Impeachment of Fernando Lugo

Last updated

Impeachment of Fernando Lugo
Lugo-wef.jpg
Fernando Lugo in 2010
Accused Fernando Lugo, 48th President of Paraguay
Date21–22 June 2012 (2012-06-21 – 2012-06-22)
OutcomeNo impeachment trial held
Congressional votes
Voting in the Chamber of Deputies
(21 June 2012)
AccusationResolution to impeach
Votes in favor76
Votes against1
ResultResolution approved
Voting in the Senate (22 June 2012)
AccusationResolution to convict
Votes in favor39
Votes against4
ResultLugo convicted

Fernando Lugo, elected President of Paraguay in 2008, was impeached and removed from office by the Congress of Paraguay in June 2012. On 21 June the Chamber of Deputies voted 76 to 1 to impeach Lugo, and the Senate removed him from office the following day, by 39 votes to 4, resulting in Vice President Federico Franco, who had broken with Lugo, becoming President. Lugo contends he was denied due process because he did not have enough time to prepare a defense. A number of Latin American governments declared the proceeding was effectively a coup d'état . Lugo himself formally accepted the impeachment, but called it a "parliamentary coup". [1]

Contents

Background

The election of Lugo to the presidency in 2008 broke a 61-year period in office for the Colorado Party (ANR-PC). Lugo was aided by the presence of Federico Franco of the traditional opposition Authentic Radical Liberal Party (PLRA) on the ticket as its vice presidential candidate. Lugo's electoral coalition, the Patriotic Alliance for Change (APC), was able to elect him as President (gaining 42.3% of the vote, against the second-placed Colorado candidate's 31.8%). However the Liberals and Colorados retained a majority of both houses of Congress. The Liberal Party, initially a member of the Alliance, withdrew in 2009, leaving the Alliance with just a handful of Congressional seats.

In mid-May 2012 around 150 landless farmers occupied the Campos Morombi belonging to ex-Colorado Senator Blas Riquelme. [2] [3] The farmers said the land, in Curuguaty in the eastern Canindeyú Department, had been taken illegally during the dictatorship of Alfredo Stroessner. [2] [4] On 15 June 2012 a police operation to evict landless farmers, enforcing a court order obtained by Riquelme, [5] led to the death of 6 police officers and 11 farmers. [2] The eviction involved over 300 police evicting over 150 farmers; according to the BBC, "the eviction escalated into violence and the farmers opened fire on the police." [4] The GEO chief and deputy had approached the farmers for dialogue without arms drawn, not expecting violence, and were both shot in the head. [3] Some suspected the involvement of the Paraguayan People’s Army. [3] On 16 June Lugo accepted the resignation of his interior minister Carlos Filizzola and of National Police chief General Paulino Rojas. [5] On 16 June former National General Counsel Rubén Candia Amarilla, a controversial figure from the Colorado Party, [6] took over the Ministry of Interior. [7] Immediately, the PLRA (Partido Liberal Radical Auténtico, or Authentic Radical Liberal party) requested the dismissal of Candia Amarilla and the new National Police chief Arnaldo Sanabria, who led the police operation that ended in the deaths of the farmers in Curuguaty. [8] On 19 June "Emilio Camacho, auditor of the Paraguayan Land Institute (INDERT), confirmed that Blas Riquelme did not have the title to the 2,000 hectares."[ citation needed ] On 20 June Lugo announced a special commission to investigate the incident. [2]

Impeachment

On 21 June, the Chamber of Deputies launched proceedings to impeach Lugo under Article 225 of the Constitution of Paraguay.

The Chamber cited the 15 June incident as well as insecurity, nepotism and a controversial land purchase to vote 76 to 1 to impeach Lugo on 21 June 2012. [9] The Senate took up the case the next day. [10] The impeachment was attended by a delegation of Foreign Affairs ministers from the other nations of the Union of South American Nations. [11] The vote ended with 39 votes for Lugo's removal and four for his continuity, which removed Lugo from office and made Vice President Federico Franco (who had broken with Lugo earlier) the new president of Paraguay. [12] Lugo announced that he would denounce the case to the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, stating that the time to prepare a legal defence, just two hours, may be unconstitutional. [13]

The impeachment was endorsed by the Supreme Court of Paraguay and by the country's electoral court on 25 June. The next day, Lugo stated that while he still believed his impeachment amounted to a coup, nothing short of a "miraculous" reversal of course by Congress would allow him to regain office. Short of that, he said, "all my legal possibilities ended yesterday ... Legally there is no other way to reverse this situation." [1] The electoral court declared that Lugo had been duly removed from office under Article 225, and that Federico Franco had correctly succeeded as President under Article 234. [14]

Voting result in the Congress of Paraguay

Chamber of Deputies vote on initiating impeachment proceedings against President Fernando Lugo.
Ballot21 June 2012
Required majority54 out of 80 (67.50%)
Yes
76 / 80
No
1 / 80
Abstentions
0 / 80
Absentees
3 / 80
Source: [15]
Chamber of Senators vote on removing President Fernando Lugo from office.
Ballot22 June 2012
Required majority30 out of 45 (66.67%)
Yes
39 / 45
No
4 / 45
Abstentions
0 / 130
Absentees
2 / 45
Source: [16]

Reactions

The presidents of Paraguay's neighbouring countries rejected Lugo's removal from office, and compared it to a coup d'état. Brazilian president Dilma Rousseff proposed suspending Paraguay's membership in Mercosur and the Union of South American Nations. Cristina Fernández de Kirchner of Argentina, Evo Morales of Bolivia, Rafael Correa of Ecuador and Leonel Fernández of the Dominican Republic announced that they would not recognize Franco as president. [17] Condemnation also came from more rightist governments in the region, such as Mexico, Colombia and Chile. Lugo's removal has drawn comparisons to the ousting of Honduras's Manuel Zelaya in 2009; like the ousting of Lugo, it was defended as legal and constitutional while being denounced as unethical, having ulterior motives, and a coup across the Western Hemisphere's political spectrum. [18]

Bolivarian Alliance for the Americas (ALBA) countries issued a joint statement condemning the events as a coup, and a number of countries (ALBA members Bolivia, [19] Cuba, Venezuela and Ecuador, as well as non-members Brazil, Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Peru, Mexico [20] ) withdrew their ambassadors to Paraguay. Mercosur suspended Paraguay, and Ecuador has said it may invoke UNASUR's democratic clause, which could lead to the expulsion of Paraguay from both bodies. [21]

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights issued a statement on 23 June declaring "unacceptable the speed with which the impeachment of the constitutional and democratically elected President was conducted. Considering that it was a process for the removal of a Head of State, it is highly questionable that this could be done within 24 hours while still respecting the due process guarantees necessary for an impartial trial. The Commission considers that the procedure that was followed affects the rule of law." [22]

On 26 June Reporters without Borders raised concerns about possible censorship of TV Pública Paraguay following the impeachment trial. [23]

In contrast, some Uruguayan opposition politicians and analysts regarded the impeachment as lawful under the Paraguayan constitution, such as Juan Carlos Doyenart, [24] Julio María Sanguinetti [25] and Sergio Abreu. [26]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paraguay</span> Country in South America

Paraguay, officially the Republic of Paraguay, is a landlocked country in South America. It is bordered by Argentina to the south and southwest, Brazil to the east and northeast, and Bolivia to the northwest. It has a population of around 7.4 million, nearly 3 million of whom live in the capital and largest city of Asunción, and its surrounding metro area.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Authentic Radical Liberal Party</span> Political party in Paraguay

The Authentic Radical Liberal Party is a centrist to centre-left liberal and radical political party in Paraguay. The party is a full member of Liberal International. The liberales, as they are known, are the leading opposition to the dominant conservative Colorado Party. They have taken this position since the end of the Alfredo Stroessner dictatorship in 1989. They are the political successors of the Liberal Party, which traces its history back to 10 July 1887.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Luis María Argaña</span> Paraguayan politician and jurist (1932–1999)

Luis María del Corazón de Jesús Dionisio Argaña Ferraro was a Paraguayan politician and jurist. A prominent and influential member of the Colorado Party, he was a Supreme Court judge, unsuccessfully ran for the Colorado Party's nomination for president in the 1993 election and eventually was elected Vice-President in the 1998 election, but was assassinated seven months after assuming office in March 1999 at a time when it appeared likely that he would inherit the presidency from Raúl Cubas, who was on the verge of being impeached. The incident and its aftermath is known in Paraguay as Marzo paraguayo. An airport in Paraguay, Dr. Luis María Argaña International Airport, is named for him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Union of South American Nations</span> Intergovernmental regional organization

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fernando Lugo</span> 48th President of Paraguay (2008–12)

Fernando Armindo Lugo Méndez is a Paraguayan politician and laicized Catholic bishop who was President of Paraguay from 2008 to 2012. Previously he was a Roman Catholic priest and bishop, serving as Bishop of the Diocese of San Pedro from 1994 to 2005. He was elected as president in 2008, an election that ended 61 years of rule by the Colorado Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Julio César Franco (politician)</span> Paraguayan politician

Julio César Ramón Franco Gómez is a Paraguayan politician of the Authentic Radical Liberal Party. He was vice president from 2000 to 2002, served as senator from 1998 to 2003, and was presidential candidate for the Authentic Radical Liberal Party in the 2003 election, losing to Nicanor Duarte of the Colorado Party. He was elected to the Senate again in 2008.

First Lady of Paraguay, also called First Lady of the Nation, is the official post of the wife of the president of Paraguay. The official workplace of the Paraguayan first lady is Mburuvicha Róga. The current first lady of Paraguay is Silvana López Moreira, wife of President Mario Abdo Benítez.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Federico Franco</span> 49th President of Paraguay (2012-13)

Luis Federico Franco Gómez is a Paraguayan politician who was President of Paraguay from June 2012 until August 2013. A member of the Authentic Radical Liberal Party (PLRA), he was elected as Vice President of Paraguay in the 2008 presidential election as the running mate of Fernando Lugo; he took office in August 2008. Following Lugo's impeachment by the Senate on 22 June 2012, he succeeded Lugo as President to complete the presidential mandate until 15 August 2013.

Below is a timeline of the history of Paraguay:

Events from the year 2012 in Paraguay

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2013 Paraguayan general election</span>

General elections were held in Paraguay on 21 April 2013. They resulted in a victory for the Colorado Party, which had ruled the country for 60 years before losing power in 2008. The presidential elections were won by the Colorado Party's Horacio Cartes, who defeated Efraín Alegre of the Paraguay Alegre alliance. The Colorado Party also won the most seats in the Senate and Chamber of Deputies.

Blas Nicolás Riquelme Centurión was a Paraguayan politician and businessman. He was a member of the Senate of Paraguay for the Colorado Party from 1989 to 2008, and was elected President of the party, succeeding Luis María Argaña; he resigned in 1994. He was a candidate in the Colorado Party's 1996 primary election for the 1998 presidential election, backed by Lino Oviedo. He was leader of the Movimiento Tradicionalismo Democrático (TRADEM), and one of the major financiers of the Colorado Party. He was President of the Chamber of Industry until 1984.

Carlos Alberto Filizzola Pallarés is a Paraguayan politician. He has been a member of the Senate of Paraguay since 2003, and the President of the political party Party for a Country of Solidarity since its creation in 2000. He was Interior Minister in the government of Fernando Lugo, resigning on 15 June 2012 following violent clashes during an eviction of landless farmers occupying land.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Efraín Alegre</span> Paraguayan politician

Pedro Efraín Alegre Sasiain is a Paraguayan politician, lawyer, and university professor. President of the Authentic Radical Liberal Party (PLRA), Alegre served as president of the Chamber of Deputies between 2000 and 2001; Senator in 2008; and Minister of Public Work and Communications between 2008 and 2011 in the Fernando Lugo cabinet. He was a presidential candidate in the 2013, 2018, and 2023 general elections, coming second in all three elections and losing to different candidates from the Colorado Party in each of the three elections.

Victor Luís Bernal Garay is a Paraguayan senator for the Colorado Party and the former director of the bi-national hydroelectric enterprise Itaipú. He is an accountant by profession. An official investigation of Bernal's finances began while he was at Itaipú and continued into his years in the Senate. An attempt was made to impeach him, and both he and his wife, María Elizabeth Pleva, spent years engaged in legal battles over charges of embezzlement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2017 Paraguayan crisis</span>

On 31 March 2017, a series of protests began in Paraguay, during which demonstrators set fire to the Congress building. The demonstrations occurred in response to a constitutional amendment that would permit President Horacio Cartes to run for re-election, a move described by the opposition as "a coup". One protester was killed in Paraguay's capital, Asunción, after being hit by a shotgun blast by police. Several protesters, politicians and journalists, as well as police, were reported injured, including one lower-house deputy who had to undergo surgery after being injured by rubber bullets. On 17 April, President Cartes announced that he was resigning from any possible candidacy for a second presidential term. On 26 April, the Chamber of Deputies of Paraguay rejected the proposed constitutional amendment for presidential re-election.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1954 Paraguayan coup d'état</span>

The 1954 Paraguayan coup d'état occurred in May 1954. It was led by Alfredo Stroessner, with the support of Epifanio Méndez Fleitas, and resulted in the overthrow of the government of Federico Chávez. The coup was the culmination of a complex series of political rivalries within the ruling Colorado Party. Approximately 25 people were killed during the putsch, which helped set the stage for the election of Stroessner as president of Paraguay later that year.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conservative wave</span> Political phenomenon in Latin America

The conservative wave, or blue tide, was a right-wing political phenomenon that occurred in the mid-2010s to the early 2020s in Latin America as a direct reaction to the pink tide.

<i>Marzo paraguayo</i> Political crisis in Paraguay

The Marzo paraguayo was a political crisis that occurred in Paraguay because of the assassination of the then-Vice President Luis María Argaña on 23 March 1999. The opposition blamed the then-President, Raúl Cubas Grau, and also the strongman of Paraguayan politics of that time, Lino Oviedo, for the assassination. Argaña's assassination provoked a series of demonstrations by opponents and supporters to Oviedo and the Cubas government, which culminated in clashes in which seven demonstrators opposed to the government died, which resulted in the resignation of Cubas from the presidency.

The I CELAC summit or 2013 CELAC summit was the first ordinary heads of state summit of the Community of Latin American and Caribbean States. It was held on 27 and 28 January 2013 in Santiago, Chile.

References

  1. 1 2 Reuters, 26 June 2012, Paraguay's Lugo says only miracle can reinstate him
  2. 1 2 3 4 (in Spanish)Crónica, 20 June 2012, Lugo creó una comisión civil para investigar masacre en Curuguaty Archived 28 September 2013 at the Wayback Machine
  3. 1 2 3 (in Spanish) Diario ABC Color , 15 June 2012, Dantesco enfrentamiento en colonia de Curuguaty
  4. 1 2 BBC, 23 June 2012, Paraguay President Fernando Lugo impeached by congress
  5. 1 2 EFE, Sydney Morning Herald , 17 June 2012, Minister dumped after Paraguay strife
  6. ↑ "Candia Amarilla: De juez blanqueador estronista a Ministro del Interior | E'a". Archived from the original on 26 June 2012. Retrieved 27 June 2012.
  7. ↑ (in Spanish) La Nación , 16 June 2012, Rubén Candia Amarilla es el nuevo ministro del Interior Archived 19 June 2012 at the Wayback Machine
  8. ↑ "Ante la presión, Lugo busca cambiar de nuevo al comandante de la Policía". Ultimahora.com. Retrieved 28 October 2018.
  9. ↑ Paraguay president faces impeachment after deadly clash, Mariano Castillo, CNN, 21 June 2012
  10. ↑ Paraguay's President Fernando Lugo faces impeachment, BBC, 21 June 2012
  11. ↑ "Unasur delegation travels to Paraguay to ensure "democratic system integrity"". En.mercopress.com. 21 June 2012. Retrieved 22 June 2012.
  12. ↑ ""Institutional coup" removes Paraguayan president Lugo from office". Merco Press. 22 June 2012. Retrieved 22 June 2012.
  13. ↑ "Paraguay: el Congreso destituyó al presidente Lugo" [Paraguay: the Congress deposed president Lugo]. La Nación (in Spanish). 22 June 2012. Retrieved 22 June 2012.
  14. ↑ (in Spanish) Última Hora , 25 June 2012, Justicia Electoral declara a Franco presidente legítimo de Paraguay
  15. ↑ "Congreso vota a favor del "juicio político" contra Fernando Lugo". Elnorte.ec. Retrieved 28 October 2018.
  16. ↑ "Paraguayan President Impeached". Worldview.stratfor.com. Retrieved 28 October 2018.
  17. ↑ "Argentina "no convalidará el golpe en Paraguay" mientras que Brasil sugirió que quedaría fuera de la Unasur y el Mercosur" [Argentina "will not support the coup in Paraguay" and Brazil suggested that it would be left out of Unasur and Mercosur]. La Nación (in Spanish). 22 June 2012. Retrieved 22 June 2012.
  18. ↑ Orsi, Peter (24 June 2012). "Does Paraguay risk pariah status with president's ouster?". Associated Press.
  19. ↑ (Spanish) Informador "Evo Morales retira embajador boliviano en Paraguay" (2 June 2012) Guadalajara: México. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
  20. ↑ Moffett, Matt; Romig, Shane (24 June 2012). "Paraguay's Neighbors Protest Swift Removal of Leader" . The Wall Street Journal . Retrieved 20 February 2018.
  21. ↑ Mendoza, Associated Press in (29 June 2012). "Paraguay suspended from Mercosur". The Guardian . Retrieved 28 October 2018.
  22. ↑ IACHR, 23 June 2012, IACHR Expresses Concern over the Ousting of the Paraguayan President
  23. ↑ Reporters without Borders, 26 June 2012, Concern about public media after President Lugo’s controversial ouster Archived 7 July 2012 at the Wayback Machine
  24. ↑ "Jurídicamente no es un golpe de Estado" Archived 17 December 2013 at the Wayback Machine - El Observador, 22 June 2012
  25. ↑ Sanguinetti criticó actitud del Mercosur por crisis paraguaya - El País, 24 June 2012
  26. ↑ Partido Nacional recibe a delegación - El País, 27 June 2012
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.