2008 Belizean general election

2008 Belizean general election

←  2003 7 February 2008 2012  →
All 31 seats in the House of Representatives 16 seats needed for a majority
Turnout	77.18%
First party Second party   Leader Dean Barrow Said Musa Party UDP PUP Last election 7 seats 22 seats Seats won 25 6 Seat change 18 16 Popular vote 66,203 47,624 Percentage 56.61% 40.72% Swing 17.2 12.44
Results by constituency
Prime Minister before election Said Musa PUP Subsequent Prime Minister Dean Barrow UDP

General elections were held in Belize on 7 February 2008. Beginning with this election, Belizeans elected 31 members to the House of Representatives of Belize instead of 29. In what was considered an upset, the opposition United Democratic Party (UDP) won the election with 25 out of 31 seats; the ruling People's United Party won six. ^[1]

The elections were held alongside a constitutional referendum had also been called to determine the views of Belizeans on an elected Senate.

Background

In August 2003 Cayo South Area Rep. Agripino Cawich of the PUP died, triggering a by-election in the constituency, only the second held in Belize since independence. The by-election was won by the UDP's John Saldivar, who had lost to Cawich in the general election earlier in 2003. Saldivar's win flipped the constituency to the UDP column and increased the party's caucus to eight for the remainder of the term. ^[2]

Beginning in March 2007 and continuing through April 22, Belize's 193 villages held council elections on Sundays of every weekend except for Easter. While the Village Council elections are supposed to be non-partisan, the major parties and independents considered them a litmus test for the general elections. From the very beginning, back and forth charges of inaccurate statistics and party favoritism have stained the elections, with both the blue and the red claiming victory in the majority of contested seats. Press releases from both parties claim victory. The results are detailed below.

_{Results of Village Council elections 2007 ^[3]}

UDP	PUP	Independent
114 (own estimate)	103 (own estimate)	16 (PUP estimate)
74 (PUP estimate)	67 (UDP estimate)	9 (UDP estimate)

Prime Minister Said Musa twice had chances to dissolve the House of Representatives in session, on November 16, 2007 and December 19, 2007; both times he passed. However, Musa committed to calling elections before March 2008, the date when they were last held. With the announcement on Monday, January 7, 2008, the House was dissolved from that date. 93 candidates from six parties were nominated Monday, January 21, 2008 and elections were held on Thursday, February 7, 2008. The date chosen was one day behind Ash Wednesday, February 6; according to local media three elections have been called on an Ash Wednesday during Musa's term, of which he has won two.

Campaign

People's United Party

Campaigning kicked off in earnest from as early as summer 2007. The ruling PUP have rolled out a number of programs designed to woo the electorate, including the promise of free textbooks for primary school students, ^[4] improved infrastructure on the deep southside of Belize City ^[5] and a planned rollout of a health insurance scheme in early 2008. Prime Minister Said Musa spent much of the early summer touring the South and West and continued his tour of the country in September and October. The PUP held a press conference on January 7, 2008 and announced pay increases for soldiers, teachers and public officers to take place after the general election. They released their manifesto "Believe in Belize-The BLUEprint" on January 22.

United Democratic Party

The United Democratic Party, for its part, concentrated on shoring up support ^[6] in the districts and fighting fires in the various municipal governments they have controlled since March 2006. Party Leader Dean Barrow has likewise toured much of the country since June. Both parties' journalism machinery have dug up various scandals on either side. The Elections and Boundaries Department have noted an increase ^[7] in the number of voter transfers between divisions, ^[8] usually done in July and August.

The UDP released its election manifesto, Imagine the Possibilities: 2008-13, to a cheering crowd of supporters at its party headquarters in Belize City on January 16, 2008.

Third party announcements

Several third parties participated. Among them are established parties Vision Inspired by the People out of Belmopan and We the People Reform Movement from the North, Cornelius Dueck's National Reform Party and Wil Maheia's People's National Party

Attempts by third parties to unify have largely proven unsuccessful. The Amandala of March 18, 2007 indicated that the PNP and WTP had formed an alliance (later named the National Belizean Alliance (NBA)) and were expected to announce their combined slate soon. The parties wrote joint letters to the Amandala in pre-election issues.

Each party separately nominated candidates: VIP nominated 11 candidates, as did the NRP, and the NBA nominated four.

In the Amandala of Sunday, March 11, former party the National Reality Truth Creation Party returned to the political scene with a full page ad endorsing one Ebony Babb for Queen's Square; the ad also extolled the Christian virtues of the party, led by musician Jorge Ernesto Babb. The ad appealed to all "natural Creole born Belizeans" to support the NRTCP in 2008. Subsequent announcements by the NRTCP in the Amandala include Babb himself as a candidate in Freetown.

In November 2007, the major parties confronted each other over an inflammatory political sign ^[9] in Belize City; ^[10] a number of individuals were either arrested or threatened with arrest, including Mayor Zenaida Moya. ^[11] The incident drew the ire of third parties such as the NBA and VIP ^[12] and led to the signing of a "gentleman's agreement between all major political parties at the request of the Police Department. Despite the signing of this agreement, reports of continued vandalism of signs and inflammatory television commercials continue to circulate.

Campaign issues

• Municipal governance: The People's United Party, who were defeated in the 2006 municipal elections by the United Democratic Party, point to their spotty performance in governing the towns, particularly Belize City, Orange Walk and San Ignacio; the UDP claim the PUP has been strangling their resources and falsifying the situation.
• Political reform and corruption: The minor parties have all come forward with strategies designed to prevent the large-scale official corruption they say has taken place under the outgoing administration. These include electing the Senate and empowering it with greater oversight over the House, limiting the term of the prime minister and the House, electing the prime minister directly instead of by appointment, introducing powers of impeachment and recall, and strengthening established institutions and officials to keep them independent of the political hierarchy, among others. Both major parties have adopted bits and pieces of these strategies, but the UDP is not fully convinced of the necessity of an elected Senate.
  • Note: On December 19, 2007, the ruling party issued in its last House meeting for the year a bill for a referendum on the introduction of an elected Senate. Despite the Opposition's pleas for the date to be extended in order to consider as many forms of the elected Senate as possible the resolution passed both the Senate ^[13] and the House. ^[14]
• Administration performance: The UDP remains convinced that the ruling PUP have largely abandoned the promises that got them elected in 1998 and 2003, while the PUP point to a number of natural disasters and other emergencies that they say have prevented them from doing a better job. The PUP's view seems borne out by the passage of two hurricanes, Dean which caused 200 m in damages and Felix.

Candidates

This list represents the nominations received by the Elections and Boundaries Department on Nomination Day, January 21.Bold indicates incumbent.

Constituency	PUP	UDP	VIP	NRP	NBA
Albert	Mark Espat	Tom Morrison
Belize Rural Central	Ralph Fonseca [15]	Michael Hutchinson	Harrisford Myers
Belize Rural North	Earl Perez	Edmond Castro
Belize Rural South	Merlene Spain	Manuel Heredia Jr.		Ernesto Caliz
Belmopan	Rolando Zetina [16]	John Saldivar [17]	Paul Morgan
Caribbean Shores	Jose Coye	Carlos Perdomo
Cayo Central	Mario Castellaños	Rene Montero	Gilroy Requeña	George Boiton Jr.
Cayo North	Otto Coleman	Salvador Fernandez		Alden McDougal
Cayo Northeast	Orlando Habet	Elvin Penner		Cornelius Dueck
Cayo South	Charles Galvez	Ramon Witz	Hubert Enriquez		Richard Smith
Cayo West	Kendall Mendez	Erwin Contreras	Martha Hendricks
Collet	Carolyn Trench-Sandiford	Patrick Faber	Patrick Rogers
Corozal Bay	Juan Vildo Marin	Pablo Marin
Corozal North	Valdemar Castillo	Nemencio Acosta
Corozal Southeast	Florencio Marin Jr. [18]	Servando Samos
Corozal Southwest	Gregorio Garcia	Gabriel Martinez
Dangriga	Cassian Nunez	Arturo Roches	Quentin Mejia	Denton Castillo
Fort George	Said Musa	Dr. George Gough
Freetown	Francis Fonseca	Michael Peyrefitte
Lake Independence	Cordel Hyde	Vanley Jenkins	"Seagull" Joseph Martinez	Gary Lambey
Mesopotamia	Austin Waight	Michael Finnegan
Orange Walk Central	Johnny Briceño	Rosendo Urbina		Alvaro Espejo
Orange Walk East	Marco Tulio Mendez	Marcel Cardona		Pabel Torres
Orange Walk North	Servulo Baeza	Gaspar Vega		Hilberto Nah
Orange Walk South	Jose Mai	Mark Pech		Edwardo Melendez	Salustiano Lizama
Pickstock	Godfrey Smith	Wilfred Elrington
Port Loyola	Oscar Rosado	Anthony Martinez	Erwin X (Jones)
Queen's Square	Anthony Sylvester	Dean Barrow
Stann Creek West	Rodwell Ferguson	Melvin Hulse	Mateo Polanco
Toledo East	Mike Espat	Eden Martinez			Wil Maheia
Toledo West	Marcial Mes	Juan Coy	Max Cho	Fermin Choc	Dionisio Chuc

Others:

• National Reality Truth Creation Party:
  • Jorge E. Babb, Freetown
  • Ebony Babb, Queen's Square
• Independents
  • Herman Lewis, Toledo East
  • Queen Miller, Belize Rural Central
  • Nazim Juan, Cayo Central

Max Samuels in Belize Rural North, Florencio Marin Senior in Corozal South East, Dave Burgos in Orange Walk East, Ismael Cal in Orange Walk South, Ainslie Leslie in Cayo North and Sylvia Flores in Dangriga are not seeking reelection. All represented the People's United Party in their constituencies.

^[19]

Opinion polls

The Society for the Promotion of Education and Research (SPEAR) released the results of an opinion poll conducted in conjunction with SJC's Belizean Studies Centre in October 2005. In an election 49% of voters would consider voting for a third party; between the current parties 34.5% said they would vote for the PUP and the rest for the UDP. ^[20]

As a followup, SPEAR conducted a second poll released on October 31, 2006 ( ^[21] ). When asked who they would vote for, 32% said UDP, 11.8% PUP and 22% a third party. Smaller numbers either said they would not vote at all or declined to say who they would vote for. The nation's largest newspaper, the Amandala , headlined ^[22] that more than half of Belizeans had rejected the PUP and UDP by either supporting a third party or declining to vote; this notion was soundly rejected by the UDP in particular and resulted in back and forth editorial responses in the Amandala and the UDP's Guardian in November, with the UDP charging that publisher Evan X Hyde was playing into the PUP's hands by supporting third parties openly instead of the UDP, and Amandala reiterating that its policy was of Belizeans First ^[23] and that neither party had thoroughly considered the welfare of "roots" Belizeans since Independence. In March 2007, the University of Belize and Saint John's College Junior College's Belizean Studies Centre conducted a one-weekend poll of 430 randomly selected persons seeking opinions on the 2008 elections. ^[24] The poll was supervised by UB Registrar Dr. Roy Young and BSC's Yasmine Andrews. On the question of approval of party leaders, the UDP's Dean Barrow led all contestants with 55.7% approval; sitting Prime Minister Said Musa scored 14.9%, while independent leaders rated below that. Results by party were similar, with the UDP scoring 55.5%, the PUP 16% and independents scores ranging from 2 to 9%.

Results

Party		Votes	%	Seats	+/–
	United Democratic Party	67,037	55.72	25	+18
	People's United Party	50,744	42.18	6	–16
	National Reform Party	1,039	0.86	0	New
	Vision Inspired by the People	874	0.73	0	New
	People's National Party	314	0.26	0	New
	National Belizean Alliance	192	0.16	0	New
	National Reality Truth Creation Party	29	0.02	0	New
	Independents	72	0.06	0	0
Total		120,301	100.00	31	+2
Valid votes		120,301	99.28
Invalid/blank votes		867	0.72
Total votes		121,168	100.00
Registered voters/turnout		156,993	77.18
Source: Caribbean Elections

References

1. UDP causes major upset in Belize elections Archived February 11, 2008, at the Wayback Machine (February 8, 2008), Caribbean360.com.
2. Result of By-election 2003 Archived 9 June 2015 at the Wayback Machine , Belize Elections and Boundaries Commission. (accessed 3 December 2014)
3. Channel5Belize.COM Archived September 29, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
4. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 2 August 2007. Channel 5 News, July 9, 2007: Government plan for free textbooks
5. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 29 September 2007. Retrieved 2 August 2007. Channel 5 News, July 10, 2007: Southside project under fire from area rep
6. http://www.7newsbelize.com/archive/08010709.html%5B%5D 7 News, August 2, 2007: Barrow on UDP's readiness
7. https://web.archive.org/web/20071004211033/http://www.7newsbelize.com/archive/08010708.html 7 News, August 2, 2007: Finnegan and voter transfers
8. http://www.7newsbelize.com/archive/08010707.html%5B%5D 7 News, August 2, 2007: 1 more month to transfer
9. http://www.amandala.com.bz/index.php?id=6279 PUP, UDP eyeball to eyeball over sign
10. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 13 February 2008. Retrieved 17 November 2007. News 5 story on incident
11. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 13 February 2008. Retrieved 17 November 2007. Follow-up report
12. Amandala, November 18, 2007.
13. http://www.7newsbelize.com/archive/12210701.html7News, Dec. 21, 2007.
14. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 13 February 2008. Retrieved 24 December 2007. No election date but referendum on elected Senate proposed, Channel 5, Dec. 19, 2007.
15. Endorsed June 24.http://www.channel5belize.com/archive_detail_story.php?story_id=18712 Archived August 23, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
16. Endorsed June 26.http://www.channel5belize.com/archive_detail_story.php?story_id=18698 Archived August 20, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
17. Currently representing Cayo South.
18. son of current area rep
19. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 13 February 2008. Retrieved 25 January 2008. Channel 5 News, January 23, 2008.
20. "New Poll Shows Musa's Approval Rating at 20%". www.7newsbelize.com. Archived from the original on 14 July 2006. Retrieved 22 May 2022.
21. "Channel5Belize.COM". Archived from the original on 29 September 2007. Retrieved 20 June 2007. News 5 report
22. http://www.amandala.com.bz/index.php?id=60 51% of Belizeans reject PUP, UDP! (Amandala)
23. Belize News - Belize's Leading Newspaper | Belize's Breaking News - Amandala Online
24. https://web.archive.org/web/20071007205402/http://www.7newsbelize.com/archive/03200704.html 7 News story by Alfonso Noble