Impeachment of Bill Clinton

Last updated

Impeachment of Bill Clinton
Senate in session.jpg
Floor proceedings of the U.S. Senate during the trial of President Bill Clinton in 1999, Chief Justice William Rehnquist presiding
Accused Bill Clinton, 42nd President of the United States
Proponents
DateDecember 19, 1998 (1998-12-19) to February 12, 1999 (1999-02-12)
OutcomeAcquitted by the U.S. Senate, remained in office
ChargesPerjury (2), obstruction of justice, abuse of power
CauseClinton's testimony denying that he had engaged in a sexual relationship with Monica Lewinsky in a sexual harassment lawsuit filed against Clinton by Paula Jones; allegations made in the Starr Report
Congressional votes
Voting in the U.S. House of Representatives
AccusationPerjury /grand jury
Votes in favor228
Votes against206
ResultApproved
AccusationPerjury /Jones case
Votes in favor205
Votes against229
ResultRejected
AccusationObstruction of justice
Votes in favor221
Votes against212
ResultApproved
AccusationAbuse of power
Votes in favor148
Votes against285
ResultRejected
Voting in the U.S. Senate
AccusationArticle I – perjury /grand jury
Votes in favor45 "guilty"
Votes against55 "not guilty"
ResultAcquitted (67 "guilty" votes necessary for a conviction)
AccusationArticle II – obstruction of justice
Votes in favor50 "guilty"
Votes against50 "not guilty"
ResultAcquitted (67 "guilty" votes necessary for a conviction)

Bill Clinton, the 42nd president of the United States, was impeached by the United States House of Representatives of the 105th United States Congress on December 19, 1998, for "high crimes and misdemeanors". The House adopted two articles of impeachment against Clinton, with the specific charges against Clinton being lying under oath and obstruction of justice. Two other articles had been considered but were rejected by the House vote.

Contents

Clinton's impeachment came after a formal House inquiry, which had been launched on October 8, 1998. The charges for which Clinton was impeached stemmed from a sexual harassment lawsuit filed against Clinton by Paula Jones. During pre-trial discovery in the lawsuit, Clinton gave testimony denying that he had engaged in a sexual relationship with White House intern Monica Lewinsky. The catalyst for the president's impeachment was the Starr Report, a September 1998 report prepared by Ken Starr, Independent Counsel, for the House Judiciary Committee. The Starr Report included details outlining a sexual relationship between Clinton and Lewinsky [1] Clinton was the second American president to be impeached, the first being Andrew Johnson, who was impeached in 1868. [lower-alpha 1]

The approved articles of impeachment would be submitted to the United States Senate on January 7, 1999. A trial in the Senate then began, with Chief Justice William Rehnquist presiding. On February 12, Clinton was acquitted on both counts as neither received the necessary two-thirds majority vote of the senators present for conviction and removal from office—in this instance 67 votes were needed. On Article One, 45 senators voted to convict while 55 voted for acquittal. On Article Two, 50 senators voted to convict while 50 voted for acquittal. [3] Clinton remained in office for the remainder of his second term. [4]

Background

In 1994, Paula Jones filed a lawsuit accusing Clinton of sexual harassment when he was governor of Arkansas. [5] Clinton attempted to delay a trial until after he left office, but in May 1997 the Supreme Court unanimously rejected Clinton's claim that the Constitution immunized him from civil lawsuits, and shortly thereafter the pre-trial discovery process commenced. [6]

Separate from this, in January 1994, Attorney General Janet Reno appointed Robert B. Fiske as an Independent counsel to investigate the Whitewater controversy. [7] In August of that year, Ken Starr was appointed to replace Fiske in this role. [7]

In 1997, the first effort in Congress to start an impeachment against Clinton was launched by Republican Congressman Bob Barr. [8]

In a January 17, 1998, sworn deposition, Clinton denied having a "sexual relationship", "sexual affair", or "sexual relations" with Lewinsky. [9] His lawyer, Robert S. Bennett, stated with Clinton present that Lewinsky's affidavit showed there was no sex in any manner, shape or form between Clinton and Lewinsky. The Starr Report states that the following day, Clinton "coached" his secretary Betty Currie into repeating his denials should she be called to testify.

After rumors of the scandal reached the news, Clinton publicly said, "I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Miss Lewinsky." [10] But months later, Clinton admitted his relationship with Lewinsky was "wrong" and "not appropriate". Lewinsky engaged in oral sex with Clinton several times. [11] [12]

The judge in the Jones case later ruled the Lewinsky matter immaterial, and threw out the case in April 1998 on the grounds that Jones had failed to show any damages. After Jones appealed, Clinton agreed in November 1998 to settle the case for $850,000 while still admitting no wrongdoing. [13]

The Starr Report was released to Congress on September 9, 1998, and to the public on September 11. [7] [14] In the report, Starr argued that there were eleven possible grounds for impeachment of Clinton, including perjury, obstruction of justice, witness tampering, and abuse of power. The report also detailed explicit and graphic details of the sexual relationship between Clinton and Lewinsky. [7] [15]

Independent counsel investigation

The charges arose from an investigation by Ken Starr, an Independent Counsel. [16] With the approval of United States Attorney General Janet Reno, Starr conducted a wide-ranging investigation of alleged abuses, including the Whitewater controversy, the firing of White House travel agents, and the alleged misuse of FBI files. On January 12, 1998, Linda Tripp, who had been working with Jones's lawyers, informed Starr that Lewinsky was preparing to commit perjury in the Jones case and had asked Tripp to do the same. She also said Clinton's friend Vernon Jordan was assisting Lewinsky. Based on the connection to Jordan, who was under scrutiny in the Whitewater probe, Starr obtained approval from Reno to expand his investigation into whether Lewinsky and others were breaking the law.

A much-quoted statement from Clinton's grand jury testimony showed him questioning the precise use of the word "is". Contending his statement that "there's nothing going on between us" had been truthful because he had no ongoing relationship with Lewinsky at the time he was questioned, Clinton said, "It depends on what the meaning of the word 'is' is. If the—if he—if 'is' means is and never has been, that is not—that is one thing. If it means there is none, that was a completely true statement." [17] Starr obtained further evidence of inappropriate behavior by seizing the computer hard drive and email records of Monica Lewinsky. Based on the president's conflicting testimony, Starr concluded that Clinton had committed perjury. Starr submitted his findings to Congress in a lengthy document, the Starr Report , which was released to the public via the Internet a few days later and included descriptions of encounters between Clinton and Lewinsky. [18] Starr was criticized by Democrats for spending $70 million on the investigation. [19] Critics of Starr also contend that his investigation was highly politicized because it regularly leaked tidbits of information to the press in violation of legal ethics, and because his report included lengthy descriptions which were humiliating and irrelevant to the legal case. [20] [21]

Impeachment inquiry by the House Committee on the Judiciary

On October 8, 1998, the United States House of Representatives voted to authorize a broad impeachment inquiry, thereby initiating the impeachment process. [22] The Republican controlled House of Representatives had decided this with a bipartisan vote of 258–176, with 31 Democrats joining Republicans. [23] Since Ken Starr had already completed an extensive investigation, the House Judiciary Committee conducted no investigations of its own into Clinton's alleged wrongdoing and held no serious impeachment-related hearings before the 1998 midterm elections.[ citation needed ] Impeachment was one of the major issues in those elections.[ citation needed ]

In the November 1998 House elections, the Democrats picked up five seats in the House, but the Republicans still maintained majority control. The results went against what House Speaker Newt Gingrich predicted, who, before the election, had been reassured by private polling that Clinton's scandal would result in Republican gains of up to thirty House seats. Shortly after the elections, Gingrich, who had been one of the leading advocates for impeachment, announced he would resign from Congress as soon as he was able to find somebody to fill his vacant seat; [24] [25] Gingrich fulfilled this pledge, and officially resigned from Congress on January 3, 1999. [26]

Impeachment proceedings were held during the post-election, "lame duck" session of the outgoing 105th United States Congress. Unlike the case of the 1974 impeachment process against Richard Nixon, the committee hearings were perfunctory but the floor debate in the whole House was spirited on both sides. The Speaker-designate, Representative Bob Livingston, chosen by the Republican Party Conference to replace Gingrich as House Speaker, announced the end of his candidacy for Speaker and his resignation from Congress from the floor of the House after his own marital infidelity came to light. [27] In the same speech, Livingston also encouraged Clinton to resign. Clinton chose to remain in office and urged Livingston to reconsider his resignation. [28] Many other prominent Republican members of Congress (including Dan Burton, [27] Helen Chenoweth, [27] and Henry Hyde, [27] the chief House manager of Clinton's trial in the Senate) had infidelities exposed about this time, all of whom voted for impeachment. Publisher Larry Flynt offered a reward for such information, and many supporters of Clinton accused Republicans of hypocrisy. [27]

Impeachment by House of Representatives

December 18, 1998: The House continued debate on four articles of impeachment against President Clinton for perjury, obstruction of justice and abuse of power.

On December 11, 1998, the House Judiciary Committee agreed to send four articles of impeachment to the full House for consideration. The vote on two articles, grand jury perjury and obstruction of justice, was 21–17, both along party lines. On the other, perjury in the Paula Jones case, the committee voted 20–18, with Republican Lindsey Graham joining with Democrats, in order to give President Clinton "the legal benefit of the doubt". [29] The next day, December 12, the committee agreed to send a fourth and final article, for abuse of power, to the full House by a 21–17 vote, again, along party lines. [30]

Although proceedings were delayed due to the bombing of Iraq, on the passage of H. Res. 611, Clinton was impeached by the House of Representatives on December 19, 1998, on grounds of perjury to a grand jury (first article, 228–206) [31] and obstruction of justice (third article, 221–212). [32] The two other articles were rejected, the count of perjury in the Jones case (second article, 205–229) [33] and abuse of power (fourth article, 148–285). [34] Clinton thus became the second U.S. president to be impeached; the first, Andrew Johnson, was impeached in 1868. [35] [36] The only other previous U.S. president to be the subject of formal House impeachment proceedings was Richard Nixon in 1973–74. The Judiciary Committee agreed to a resolution containing three articles of impeachment in July 1974, but Nixon resigned from office soon thereafter, before the House took up the resolution. [37]

H. Res. 611 – Impeaching President Bill Clinton
December 19, 1998
First article
(perjury /grand jury)
PartyTotal votes [31]
Democratic Republican Independent
Yea Black check.svg52230228
Nay20051206
Second article
(perjury /Jones case)
PartyTotal votes [33]
Democratic Republican Independent
Yea52000205
Nay Black check.svg200281229
Third article
(obstruction of justice)
PartyTotal votes [32]
Democratic Republican Independent
Yea Black check.svg52160221
Nay199121212
Fourth article
(abuse of power)
PartyTotal votes [34]
Democratic Republican Independent
Yea11470148
Nay Black check.svg203811285

Five Democrats (Virgil Goode, Ralph Hall, Paul McHale, Charles Stenholm and Gene Taylor) voted for the first three articles of impeachment, but only Taylor voted for the abuse of power charge. Five Republicans (Amo Houghton, Peter King, Connie Morella, Chris Shays and Mark Souder) voted against the first perjury charge. Eight more Republicans (Sherwood Boehlert, Michael Castle, Phil English, Nancy Johnson, Jay Kim, Jim Leach, John McHugh and Ralph Regula), but not Souder, voted against the obstruction charge. Twenty-eight Republicans voted against the second perjury charge, sending it to defeat, and eighty-one voted against the abuse of power charge.

Votes by member
DistrictMemberPartyVotes on proposed articles
1st
(perjury/grand jury)
[38]
2nd
(perjury/Jones case)
[39]
3rd
(obstruction of justice)
[40]
4th
(abuse of power)
[41]
Hawaii 1 Neil Abercrombie
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 5 Gary Ackerman
D
NayNayNayNay
Alabama 4 Robert Aderholt
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Maine 1 Tom Allen
D
NayNayDid not voteDid not vote
New Jersey 1 Rob Andrews
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 7 Bill Archer
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 26 Dick Armey
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Alabama 6 Spencer Bachus
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Kentucky 6 Scotty Baesler
D
NayNayNayNay
Louisiana 6 Richard Baker
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Maine 2 John Baldacci
D
NayNayNayNay
North Carolina 10 Cass Ballenger
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Michigan 5 James A. Barcia
D
NayNayNayNay
Georgia 7 Bob Barr
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Nebraska 3 Bill Barrett
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Wisconsin 5 Tom Barrett
D
NayNayNayNay
Maryland 6 Roscoe Bartlett
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 6 Joe Barton
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Hampshire 2 Charles Bass
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Virginia 1 Joe Barton
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 30 Xavier Becerra
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 25 Ken Bentsen
D
NayNayNayNay
Nebraska 1 Doug Bereuter
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
California 26 Howard Berman
D
NayNayNayNay
Arkansas 1 Marion Berry
D
NayNayNayNay
California 49 Brian Bilbray
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Florida 9 Michael Bilirakis
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Georgia 2 Sanford Bishop
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 5 Rod Blagojevich
D
NayNayNayNay
Virginia 7 Thomas J. Bliley Jr.
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Florida 9 Michael Bilirakis
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Oregon 3 Earl Blumenauer
D
NayNayNayNay
Missouri 7 Roy Blunt
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New York 23 Sherwood Boehlert
R
YeaYeaNayNay
Ohio 8 John Boehner
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 23 Henry Bonilla
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Michigan 10 David Bonior
D
NayNayNayNay
California 44 Mary Bono
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 3 Robert Borski
D
NayNayNayNay
Iowa 3 Leonard Boswell
D
NayNayNayNay
Virginia 9 Rick Boucher
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 2 Allen Boyd
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 1 Bob Brady
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 8 Kevin Brady
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 42 George Brown Jr.
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 13 Sherrod Brown
D
NayNayNayNay
Tennessee 7 Ed Bryant
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Kentucky 4 Jim Bunning
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
North Carolina 5 Richard Burr
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Indiana 6 Dan Burton
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Indiana 5 Steve Buyer
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Alabama 1 Sonny Callahan
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 43 Ken Calvert
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Michigan 4 Dave Camp
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 15 Tom Campbell
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Florida 12 Charles Canady
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Utah 3 Chris Cannon
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 22 Lois Capps
D
NayNayNayNay
Maryland 3 Ben Cardin
D
NayNayNayNay
Indiana 10 Julia Carson
D
NayNayNayNay
Delaware at-large Mike Castle
R
YeaNayNayNay
Ohio 1 Steve Chabot
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Georgia 8 Saxby Chambliss
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Idaho 1 Helen Chenoweth
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Nebraska 2 Jon Christensen
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Michigan 1 Bill Clay
D
NayNayNayNay
North Carolina 1 Eva Clayton
D
NayNayNayNay
Tennessee 5 Bob Clement
D
NayNayNayNay
South Carolina 6 Jim Clyburn
D
NayNayNayNay
North Carolina 6 Howard Coble
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Oklahoma 2 Tom Coburn
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Georgia 3 Mac Collins
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 19 Larry Combest
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 18 Gary Condit
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 14 John Conyers
D
NayNayNayNay
Utah 2 Merrill Cook
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Louisiana 5 John Cooksey
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Illinois 12 Jerry Costello
D
NayNayNayNay
California 47 Christopher Cox
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 14 William J. Coyne
D
NayNayNayNay
Alabama 5 Bud Cramer
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 8 Phil Crane
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Idaho 2 Mike Crapo
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Wyoming at-large Barbara Cubin
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Maryland 7 Elijah Cummings
D
NayNayNayNay
California 51 Duke Cunningham
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Missouri 6 Pat Danner
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 11 Jim Davis
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 7 Danny K. Davis
D
NayNayNayNay
Virginia 11 Tom Davis
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Georgia 9 Nathan Deal
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Oregon 4 Peter DeFazio
D
NayNayNayNay
Colorado 1 Diana DeGette
D
NayNayNayNay
Massachusetts 10 Bill Delahunt
D
NayNayNayNay
Connecticut 3 Rosa DeLauro
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 22 Tom DeLay
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Florida 20 Peter Deutsch
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 21 Lincoln Díaz-Balart
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Arkansas 4 Jay Dickey
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Washington 6 Norm Dicks
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 16 John Dingell
D
NayNayNayNay
California 32 Julian Dixon
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 10 Lloyd Doggett
D
NayNayNayNay
California 20 Cal Dooley
D
NayNayNayNay
California 4 John Doolittle
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 18 Mike Doyle
D
NayNayNayNay
California 28 David Dreier
D
NayNayNayNay
Tennessee 2 Jimmy Duncan
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Washington 8 Jennifer Dunn
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 11 Chet Edwards
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 3 Vern Ehlers
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Maryland 2 Bob Ehrlich
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Missouri 8 Jo Ann Emerson
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New York 17 Eliot Engel
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 21 Phil English
R
YeaNayNayNay
Nevada 1 John Ensign
R
YeaNayYeaNay
California 14 Anna Eshoo
D
NayNayNayNay
North Carolina 2 Bob Etheridge
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 17 Lane Evans
D
NayNayNayNay
Alabama 2 Terry Everett
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Illinois 15 Tom Ewing
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 17 Sam Farr
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 2 Chaka Fattah
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 13 Harris Fawell
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
California 3 Vic Fazio
D
NayNayNayNay
California 50 Bob Filner
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 16 Mark Foley
R
YeaNayYeaNay
New York 1 Michael Forbes
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Tennessee 9 Harold Ford Jr.
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 13 Vito Fossella
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Florida 4 Tillie Fowler
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 13 Jon D. Fox
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Massachusetts 4 Barney Frank
D
NayNayNayNay
New Jersey 7 Bob Franks
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New Jersey 11 Rodney Frelinghuysen
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Texas 24 Martin Frost
D
NayNayNayNay
Oregon 1 Elizabeth Furse
D
NayNayNayNay
California 23 Elton Gallegly
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Iowa 4 Greg Ganske
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Connecticut 2 Sam Gejdenson
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 17 George Gekas
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Missouri 3 Dick Gephardt
D
NayNayNayNay
Nevada 2 Jim Gibbons
R
YeaNayYeaYea
Maryland 1 Wayne Gilchrest
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Ohio 5 Paul Gillmor
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New York 20 Benjamin Gilman
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Georgia 6 Newt Gingrich
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 20 Henry B. González
D
NayNayNayNay
Virginia 5 Virgil Goode
D
YeaYeaYeaNay
Virginia 6 Bob Goodlatte
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 19 Bill Goodling
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Tennessee 6 Bart Gordon
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 14 Porter Goss
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
South Carolina 3 Lindsey Graham
R
YeaNayYeaYea
Texas 12 Kay Granger
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Texas 29 Gene Greene
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 8 Jim Greenwood
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Illinois 4 Luis Gutiérrez
D
NayNayNayNay
Minnesota 1 Gil Gutknecht
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Ohio 3 Tony P. Hall
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 4 Ralph Hall
D
YeaYeaYeaNay
Indiana 9 Lee Hamilton
D
NayNayNayNay
Utah 1 Jim Hansen
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 36 Jane Harman
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 14 Dennis Hastert
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Florida 23 Alcee Hastings
D
NayNayNayNay
Washington 4 Doc Hastings
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Arizona 6 J. D. Hayworth
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Colorado 5 Joel Hefley
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
North Carolina 8 Bill Hefner
D
NayNayNayNay
California 2 Wally Herger
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Montana at-large Rick Hill
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Tennessee 4 Van Hilleary
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Alabama 7 Earl Hilliard Sr.
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 26 Maurice Hinchey
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 15 Rubén Hinojosa
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 7 Dave Hobson
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Michigan 2 Pete Hoekstra
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 6 Tim Holden
D
NayNayNayNay
Oregon 5 Darlene Hooley
D
NayNayNayNay
California 38 Steve Horn
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Indiana 8 John Hostettler
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New York 31 Amo Houghton
R
NayNayNayNay
Maryland 5 Steny Hoyer
D
NayNayNayNay
Missouri 9 Kenny Hulshof
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
California 52 Duncan L. Hunter
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Arkansas 3 Asa Hutchinson
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Illinois 6 Henry Hyde
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
South Carolina 4 Bob Inglis
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Oklahoma 5 Ernest Istook
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Illinois 2 Jesse Jackson Jr.
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 18 Sheila Jackson Lee
D
NayNayNayNay
Louisiana 2 William Jefferson
D
NayNayNayNay
Tennessee 1 Bill Jenkins
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Louisiana 7 Chris John
D
NayNayNayNay
Connecticut 6 Nancy Johnson
R
YeaYeaNayNay
Wisconsin 8 Jay Johnson
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 30 Eddie Bernice Johnson
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 3 Sam Johnson
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
North Carolina 3 Walter B. Jones Jr.
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 11 Paul Kanjorski
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 9 Marcy Kaptur
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 12 John Kasich
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New York 19 Sue Kelly
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Massachusetts 8 Joseph P. Kennedy II
D
NayNayNayNay
Rhode Island 1 Patrick J. Kennedy
D
NayNayNayNay
Connecticut 1 Barbara B. Kennelly
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 9 Dale Kildee
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 15 Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick
D
NayNayNayNay
California 41 Jay Kim
R
YeaNayNayNay
Wisconsin 3 Ron Kind
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 3 Peter King
R
NayNayNayNay
Georgia 1 Jack Kingston
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Wisconsin 4 Jerry Kleczka
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 4 Ron Klink
D
NayNayNayNay
Wisconsin 2 Scott Klug
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Michigan 11 Joe Knollenberg
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Arizona 5 Jim Kolbe
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Ohio 10 Dennis Kucinich
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 29 John LaFalce
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 18 Ray LaHood
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 9 Nick Lampson
D
NayNayNayNay
California 12 Tom Lantos
D
NayNayNayNay
Oklahoma 1 Steve Largent
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Iowa 5 Tom Latham
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Ohio 19 Steve LaTourette
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New York 2 Rick Lazio
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Iowa 1 Jim Leach
R
YeaYeaNayNay
California 9 Barbara Lee
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 12 Sander Levin
D
NayNayNayNay
California 40 Jerry Lewis
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Georgia 5 John Lewis
D
NayNayNayNay
Kentucky 2 Ron Lewis
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Georgia 11 John Linder
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Illinois 3 Bill Lipinski
D
NayNayNayNay
Louisiana 1 Bob Livingston
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Jersey 2 Frank LoBiondo
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
California 16 Zoe Lofgren
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 18 Nita Lowey
D
NayNayNayNay
Oklahoma 6 Frank Lucas
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Minnesota 6 Bill Luther
D
NayNayNayNay
Connecticut 5 James H. Maloney
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 14 Carolyn Maloney
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 7 Tomas Manton
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 16 Don Manzullo
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Massachusetts 7 Ed Markey
D
NayNayNayNay
California 31 Matthew G. Martínez
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 20 Frank Mascara
D
NayNayNayNay
California 5 Bob Matsui
D
NayNayNayNay
Missouri 5 Karen McCarthy
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 4 Carolyn McCarthy
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 8 Bill McCollum
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Louisiana 4 Jim McCrery
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Pennsylvania 10 Joseph M. McDade
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Washington 7 Jim McDermott
D
NayNayNayNay
Massachusetts 3 Jim McGovern
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 15 Paul McHale
D
YeaYeaYeaNay
New York 24 John M. McHugh
R
YeaYeaNayNay
Colorado 3 Scott McInnis
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Indiana 2 David McIntosh
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
North Carolina 7 Mike McIntyre
D
NayNayNayNay
California 25 Buck McKeon
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Georgia 4 Cynthia McKinney
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 21 Michael McNulty
D
NayNayNayNay
Massachusetts 4 Marty Meehan
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 17 Carrie Meek
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 6 Gregory Meeks
D
NayNayNayNay
New Jersey 13 Bob Menendez
D
NayNayNayNay
Washington 2 Jack Metcalf
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Florida 7 John Mica
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 37 Juanita Millender-McDonald
D
NayNayNayNay
California 7 George Miller
D
Did not voteDid not voteDid not voteDid not vote
Florida 13 Dan Miller
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Minnesota 2 David Minge
D
NayNayNayNay
Hawaii 2 Patsy Mink
D
NayNayNayNay
Massachusetts 9 Joe Moakley
D
NayNayNayNay
West Virginia 1 Alan Mollohan
D
NayNayNayNay
Kansas 1 Jerry Moran
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Virginia 8 Jim Moran
D
NayNayNayNay
Maryland 8 Connie Morella
R
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 12 John Murtha
D
NayNayNayNay
North Carolina 9 Sue Myrick
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New York 8 Jerry Nadler
D
NayNayNayNay
Massachusetts 2 Richard Neal
D
NayNayNayNay
Washington 5 George Nethercutt
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Wisconsin 1 Mark Neumann
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Ohio 18 Bob Ney
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Kentucky 3 Anne Northup
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Georgia 10 Charlie Norwood
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Iowa 2 Jim Nussle
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Michigan 8 Jim Oberstar
D
NayNayNayNay
Wisconsin 7 Dave Obey
D
NayNayNayNay
Massachusetts 1 John Olver
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 27 Solomon Ortiz
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 11 Major Owens
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 4 Mike Oxley
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 48 Ron Packard
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Jersey 6 Frank Pallone
D
NayNayNayNay
New Jersey 12 Mike Pappas
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Missouri 4 Michael Parker
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New Jersey 8 Bill Pascrell
D
NayNayNayNay
Arizona 2 Ed Pastor
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 14 Ron Paul
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 27 Bill Paxon
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Jersey 10 Donald M. Payne
D
NayNayNayNay
Indiana 7 Ed Pease
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 8 Nancy Pelosi
D
NayNayNayNay
Minnesota 7 Collin Peterson
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 5 John Peterson
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Wisconsin 6 Tom Petri
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Missouri 3 Chip Pickering
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Virginia 2 Owen B. Pickett
D
NayNayNayNay
Pennsylvania 16 Joe Pitts
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 11 Richard Pombo
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
North Dakota at-large Earl Pomeroy
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 10 John Porter
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Ohio 2 Rob Portman
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Illinois 19 Glenn Poshard
D
NayNayNayNay
North Carolina 4 David Price
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 15 Deborah Pryce
R
YeaNayYeaNay
New York 30 Jack Quinn
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
California 19 George Radanovich
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
West Virginia 3 Nick Rahall
D
NayNayNayNay
Minnesota 3 Jim Ramstad
R
YeaNayYeaNay
New York 15 Charles Rangel
D
NayNayNayNay
New Mexico 3 Bill Redmond
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Ohio 16 Ralph Regula
R
YeaYeaNayNay
Texas 16 Silvestre Reyes
D
NayNayNayNay
California 1 Frank Riggs
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Alabama 3 Bob Riley
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Michigan 13 Lynn Rivers
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 28 Ciro Rodriguez
D
NayNayNayNay
Indiana 3 Tim Roemer
D
NayNayNayNay
California 27 James E. Rogan
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Kentucky 5 Hal Rogers
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
California 45 Dana Rohrabacher
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Florida 18 Ileana Ros-Lehtinen
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Jersey 9 Steve Rothman
D
NayNayNayNay
New Jersey 5 Marge Roukema
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 33 Lucille Roybal-Allard
D
NayNayNayNay
California 39 Ed Royce
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Illinois 1 Bobby Rush
D
NayNayNayNay
Kansas 2 Jim Ryun
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Minnesota 5 Martin Olav Sabo
D
NayNayNayNay
Arizona 1 Matt Salmon
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 46 Loretta Sanchez
D
NayNayNayNay
Vermont at-large Bernie Sanders
I
NayNayNayNay
Texas 1 Max Sandlin
D
NayNayNayNay
South Carolina 1 Mark Sanford
R
YeaNayYeaYea
Ohio 14 Tom Sawyer
D
NayNayNayNay
New Jersey 3 Jim Saxton
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Florida 1 Joe Scarborough
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Colorado 6 Daniel Schaefer
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Colorado 4 Bob Schaffer
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New York 9 Chuck Schumer
D
NayNayNayNay
Virginia 3 Bobby Scott
D
NayNayNayNay
Wisconsin 9 Jim Sensenbrenner
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New York 16 José E. Serrano
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 5 Pete Sessions
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Arizona 4 John Shadegg
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Florida 22 Clay Shaw
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Connecticut 4 Chris Shays
R
NayNayNayNay
California 14 Brad Sherman
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 20 John Shimkus
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Pennsylvania 9 Bud Shuster
R
YeaNayYeaNay
Virginia 4 Norman Sisisky
D
NayNayNayNay
Colorado 2 David Skaggs
D
NayNayNayNay
New Mexico 2 Joe Skeen
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Missouri 4 Ike Skelton
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 28 Louise Slaughter
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 7 Nick Smith
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Jersey 7 Chris Smith
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Oregon 2 Bob Smith
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 21 Lamar Smith
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Washington 9 Adam Smith
D
NayNayNayNay
Washington 3 Linda Smith
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Kansas 3 Vince Snowbarger
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Arkansas 2 Vic Snyder
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 22 Gerald Solomon
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Indiana 4 Mark Souder
R
NayNayYeaNay
South Carolina 2 Floyd Spence
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
South Carolina 5 John Spratt
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 8 Debbie Stabenow
D
NayNayNayNay
California 13 Pete Stark
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 6 Cliff Stearns
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Texas 17 Charles Stenholm
D
YeaYeaYeaNay
Ohio 11 Louis Stokes
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 6 Ted Strickland
D
NayNayNayNay
Arizona 3 Bob Stump
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Michigan 1 Bob Stupak
D
NayNayNayNay
New Hampshire 1 John E. Sununu
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Missouri 2 Jim Talent
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Tennessee 8 John Tanner
D
NayNayNayNay
California 10 Ellen Tauscher
D
NayNayNayNay
Louisiana 3 Billy Tauzin
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Mississippi 5 Gene Taylor
D
YeaYeaYeaYea
North Carolina 11 Charles Taylor
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 21 Bill Thomas
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Mississippi 2 Bennie Thompson
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 13 Mac Thornberry
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
South Dakota at-large John Thune
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Florida 5 Karen Thurman
D
NayNayNayNay
Kansas 4 Todd Tiahrt
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Massachusetts 6 John F. Tierney
D
NayNayNayNay
California 34 Esteban Torres
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 10 Edolphus Towns
D
NayNayNayNay
Ohio 17 James Traficant
D
NayNayNayNay
Texas 2 Jim Turner
D
NayNayNayNay
Michigan 6 Fred Upton
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
New York 12 Nydia Velázquez
D
NayNayNayNay
Minnesota 4 Bruce Vento
D
NayNayNayNay
Indiana 1 Pete Visclosky
D
NayNayNayNay
New York 25 James T. Walsh
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Tennessee 3 Zach Wamp
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 35 Maxine Waters
D
NayNayNayNay
Oklahoma 3 Wes Watkins
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
North Carolina 12 Mel Watt
D
NayNayNayNay
Oklahoma 4 J. C. Watts
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 29 Henry Waxman
D
NayNayNayNay
Florida 15 Dave Weldon
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Pennsylvania 7 Curt Weldon
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Illinois 11 Jerry Weller
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Illinois 19 Robert Wexler
D
NayNayNayNay
Rhode Island 2 Robert Weygand
D
NayNayNayNay
Washington 1 Rick White
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Kentucky 1 Ed Whitfield
R
YeaYeaYeaNay
Mississippi 1 Roger Wicker
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
New Mexico 1 Heather Wilson
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
West Virginia 2 Bob Wise
D
NayNayNayNay
Virginia 10 Frank Wolf
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
California 6 Lynn Woolsey
D
NayNayNayNay
Maryland 4 Albert Wynn
D
NayNayNayNay
Illinois 9 Sidney R. Yates
D
NayNayNayNay
Alaska at-large Don Young
R
YeaYeaYeaYea
Florida 10 Bill Young
R
YeaYeaYeaYea

Articles referred to Senate

Article I, charging Clinton with perjury, alleged in part that:

On August 17, 1998, William Jefferson Clinton swore to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth before a federal grand jury of the United States. Contrary to that oath, William Jefferson Clinton willfully provided perjurious, false and misleading testimony to the grand jury concerning one or more of the following:

  1. the nature and details of his relationship with a subordinate government employee;
  2. prior perjurious, false and misleading testimony he gave in a federal civil rights action brought against him;
  3. prior false and misleading statements he allowed his attorney to make to a federal judge in that civil rights action; and
  4. his corrupt efforts to influence the testimony of witnesses and to impede the discovery of evidence in that civil rights action. [42] [43]

Article II, charging Clinton with obstruction of justice alleged in part that:

The means used to implement this course of conduct or scheme included one or more of the following acts:

  1. ... corruptly encouraged a witness in a Federal civil rights action brought against him to execute a sworn affidavit in that proceeding that he knew to be perjurious, false and misleading.
  2. ... corruptly encouraged a witness in a Federal civil rights action brought against him to give perjurious, false and misleading testimony if and when called to testify personally in that proceeding.
  3. ... corruptly engaged in, encouraged, or supported a scheme to conceal evidence that had been subpoenaed in a Federal civil rights action brought against him.
  4. ... intensified and succeeded in an effort to secure job assistance to a witness in a Federal civil rights action brought against him in order to corruptly prevent the truthful testimony of that witness in that proceeding at a time when the truthful testimony of that witness would have been harmful to him.
  5. ... at his deposition in a Federal civil rights action brought against him, William Jefferson Clinton corruptly allowed his attorney to make false and misleading statements to a Federal judge characterizing an affidavit, in order to prevent questioning deemed relevant by the judge. Such false and misleading statements were subsequently acknowledged by his attorney in a communication to that judge.
  6. ... related a false and misleading account of events relevant to a Federal civil rights action brought against him to a potential witness in that proceeding, in order to corruptly influence the testimony of that witness.
  7. ... made false and misleading statements to potential witnesses in a Federal grand jury proceeding in order to corruptly influence the testimony of those witnesses. The false and misleading statements made by William Jefferson Clinton were repeated by the witnesses to the grand jury, causing the grand jury to receive false and misleading information. [42] [44]

Senate trial

Tickets dated January 14 and 15, 1999, for President Bill Clinton's impeachment trial Tickets for Bill Clinton's impeachment trial.jpg
Tickets dated January 14 and 15, 1999, for President Bill Clinton's impeachment trial

Preparation

Between December 20 and January 5, Republican and Democratic Senate leaders negotiated about the pending trial. [45] There was some discussion about the possibility of censuring Clinton instead of holding a trial. [45] Disagreement arose as to whether to call witnesses. This decision would ultimately not be made until after the opening arguments from the House impeachment managers and the White House defense team. [45] On January 5, the Republican Majority Leader Trent Lott, announced that the trial would start on January 7. [45]

Officers

Thirteen House Republicans from the Judiciary Committee served as "managers", the equivalent of prosecutors: Henry Hyde (chairman), Jim Sensenbrenner, Bill McCollum, George Gekas, Charles Canady, Steve Buyer, Ed Bryant, Steve Chabot, Bob Barr, Asa Hutchinson, Chris Cannon, James E. Rogan and Lindsey Graham. [46]

Clinton was defended by Cheryl Mills. Clinton's counsel staff included Charles Ruff, David E. Kendall, Dale Bumpers, Bruce Lindsey, Nicole Seligman, Lanny A. Breuer and Gregory B. Craig. [47]

Process and schedule

The Senate trial began on January 7, 1999, with Chief Justice of the United States William Rehnquist presiding. The first day consisted of formal presentation of the charges against Clinton, and of Rehnquist swearing in all senators. [45]

A resolution on rules and procedure for the trial was adopted unanimously on the following day; [48] however, senators tabled the question of whether to call witnesses in the trial. The trial remained in recess while briefs were filed by the House (January 11) and Clinton (January 13). [49] [50]

The managers presented their case over three days, from January 14 to 16, arguing for removal of the President from office by virtue of what they characterized as Clinton's "willful, premeditated, deliberate corruption of the nation's system of justice through perjury and obstruction of justice". [51] The defense presentation took place January 19–21. Clinton's defense counsel argued that the case made against Clinton was, "an unsubstantiated, circumstantial case that does not meet the constitutional standard to remove the President from office". [51] January 22 and 23 were devoted to questions from members of the Senate to the House managers and Clinton's defense counsel. Under the rules, all questions (over 150) were to be written down and given to Rehnquist to read to the party being questioned. [45] [52] [53]

On January 25, Senator Robert Byrd moved for dismissals of both articles of impeachment. On the following day, Representative Bryant moved to call witnesses to the trial, a question the Senate had scrupulously avoided to that point. In both cases, the Senate voted to deliberate on the question in private session, rather than public, televised procedure. On January 27, the Senate voted on both motions in public session; the motion to dismiss failed on a nearly party line vote of 56–44, while the motion to depose witnesses passed by the same margin. A day later, the Senate voted down motions to move directly to a vote on the articles of impeachment and to suppress videotaped depositions of the witnesses from public release, Senator Russ Feingold again voting with the Republicans.

Over three days, February 1–3, House managers took videotaped closed-door depositions from Monica Lewinsky, Clinton's friend Vernon Jordan, and White House aide Sidney Blumenthal. [54] On February 4, however, the Senate voted 70–30 that excerpting these videotapes would suffice as testimony, rather than calling live witnesses to appear at trial. The videos were played in the Senate on February 6, featuring 30 excerpts of Lewinsky discussing her affidavit in the Paula Jones case, the hiding of small gifts Clinton had given her, and his involvement in procurement of a job for Lewinsky.

On February 8, closing arguments were presented with each side allotted a three-hour time slot. On the President's behalf, White House Counsel Charles Ruff declared:

There is only one question before you, albeit a difficult one, one that is a question of fact and law and constitutional theory. Would it put at risk the liberties of the people to retain the President in office? Putting aside partisan animus, if you can honestly say that it would not, that those liberties are safe in his hands, then you must vote to acquit. [51]

Chief Prosecutor Henry Hyde countered:

A failure to convict will make the statement that lying under oath, while unpleasant and to be avoided, is not all that serious ... We have reduced lying under oath to a breach of etiquette, but only if you are the President ... And now let us all take our place in history on the side of honor, and, oh, yes, let right be done. [51]

Acquittal

On February 9, 1999, after voting against a public deliberation on the verdict, the Senate began closed-door deliberations instead. On February 12, 1999, the Senate emerged from its closed deliberations and voted on the articles of impeachment. A two-thirds vote, equal to 67 votes if all Senators voted, would have been necessary to convict on either charge and remove the President from office. The perjury charge was defeated with 45 votes for conviction and 55 against, and the obstruction of justice charge was defeated with 50 for conviction and 50 against. [3] [55] [56] Senator Arlen Specter voted "not proved" [lower-alpha 2] for both charges, [57] which was considered by Chief Justice Rehnquist to constitute a vote of "not guilty". All 45 Democrats in the Senate voted "not guilty" on both charges, as did five Republicans; they were joined by five additional Republicans in voting "not guilty" on the perjury charge. [3] [55] [56]

Robe worn by Chief Justice William Rehnquist during the impeachment trial William Rehnquist's robe by Matthew Bisanz.JPG
Robe worn by Chief Justice William Rehnquist during the impeachment trial
Congressional Record page, February 12, 1999, opening of the final day of the impeachment trial CongRec.png
Congressional Record page, February 12, 1999, opening of the final day of the impeachment trial
Articles of Impeachment, U.S. Senate judgement
(67 "guilty" votes necessary for a conviction)
Article One [58]
(perjury /grand jury)
PartyTotal votes
Democratic Republican
Guilty04545
Not guilty Black check.svg451055
Article Two [59]
(obstruction of justice)
PartyTotal votes
Democratic Republican
Guilty05050
Not guilty Black check.svg45550

Subsequent events

Contempt of court citation

In April 1999, about two months after being acquitted by the Senate, Clinton was cited by federal District Judge Susan Webber Wright for civil contempt of court for his "willful failure" to obey her orders to testify truthfully in the Paula Jones sexual harassment lawsuit. For this, Clinton was assessed a $90,000 fine and the matter was referred to the Arkansas Supreme Court to see if disciplinary action would be appropriate. [60]

Regarding Clinton's January 17, 1998, deposition where he was placed under oath, Webber Wright wrote:

Simply put, the president's deposition testimony regarding whether he had ever been alone with Ms. (Monica) Lewinsky was intentionally false, and his statements regarding whether he had ever engaged in sexual relations with Ms. Lewinsky likewise were intentionally false. [60]

On the day before leaving office on January 20, 2001, Clinton, in what amounted to a plea bargain, agreed to a five-year suspension of his Arkansas law license and to pay a $25,000 fine as part of an agreement with independent counsel Robert Ray to end the investigation without the filing of any criminal charges for perjury or obstruction of justice. [61] [62] On October 1, 2001, Clinton was accordingly suspended from the practice of law in the United States Supreme Court who also issued an order to show cause in 40 days "why he should not be disbarred from the practice of law in this Court." [63] Clinton resigned from the Supreme Court bar during the show-cause period, and the Supreme Court accordingly ordered his name "stricken from the roll of attorneys admitted to the practice of law before this Court." [64]

Civil settlement with Paula Jones

Eventually, the court dismissed the Paula Jones harassment lawsuit, before trial, on the grounds that Jones failed to demonstrate any damages. However, while the dismissal was on appeal, Clinton entered into an out-of-court settlement by agreeing to pay Jones $850,000. [65] [66]

Political ramifications

Opponents of Clinton's impeachment demonstrating outside the Capitol in December 1998 19a.AntiImpeachRally.WDC.17December1998 (22717930575).jpg
Opponents of Clinton's impeachment demonstrating outside the Capitol in December 1998

Polls conducted during 1998 and early 1999 showed that only about one-third of Americans supported Clinton's impeachment or conviction. However, one year later, when it was clear that impeachment would not lead to the ousting of the President, half of Americans said in a CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll that they supported impeachment, 57% approved of the Senate's decision to keep him in office, and two-thirds of those polled said the impeachment was harmful to the country. [67]

While Clinton's job approval rating rose during the Clinton–Lewinsky scandal and subsequent impeachment, his poll numbers with regard to questions of honesty, integrity and moral character declined. [68] As a result, "moral character" and "honesty" weighed heavily in the next presidential election. According to The Daily Princetonian , after the 2000 presidential election, "post-election polls found that, in the wake of Clinton-era scandals, the single most significant reason people voted for Bush was for his moral character." [69] [70] [71] According to an analysis of the election by Stanford University:

A more political explanation is the belief in Gore campaign circles that disapproval of President Clinton's personal behavior was a serious threat to the vice president's prospects. Going into the election the one negative element in the public's perception of the state of the nation was the belief that the country was morally on the wrong track, whatever the state of the economy or world affairs. According to some insiders, anything done to raise the association between Gore and Clinton would have produced a net loss of support—the impact of Clinton's personal negatives would outweigh the positive impact of his job performance on support for Gore. Thus, hypothesis four suggests that a previously unexamined variable played a major role in 2000—the retiring president's personal approval. [72]

The Stanford analysis, however, presented different theories and mainly argued that Gore had lost because he decided to distance himself from Clinton during the campaign. The writers of it concluded: [72]

We find that Gore's oft-criticized personality was not a cause of his under-performance. Rather, the major cause was his failure to receive a historically normal amount of credit for the performance of the Clinton administration ... [and] failure to get normal credit reflected Gore's peculiar campaign which in turn reflected fear of association with Clinton's behavior. [72]

According to the America's Future Foundation:

In the wake of the Clinton scandals, independents warmed to Bush's promise to 'restore honor and dignity to the White House'. According to Voter News Service, the personal quality that mattered most to voters was 'honesty'. Voters who chose 'honesty' preferred Bush over Gore by over a margin of five to one. Forty four percent of Americans said the Clinton scandals were important to their vote. Of these, Bush reeled in three out of every four. [73]

Political commentators have argued that Gore's refusal to have Clinton campaign with him was a bigger liability to Gore than Clinton's scandals. [72] [74] [75] [76] [77] The 2000 U.S. Congressional election also saw the Democrats gain more seats in Congress. [78] As a result of this gain, control of the Senate was split 50–50 between both parties, [79] and Democrats would gain control over the Senate after Republican Senator Jim Jeffords defected from his party in early 2001 and agreed to caucus with the Democrats. [80]

Al Gore reportedly confronted Clinton after the election, and "tried to explain that keeping Clinton under wraps [during the campaign] was a rational response to polls showing swing voters were still mad as hell over the Year of Monica". According to the AP, "during the one-on-one meeting at the White House, which lasted more than an hour, Gore used uncommonly blunt language to tell Clinton that his sex scandal and low personal approval ratings were a hurdle he could not surmount in his campaign ... [with] the core of the dispute was Clinton's lies to Gore and the nation about his affair with White House intern Monica Lewinsky." [81] [82] [83] Clinton, however, was unconvinced by Gore's argument and insisted to Gore that he would have won the election if he had embraced the administration and its good economic record. [81] [82] [83]

Partial retraction from Starr

In January 2020, while testifying as a defense lawyer for U.S. President Donald Trump during his first Senate impeachment trial, Starr himself would retract some of the allegations he made to justify Clinton's impeachment. [84] Slate journalist Jeremy Stahl pointed out that as he was urging the Senate not to remove Trump as president, Starr contradicted various arguments he used in 1998 to justify Clinton's impeachment. [84] In defending Trump, Starr also claimed he was wrong to have called for impeachment against Clinton for abuse of executive privilege and efforts to obstruct Congress, and stated that the House Judiciary Committee was right in 1998 to have rejected one of the planks for impeachment he had advocated for. [84] He also invoked a 1999 Hofstra Law Review article by Yale law professor Akhil Amar, who argued that the Clinton impeachment proved just how impeachment and removal causes "grave disruption" to a national election. [84]

See also

Notes

  1. Prior to Bill Clinton, the only other U.S. president aside from Andrew Johnson to be the subject of formal House impeachment proceedings was Richard Nixon in 1973–74, but he resigned from the presidency on August 9, 1974, before the House voted on his impeachment. [2]
  2. A verdict used in Scots law. It was recorded as a "not guilty" vote.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bill Clinton</span> President of the United States from 1993 to 2001

William Jefferson Clinton is an American politician who served as the 42nd president of the United States from 1993 to 2001. A member of the Democratic Party, he previously served as Governor of Arkansas from 1979 to 1981 and again from 1983 to 1992. Clinton, whose policies reflected a centrist "Third Way" political philosophy, became known as a New Democrat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Monica Lewinsky</span> American activist and writer (born 1973)

Monica Samille Lewinsky is an American activist and writer. A former White House intern, Lewinsky gained international celebrity status in the late 1990s as a result of the public coverage of a political scandal when U.S. President Bill Clinton admitted to having an affair with her during her days as an intern between 1995 and 1997. The affair, and its repercussions, became known later as the Clinton–Lewinsky scandal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ken Starr</span> American lawyer (1946–2022)

Kenneth Winston Starr was an American lawyer and judge who as independent counsel authored the Starr Report, which served as the basis of the impeachment of Bill Clinton. He headed an investigation of members of the Clinton administration, known as the Whitewater controversy, from 1994 to 1998. Starr previously served as a federal appellate judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit from 1983 to 1989 and as the U.S. solicitor general from 1989 to 1993 during the presidency of George H. W. Bush.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clinton–Lewinsky scandal</span> 1998 American political sex scandal

The Clinton–Lewinsky scandal was a sex scandal involving Bill Clinton, the president of the United States, and Monica Lewinsky, a White House intern. Their sexual relationship began in 1995—when Clinton was 49 years old and Lewinsky was 22 years old—and lasted 18 months, ending in 1997. Clinton ended a televised speech in late January 1998 with the later infamous statement: "I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Ms. Lewinsky." Further investigation led to charges of perjury and to the impeachment of Clinton in 1998 by the U.S. House of Representatives. He was subsequently acquitted on all impeachment charges of perjury and obstruction of justice in a 21-day U.S. Senate trial.

<i>Starr Report</i>

The Starr Report, officially the Referral from Independent Counsel Kenneth W. Starr in Conformity with the Requirement of Title 28, United States Code, Section 595(c), is a United States federal government report by Independent Counsel Ken Starr concerning his investigation of President Bill Clinton. Delivered to the United States Congress on September 9, 1998, the allegations in the report led to the impeachment of Bill Clinton and the five-year suspension of Clinton's law license.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paula Jones</span> American civil servant

Paula Corbin Jones is an American civil servant. A former Arkansas state employee, Jones sued United States President Bill Clinton for sexual harassment in 1994. In the initial lawsuit, Jones cited Clinton for sexual harassment at the Excelsior Hotel in Little Rock, Arkansas on May 8, 1991. Following a series of civil suits and appeals through the U.S. District Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals from May 1994 to January 1996, Clinton v. Jones eventually reached the United States Supreme Court on May 27, 1997. The case was later settled on November 13, 1998.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alcee Hastings</span> American politician & judge (1936–2021)

Alcee Lamar Hastings was an American politician and former judge from the state of Florida. He was notable for having been impeached and removed from office as a judge for bribery and perjury.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Linda Tripp</span> American civil servant (1949–2020)

Linda Rose Tripp was an American civil servant who played a prominent role in the Clinton–Lewinsky scandal of 1998. Tripp's action in illegally and secretly recording Monica Lewinsky's confidential phone calls about her relationship with President Bill Clinton caused a sensation with their links to the earlier Clinton v. Jones lawsuit and with the disclosing of intimate details. Tripp claimed that her motives were purely patriotic, and she avoided a wiretap charge by agreeing to hand over the tapes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sidney Blumenthal</span> American political writer

Sidney Stone Blumenthal is an American journalist, political operative, and Lincoln scholar. A former aide to President Bill Clinton, he is a long-time confidant of Hillary Clinton and was formerly employed by the Clinton Foundation. As a journalist, Blumenthal wrote about American politics and foreign policy. He is also the author of a multivolume biography of Abraham Lincoln, The Political Life of Abraham Lincoln. Three books of the planned five-volume series have already been published: A Self-Made Man, Wrestling With His Angel, and All the Powers of Earth. Subsequent volumes were planned for later.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Betty Currie</span> American government official

Betty Grace Currie is an American government official who served as the personal secretary for Bill Clinton during his tenure as president of the United States. She became well known as a figure in the Lewinsky scandal for her alleged handling of gifts given to Monica Lewinsky by President Clinton.

Clinton v. Jones, 520 U.S. 681 (1997), was a landmark United States Supreme Court case establishing that a sitting President of the United States has no immunity from civil law litigation, in federal court, for acts done before taking office and unrelated to the office. In particular, there is no temporary immunity and thus no delay of federal cases until the President leaves office.

Former U.S. President Bill Clinton's public image is most notably characterized by high public approval ratings, aided by his youthful appearance, as well as his charismatic, and soundbite-ready style of speech. His personal background and lifestyle led to Nobel Prize-winning novelist Toni Morrison to call him the first "black president". Clinton was also dogged by investigations throughout his presidency, particularly of sexual misconduct, damaging the public's beliefs of his trustworthiness, though his approval ratings remained high, even as his impeachment trial continued.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1998 United States elections</span>

The 1998 United States elections were held on November 3, 1998, in the middle of Democratic President Bill Clinton's second term and during impeachment proceedings against the president as a result of the Clinton–Lewinsky scandal. Though Republicans retained control of both chambers of Congress, the elections were unusual because this is the first midterm since 1934 that the president's party gained seats in the House of Representatives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bill Clinton sexual assault and misconduct allegations</span> Accusations of sexual misconduct against Bill Clinton, 42nd President of the United States

Bill Clinton, the 42nd president of the United States (1993–2001), has been publicly accused of sexual assault and/or sexual misconduct by several women: Juanita Broaddrick accused Clinton of raping her in 1978; Leslie Millwee accused Clinton of sexually assaulting her in 1980; Paula Jones accused Clinton of exposing himself to her in 1991 as well as sexually harassing her; and Kathleen Willey accused Clinton of groping her without her consent in 1993. The Jones allegations became public in 1994, during Clinton's first term as president, while Willey's and Broaddrick's accusations became public in 1999, toward the end of Clinton's second term. Millwee made her accusations in 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impeachment trial of Bill Clinton</span> 1998 trial in the United States Senate

The impeachment trial of Bill Clinton, the 42nd president of the United States, began in the U.S. Senate on January 7, 1999, and concluded with his acquittal on February 12. After an inquiry between October and December 1998, President Clinton was impeached by the U.S. House of Representatives on December 19, 1998; the articles of impeachment charged him with perjury and obstruction of justice. It was the second impeachment trial of a U.S. president, preceded by that of Andrew Johnson.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First impeachment of Donald Trump</span> 2019 United States presidential impeachment

The first impeachment of President Donald Trump occurred on December 18, 2019. On that date, the House of Representatives adopted two articles of impeachment against Trump: abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. On February 5, 2020, the Senate voted to acquit Trump on both articles of impeachment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First impeachment trial of Donald Trump</span> 2020 trial in the US Senate

The first impeachment trial of Donald Trump, the 45th president of the United States, began in the U.S. Senate on January 16, 2020, and concluded with his acquittal on February 5. After an inquiry between September and November 2019, President Trump was impeached by the U.S. House of Representatives on December 18, 2019; the articles of impeachment charged him with abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. It was the third impeachment trial of a U.S. president, preceded by those of Andrew Johnson and of Bill Clinton.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impeachment inquiry into Bill Clinton</span> 1998 U.S. presidential impeachment inquiry

The impeachment inquiry against Bill Clinton, the 42nd president of the United States, was initiated by a vote of the United States House of Representatives on October 8, 1998, roughly a month after the release of the Starr Report. The United States House of Representatives, led by Republican Speaker Newt Gingrich, voted to authorize a broad impeachment inquiry against President Clinton. The inquiry was conducted by the House Committee on the Judiciary.

During his presidency, Bill Clinton, the 42nd president of the United States, saw multiple efforts to impeach him.

References

  1. Glass, Andrew (October 8, 2017). "House votes to impeach Clinton, Oct. 8, 1998". Politico . Archived from the original on September 28, 2020. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
  2. "House begins impeachment of Nixon". history.com. A&E Television Networks. February 26, 2019 [Published November 24, 2009]. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
  3. 1 2 3 Baker, Peter (February 13, 1999). "The Senate Acquits President Clinton". The Washington Post . The Washington Post Co. Archived from the original on November 10, 2013. Retrieved December 4, 2013.
  4. Riley, Russell L. (October 4, 2016). "Bill Clinton: Domestic Affairs". millercenter.org. Charlottesville, Virginia: The Miller Center, University of Virginia. Archived from the original on September 28, 2020. Retrieved October 3, 2019.
  5. "Clinton v. Jones Timeline". The Washington Post . July 4, 1997. Archived from the original on February 20, 2018. Retrieved December 15, 2019.
  6. "The Starr Report Narrative Pt. VII". The Washington Post . May 1997. Archived from the original on November 19, 2019. Retrieved December 15, 2019.
  7. 1 2 3 4 "Clinton impeachment timeline". The Guardian . November 18, 1998. Retrieved March 1, 2021.
  8. Pace, David (November 6, 1997). "17 in House seek probe to impeach president". Newspapers.com. The Record. Associated Press . Retrieved March 4, 2021.
  9. Starr, Kenneth. "The Starr Report Pt. XIV: The Deposition and Afterward". The Washington Post . Archived from the original on December 20, 2019. Retrieved December 18, 2019.
  10. "What Clinton Said". The Washington Post . September 2, 1998. Archived from the original on February 5, 2012. Retrieved May 5, 2010.
  11. "The Stained Blue Dress that Almost Lost a Presidency". University of Missouri-Kansas School of Law. Archived from the original on July 3, 2008. Retrieved July 10, 2008.
  12. Ross, Brian (March 19, 1998). "Hillary at White House on 'Stained Blue Dress' Day—Schules Reviewed by ABC Show Hillary May Have Been in the White House When the Fateful Act Was Committed". ABC News . Archived from the original on June 19, 2008. Retrieved July 10, 2008.
  13. Baker, Peter (November 14, 1998). "Clinton Settles Paula Jones Lawsuit for $850,000". The Washington Post . Archived from the original on September 29, 2011. Retrieved June 3, 2018.
  14. "Starr's report at a glance - September 11, 1998". www.cnn.com. CNN. AllPolitics. September 11, 1998. Retrieved March 1, 2021.
  15. "Explosive Starr report outlines case for impeachment - September 11, 1998". www.cnn.com. CNN. AllPolitics. September 11, 1998. Retrieved March 1, 2021.
  16. Erskine, Daniel H. (January 1, 2008). "The Trial of Queen Caroline and the Impeachment of President Clinton: Law As a Weapon for Political Reform". Washington University Global Studies Law Review. 7 (1): 1–33. ISSN   1546-6981. Archived from the original on September 28, 2020. Retrieved December 6, 2019.
  17. "Starr Report: Narrative". Nature of President Clinton's Relationship with Monica Lewinsky. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office. May 19, 2004. Archived from the original on December 3, 2000. Retrieved May 9, 2009.
  18. "Starr report puts Internet into overdrive". CNN. September 12, 1998. Archived from the original on September 13, 2007. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  19. "Report ends chapter of Clinton era". Chicago Tribune . March 7, 2002. Archived from the original on September 28, 2020. Retrieved January 13, 2020.
  20. "News leaks prompt lawyer to seek sanctions against Starr's Office". Thefreelibrary.com. Archived from the original on December 28, 2011. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  21. Palermo, Joseph A. (March 28, 2008). "The Starr Report: How To Impeach A President (Repeat)". HuffPost . Archived from the original on February 14, 2008. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  22. "President Clinton impeached". history.com. A&E Television Networks. January 13, 2021 [November 24, 2009]. Retrieved February 27, 2021.
  23. "House approves impeachment inquiry". CNN. October 8, 1998. Archived from the original on September 28, 2020. Retrieved December 5, 2019.
  24. Gibbs, Nancy; Duffy, Michael (November 16, 1998). "Fall Of The House Of Newt". Time . Archived from the original on August 21, 2010. Retrieved May 5, 2010.(subscription required)
  25. Tapper, Jake (March 9, 2007). "Gingrich Admits to Affair During Clinton Impeachment". ABC News . Archived from the original on March 1, 2012. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  26. "Special election set to replace Gingrich". Ocala Star-Banner. January 5, 1999. Archived from the original on January 14, 2021. Retrieved October 22, 2020 via Google News archive.
  27. 1 2 3 4 5 Kurtz, Howard, "Larry Flynt, Investigative Pornographer" Archived May 18, 2018, at the Wayback Machine , The Washington Post , December 19, 1998. Page C01. Retrieved 21-June-2010.
  28. Karl, Jonathan (December 19, 1998). "Livingston bows out of the speakership". All Politics. CNN. Associated Press. Archived from the original on March 13, 2007. Retrieved May 9, 2009.
  29. "Judiciary approves three articles of impeachment". CNN. December 11, 1998. Retrieved December 13, 2019.
  30. "Judiciary Committee wraps up case against Clinton". CNN. December 12, 1998. Retrieved December 13, 2019.
  31. 1 2 Miller, Lorraine C. (December 19, 1998). "Final vote results for roll call 543". Office of the Clerk. Archived from the original on January 6, 2010. Retrieved April 20, 2010.
  32. 1 2 Miller, Lorraine C. (December 19, 1998). "Final vote results for roll call 545". Office of the Clerk. Archived from the original on March 2, 2010. Retrieved April 20, 2010.
  33. 1 2 Miller, Lorraine C. (December 19, 1998). "Final vote results for roll call 544". Office of the Clerk. Archived from the original on March 2, 2010. Retrieved April 20, 2010.
  34. 1 2 Miller, Lorraine C. (December 19, 1998). "Final vote results for roll call 546". Office of the Clerk. Archived from the original on March 2, 2010. Retrieved April 20, 2010.
  35. Silverstein, Jason (November 15, 2019). "Impeached presidents: What have presidents been impeached for? Here are the articles for Bill Clinton, Richard Nixon and Andrew Johnson". CBS News . Retrieved December 5, 2019.
  36. Roos, David (November 1, 2019). "How Many US Presidents Have Faced Impeachment?". history.com. A&E Television Networks. Retrieved November 12, 2019.
  37. PD-icon.svg This article incorporates public domain material from Stephen W. Stathis and David C. Huckabee. Congressional Resolutions on Presidential Impeachment: A Historical Overview (PDF). Congressional Research Service . Retrieved December 23, 2019. – via University of North Texas Libraries, Digital Library, UNT Libraries Government Documents Department.
  38. "Roll Call 543 Roll Call 543, Bill Number: H. Res. 611, 105th Congress, 2nd Session". Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives. December 19, 1998. Retrieved June 22, 2023.
  39. "Roll Call 544 Roll Call 544, Bill Number: H. Res. 611, 105th Congress, 2nd Session". Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives. December 19, 1998. Retrieved June 22, 2023.
  40. "Roll Call 545 Roll Call 545, Bill Number: H. Res. 611, 105th Congress, 2nd Session". Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives. December 19, 1998. Retrieved June 22, 2023.
  41. "Roll Call 546 Roll Call 547, Bill Number: H. Res. 611, 105th Congress, 2nd Session". Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives. December 19, 1998. Retrieved June 22, 2023.
  42. 1 2 PD-icon.svg This article incorporates public domain material from A History of the Committee on the Judiciary 1813–2006, Section II–Jurisdictions History of the Judiciary Committee: Impeachment (PDF). United States House of Representatives . Retrieved December 23, 2019. (H. Doc. 109-153).
  43. Text of Article I Archived December 16, 2017, at the Wayback Machine Washington Post December 20, 1998
  44. Text of Article IIII Archived December 16, 2017, at the Wayback Machine Washington Post December 20, 1998
  45. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Wire, Sarah D. (January 16, 2020). "A look back at how Clinton's impeachment trial unfolded". Los Angeles Times . Retrieved February 27, 2021.
  46. "Prosecution Who's Who". The Washington Post . January 14, 1999. Retrieved February 28, 2021.
  47. Defense Who's Who Archived June 17, 2017, at the Wayback Machine , The Washington Post , January 19, 1999.
  48. "Senate's Unanimous Agreement on How to Proceed in Clinton Trial". The New York Times . Retrieved January 7, 2020.
  49. "S.Res.16 - A resolution to provide for the issuance of a summons and for related procedures concerning the articles of impeachment against William Jefferson Clinton, President of the United States". Library of Congress. January 8, 1999. Retrieved January 7, 2020.
  50. "White House Response to Trial Summons". The Washington Post . Archived from the original on August 17, 2000. Retrieved January 7, 2020.
  51. 1 2 3 4 "Impeachment: Bill Clinton". The History Place. 2000. Archived from the original on May 14, 2010. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
  52. "Senate Trial Transcripts". The Washington Post . 1999. Retrieved February 27, 2021.
  53. Swanson, Ian (January 28, 2020). "Senators ready for question time in impeachment trial". The Hill . Retrieved February 28, 2021.
  54. Clines, Francis X. (February 3, 1999). "THE PRESIDENT'S TRIAL: THE OVERVIEW; Senators See Lewinsky Tape And Vernon Jordan Testifies". The New York Times . Retrieved February 9, 2020.
  55. 1 2 "How the senators voted on impeachment". CNN. February 12, 1999. Retrieved June 8, 2019.
  56. 1 2 Riley, Russell L. (October 4, 2016). "Bill Clinton: Domestic Affairs". Charlottesville, Virginia: Miller Center of Public Affairs, University of Virginia. Archived from the original on September 28, 2020. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
  57. Specter, Arlen (February 12, 1999). "Senator Specter's closed-door impeachment statement". CNN. Archived from the original on June 14, 2008. Retrieved March 13, 2008. My position in the matter is that the case has not been proved. I have gone back to Scottish law where there are three verdicts: guilty, not guilty, and not proved. I am not prepared to say on this record that President Clinton is not guilty. But I am certainly not prepared to say that he is guilty. There are precedents for a Senator voting present. I hope that I will be accorded the opportunity to vote not proved in this case. ... But on this record, the proofs are not present. Juries in criminal cases under the laws of Scotland have three possible verdicts: guilty, not guilty, not proved. Given the option in this trial, I suspect that many Senators would choose 'not proved' instead of 'not guilty'.
    That is my verdict: not proved. The President has dodged perjury by calculated evasion and poor interrogation. Obstruction of justice fails by gaps in the proofs.
  58. "U.S. Senate: U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 106th Congress - 1st Session". www.senate.gov. United States Senate. Retrieved February 28, 2021.
  59. "U.S. Senate: U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 106th Congress - 1st Session". www.senate.gov. United States Senate. Retrieved February 28, 2021.
  60. 1 2 Clinton found in civil contempt for Jones testimony—April 12, 1999 Archived April 8, 2006, at the Wayback Machine
  61. "Mr. Clinton's Last Deal". The New York Times . January 20, 2001. Archived from the original on April 30, 2019. Retrieved May 15, 2019.
  62. Neal v. Clinton, Civ. No. 2000-5677 , Agreed Order of Discipline(Ark. Cir. Ct.January 19, 2001)("Mr. Clinton admits and acknowledges ... that his discovery responses interfered with the conduct of the Jones case by causing the court and counsel for the parties to expend unnecessary time, effort, and resources ...").
  63. In re Clinton, 534U.S.806 (2001).
  64. In re Clinton, 534U.S.1016 (2001).
  65. "Jones v. Clinton finally settled". CNN. November 13, 1998. Archived from the original on January 13, 2010. Retrieved January 16, 2009.
  66. "Clinton–Jones Settlement Text". CNN. November 13, 1998. Archived from the original on January 23, 2009. Retrieved January 13, 2009.
  67. Keating Holland. "A year after Clinton impeachment, public approval grows of House decision" Archived March 3, 2008, at the Wayback Machine . CNN. December 16, 1999.
  68. Broder, David S.; Morin, Richard (August 23, 1998). "American Voters See Two Very Different Bill Clintons". The Washington Post . p. A1. Archived from the original on November 22, 2017. Retrieved December 5, 2017.
  69. Arotsky, Deborah (May 7, 2004). "Singer authors book on the role of ethics in Bush presidency". The Daily Princetonian . Archived from the original on September 30, 2007.
  70. Sachs, Stephen E. (November 7, 2000). "Of Candidates and Character". The Harvard Crimson . Archived from the original on December 31, 2006. Retrieved April 1, 2007.
  71. Bishin, B. G.; Stevens, D.; Wilson, C. (Summer 2006). "Character Counts?: Honesty and Fairness in Election 2000". Public Opinion Quarterly. 70 (2): 235–48. doi:10.1093/poq/nfj016. S2CID   145608174.
  72. 1 2 3 4 Fiorina, M.; Abrams, S.; Pope, J. (March 2003). "The 2000 U.S. Presidential Election: Can Retrospective Voting Be Saved?" (PDF). British Journal of Political Science. Cambridge University Press. 33 (2): 163–87. doi:10.1017/S0007123403000073. S2CID   154669354. Archived (PDF) from the original on April 7, 2008. Retrieved March 31, 2008.
  73. Weiner, Todd J. (May 15, 2004). "Blueprint for Victory". America's Future Foundation. Archived from the original on April 2, 2015. Retrieved March 12, 2015.
  74. "S/R 25: Gore's Defeat: Don't Blame Nader (Marable)". Greens.org. Archived from the original on May 10, 2011. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  75. Weisberg, Jacob (November 8, 2000). "Why Gore (Probably) Lost". Slate. Archived from the original on May 11, 2011. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  76. "An anatomy of 2000 USA presidential election". Nigerdeltacongress.com. Archived from the original on May 16, 2011. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  77. "Beyond the Recounts: Trends in the 2000 U.S. Presidential Election". Cairn.info. November 12, 2000. Archived from the original on May 10, 2011. Retrieved May 23, 2011.
  78. Ripley, Amanda (November 20, 2000). "Election 2000: Tom Daschle, Senate Minority Leader: Partisan from the Prairie". Time . Archived from the original on November 22, 2010. Retrieved May 5, 2010.
  79. Schmitt, Eric (November 9, 2000). "THE 2000 Elections: The Senate; Democrats Gain Several Senate Seats, but Republicans Retain Control". The New York Times . Archived from the original on May 18, 2013. Retrieved May 5, 2010.
  80. "The Crist Switch: Top 10 Political Defections". Time . April 29, 2009. Archived from the original on May 3, 2010. Retrieved May 5, 2010.
  81. 1 2 Carlson, Margaret (February 11, 2001). "When a Buddy Movie Goes Bad". Time . Archived from the original on June 4, 2008. Retrieved March 31, 2008.
  82. 1 2 "Clinton and Gore have it out". Associated Press. February 8, 2001. Archived from the original on April 2, 2015.
  83. 1 2 Harris, John F. (February 7, 2001). "Blame divides Gore, Clinton". The Washington Post . Archived from the original on April 2, 2015. Retrieved March 16, 2015.
  84. 1 2 3 4 Stahl, Jeremy (January 27, 2020). "Ken Starr Argues There Are Too Many Impeachments These Days". Slate . Retrieved October 29, 2020.