision with all six conservative justices upholding the life sentence without parole for Jones, the Court ruled that the states have discretionary ability to hold juvenile offenders to life sentences without parole without having to make a separate assessment of their incorrigibility.

The Louisiana Parole Project, also known as The Parole Project, is a non-profit organization dedicated to parole, probation, and sentencing reform in the United States. The project advocates through parole and clemency petitions and assists formerly incarcerated people as they reenter society.

15 to Life: Kenneth's Story is a Canadian-American documentary film, directed by Nadine Pequeneza and released in 2014.

References

  1. ↑ "Miller v. Alabama". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved June 28, 2012.
  2. ↑ "Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012)". Justia Law. Retrieved August 17, 2023.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Savage, David G. (June 25, 2012). "Supreme Court rules mandatory juvenile life without parole cruel and unusual". The Los Angeles Times. Retrieved June 26, 2012.
  4. ↑ Cohen, Andrew (June 26, 2012). "If You Think Monday Was Bad at the Supreme Court ..." The Atlantic . Retrieved June 26, 2012.
  5. 1 2 3 Adam Liptak and Ethan Bronner (June 25, 2012). "Justices Bar Mandatory Life Terms for Juveniles". The New York Times. Retrieved June 26, 2012.
  6. ↑ "New sentencing for Region 8 inmate given life as teen". March 2013.
  7. 1 2 Miller v. Alabama, 132 S. Ct. 2455, 567 U.S., 183 L. Ed. 2d 407 (2012).
  8. ↑ Gavett, Gretchen; Childress, Sarah (June 25, 2012). "Supreme Court Bans Mandatory Life Terms for Kids: What it Means". PBS . Retrieved June 3, 2023.
  9. ↑ Grantham, Ginger (October 25, 2006). "Youth gets life without parole for murder, fire". The Moulton Advertiser. Retrieved June 3, 2023.
  10. ↑ Barnes, Robert (June 25, 2012). "Supreme Court says states may not impose mandatory life sentences on juvenile murderers". The Washington Post. Retrieved June 26, 2012.
  11. ↑ Miller v. Alabama, ___ U.S. ___, 132 S. Ct. 2455, 183 L. Ed. 2d 407 (2012).
  12. ↑ Denniston, Lyle (March 23, 2015). "Court to try again on juveniles' life sentences". SCOTUSblog.
  13. ↑ "Petition for Writ of Certiorari" (PDF). SCOTUSblog. Retrieved March 24, 2015.
  14. ↑ Sherman, Mark (January 25, 2016). "Justices Extend Bar on Automatic Life Terms for Teenagers". ABC News. Associated Press.
  15. ↑ Stolberg, Sheryl Gay (May 26, 2017). "Lee Boyd Malvo, Serving Life in 'Beltway Sniper' Case, Must Be Resentenced, Judge Says". The New York Times . Retrieved May 27, 2017.
  16. ↑ "Supreme Court agrees to hear deadly D.C. sniper case". Politico . Associated Press. March 18, 2019. Retrieved March 18, 2019.
  17. ↑ Smith, Matt (March 15, 2017). "Evan Miller Offers Apology As Resentencing Hearing Wraps". Juvenile Justice Information Exchange. Retrieved August 12, 2020.
  18. 1 2 Liptak, Adam (March 9, 2020). "Supreme Court to Consider When Juveniles May Get Life Without Parole". The New York Times . Retrieved November 3, 2020.
  19. ↑ "Sutton's Conversation with Kuntrell Jackson, Plaintiff in the U.S. Supreme Court Case Jackson v. Hobbs". ACLU Missouri. August 15, 2019. Retrieved August 12, 2020.
  20. ↑ Scarpino, Madison (June 17, 2021). "New sentence, trial requested in brutal Lawrence Co. murder case". WAFF 48.
  21. ↑ "Man Whose Murder Case Brought Ban on Mandatory Life Without Parole for Youth Gets 2nd Life Sentence". April 28, 2021.
  22. ↑ Sapienza, Brandon (April 27, 2021). "Alabama judge resentences Evan Miller, the youngest person ever given life without parole". New York Daily News.
  23. ↑ Faulk, Kent (April 27, 2021). "Evan Miller, youngest person ever sentenced to life without parole in Alabama, must remain in prison". AL.com.
  24. ↑ "Resentencing set for 2003 Lawrence County murder". waff. March 13, 2017. Retrieved November 29, 2020.
  25. ↑ "Evan Miller to be resentenced". wtvq. ABC36. August 23, 2017.
  26. ↑ "Locked up for life: A patchwork of justice for juvenile offender". Concord Monitor. Associated Press. July 30, 2017. Retrieved November 29, 2020.
  27. ↑ "Patchwork justice for juvenile lifers". digital olive software. Atlanta Journal-Constitution. August 1, 2017. Retrieved November 29, 2020.
  28. ↑ "Patchwork justice for juvenile lifers". AP news. Associated Press. March 11, 2017. Retrieved November 29, 2020.
  29. ↑ "Resentencing hearing of Evan Miller continues today". Decatur Daily. March 14, 2017. Retrieved November 29, 2020.
  30. ↑ "Evan Miller Offers Apology As Resentencing Hearing Wraps". Juvenile Justice Information Exchange. March 15, 2017. Retrieved November 29, 2020.
  31. ↑ "New sentence, trial requested in brutal Lawrence Co. Murder case". June 17, 2021.
  32. ↑ "Alabama juvenile lifer appeals life without parole sentence". June 17, 2021.
  33. ↑ "Alabama juvenile lifer appeals life without parole sentence". Associated Press . June 16, 2021.
  34. ↑ Shearouse, Daniel. "OPINIONS OF THE SUPREME COURT AND COURT OF APPEALS OF SOUTH CAROLINA" (PDF). SCCourts.org. Retrieved October 30, 2023.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.